The BMJ is a medical journal which should only be expected to comment
on political issues that are medically relevant, such as health care. The
Palestinian dimension of the Arab -Israeli conflict is a political issue
of which the call for a boycott of Israeli academic institutions icluding
the Israel Medical Association is a part. By uniquely selecting this
political issue for discussion even in a seemingly neutral manner, the BMJ
is entering a political arena. It is also conferring legitimacy on a
disgraceful campaign which has been condemned by the vast majority of UK
academics. Furthermore, by presenting the issue in this format, the BMJ
has effectively put Israel on trial.
Rapid Response:
Selected for trial on a political issue
The BMJ is a medical journal which should only be expected to comment
on political issues that are medically relevant, such as health care. The
Palestinian dimension of the Arab -Israeli conflict is a political issue
of which the call for a boycott of Israeli academic institutions icluding
the Israel Medical Association is a part. By uniquely selecting this
political issue for discussion even in a seemingly neutral manner, the BMJ
is entering a political arena. It is also conferring legitimacy on a
disgraceful campaign which has been condemned by the vast majority of UK
academics. Furthermore, by presenting the issue in this format, the BMJ
has effectively put Israel on trial.
Competing interests:
None declared
Competing interests: No competing interests