The poor and vulnerable are exploited in many ways all over the world. This piece[1] suggests such example in relation to medical research.However, Dr Singh does not tell us whether this particular research project had been 'ethically approved' by any relevant authority in India or research subjects are paid and indemnified against any adversity. Until such specific information is available, I think it is unwise to prejudge the ethical and moral issues in relation to this "groundbreaking" research project [1].
However, if the ethical and legal standards applicable to a UK research cohort are not even vaguely followed in India (in this particular case) and/or if there's evidence of blatant disregard for the health & welfare of people concerned,then those who're involved must be answerable. Perhaps, Dr Singh could carry out a more intensive investigation into the concerns he has expressed and report his findings in a future issue.
References
[1]Rashmi R Singh.
Guinea pigs for the "developed" countries
BMJ 2010; 340: c868
Rapid Response:
Research Dilemmas and Exploitation
The poor and vulnerable are exploited in many ways all over the world. This piece[1] suggests such example in relation to medical research.However, Dr Singh does not tell us whether this particular research project had been 'ethically approved' by any relevant authority in India or research subjects are paid and indemnified against any adversity. Until such specific information is available, I think it is unwise to prejudge the ethical and moral issues in relation to this "groundbreaking" research project [1].
However, if the ethical and legal standards applicable to a UK research cohort are not even vaguely followed in India (in this particular case) and/or if there's evidence of blatant disregard for the health & welfare of people concerned,then those who're involved must be answerable. Perhaps, Dr Singh could carry out a more intensive investigation into the concerns he has expressed and report his findings in a future issue.
References
[1]Rashmi R Singh.
Guinea pigs for the "developed" countries
BMJ 2010; 340: c868
Competing interests:
None declared
Competing interests: No competing interests