Intended for healthcare professionals

CCBYNC Open access
Opinion Self-Care Interventions for Sexual and Reproductive Health Rights

“Two eyed seeing”—embracing both Indigenous and western perspectives in healthcare

BMJ 2023; 383 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.p2614 (Published 13 November 2023) Cite this as: BMJ 2023;383:p2614

Self care interventions for sexual and reproductive health and rights

Click here to read the complete collection

  1. Nel Wieman, acting chief medical officer,
  2. Unjali Malhotra, medical officer, women’s health
  1. First Nations Health Authority, British Columbia, Canada
  1. Correspondence to: U Malhotra Unjali.malhotra{at}fnha.ca

Nel Wieman and Unjali Malhotra call for a “two eyed seeing” approach to healthcare, informed by both Indigenous and biomedical knowledge

In Canada, genocidal policies and systems have devastated Indigenous peoples’ determinants of health.1 For example, as a consequence of the Indian Reserve System many Indigenous peoples live in isolated areas with limited or no access to healthcare, education, or employment opportunities.2 Furthermore, the colonial legacy of anti-Indigenous racism is prevalent across Canada, including its healthcare systems, so many Indigenous people fear accessing healthcare services.34

One way to make healthcare more equitable and effective for Indigenous peoples is to incorporate their knowledge, beliefs, values, practices, medicines, and models of health and healing alongside those of western medicine in delivering healthcare. Known as “two eyed seeing,” this approach to healthcare sees from one eye with the strengths of Indigenous knowledge and ways of knowing, and from the other eye with the strengths of western knowledge, respectfully embracing both.5 Two eyed seeing acknowledges that Indigenous methods and treatments are as valid as those used in mainstream medicine, and it allows Indigenous peoples to be partners in their own healthcare (video 1).

Video 1

Ways of being: supporting self-care

Communities, Alliances & Networks

At the First Nations Health Authority (FNHA) we advocate for and use the two eyed seeing approach in our work to improve healthcare programmes, services, and health outcomes for First Nations people in the province of British Columbia.6 First Nations are one of three groups of Indigenous peoples in Canada.7 The FNHA is the first health authority of its kind in Canada and serves as a model for the other provinces.8

“Culture is medicine”

We promote and support Indigenous cultural practices and activities in our programmes and services, as we believe that they are integral to the self-care and health of Indigenous peoples and are “good medicine.” In fact, common sayings among Indigenous peoples include “culture saves lives,” “culture is medicine,” and “ceremony is medicine.”

We also regularly provide wellness grants9 to communities to support Indigenous cultural practices and activities, which include the harvesting, preparation, and use of traditional medicines and talking circles (also known as sharing or healing circles).10 Talking circles incorporate different practices and ceremonies, including storytelling, traditional songs, dance, and drumming, as well as smudging (burning of herbs and grass), sweat lodges, and cold water baths. Traditional land and water based activities are also practised, including fishing, hunting, harvesting, and eating traditional foods.

We have found that incorporating these practices into healthcare services and programmes for Indigenous people, and promoting or prescribing them for the purpose of self-care, helps improve Indigenous peoples’ health outcomes. For example, at FNHA funded overdose prevention sites,11 physicians work alongside trained First Nations elders (traditional teachers or knowledge keepers) who lead talking circles,12 share teachings, or provide counselling, smudges, and sweats.

Indigenous clients have reported that the two eyed seeing approach has greatly helped with their healing journeys by giving them a much needed sense of belonging and reconnecting them with Indigenous culture. Many were forcibly disconnected from their families, communities, and cultures by genocidal policies and systems such as the Indian Residential School System and the Sixties Scoop,1314 and they were subjected to severe racism and discrimination. Being able to access safe spaces that uphold a holistic model of care allows Indigenous people to better navigate these traumatic experiences and the intergenerational trauma that comes with having parents who were abused.15

Our “Healing Indigenous Hearts” support groups for people whose loved ones have died because of the toxic drug poisoning crisis are also conducted as sharing circles, where trained facilitators are encouraged to incorporate Indigenous knowledge and medicines alongside western models of grief support.16

Building trust through conversations

When we wanted to bring self-screening for human papillomavirus (HPV) into a First Nations community to make cervical smears more accessible, we co-hosted a talking circle to explain what we were doing and to ask for permission. This was an important project, as many First Nations women live in isolated communities and have had traumatic experiences with the healthcare system, including forced and coerced sterilisation.17 Because of this they are screened for HPV at much lower rates than non-Indigenous women, resulting in higher cervical cancer rates and poorer health outcomes.18 Community members who participated said that they felt empowered and respected by the talking circle, and this approach built their trust in healthcare providers and the self-screening programme.

Indigenous peoples have a strong oral tradition, so we respectfully listen to what they share and to their calls for change. For example, in the HPV project we had conversations with women in the community who had experienced forced and coerced sterilisation, documenting their stories. In response to their accounts, and because informed consent in healthcare is an ongoing priority, we co-developed a revised consent form and processes.19 These can also be used in conversations with patients about informed consent for contraception.

Under the guidance of an elder, the FNHA also works with First Nations families and midwives to reclaim birthing ceremonies and the tradition of midwifery. These practices were dismissed under a maternal medical evacuation policy—issued in 1892 and still in effect—that required women to leave their communities and give birth in urban healthcare facilities.20 We have supported a ceremonial lodge where elders perform a pre-birthing ceremony with the pregnant woman and her family that includes drumming and songs in traditional languages. Babies born in the community have been greeted with protocols such as elders being the first to talk to them in their own language, and they are welcomed with ceremonial songs, dances, and prayers from community members.

Indigenous peoples’ cultures, lived experiences, protocols, practices, and beliefs can no longer be ignored or set aside within the health system. Healthcare providers who are more aware of and accepting of a “two eyed seeing” or similar approach will be better placed to provide culturally safe and effective care for their Indigenous patients. By learning about, respecting, and accepting other cultures’ ways of approaching health in addition to western medical models, the healthcare community could better respond to Indigenous people’s understandings of health and self-care needs.

Footnotes

  • This article is part of a collection proposed by the UNDP/UNFPA/Unicef/WHO/World Bank Special Programme for Human Reproduction (HRP), which also provided funding for the collection, including open access fees. The BMJ commissioned, peer reviewed, edited, and made the decision to publish these articles. The lead editors for the collection were Paul Simpson and Rachael Hinton.

  • Provenance and peer review: commissioned, not externally peer reviewed.

  • Competing interests: none declared.

http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.

References