Covid is on the rise again—so what next?
BMJ 2023; 382 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.p1885 (Published 15 August 2023) Cite this as: BMJ 2023;382:p1885- Christina Pagel, professor of operational research
There are very few ways now to track the prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 in England since the end of wastewater monitoring in March 2022, the end of the Office for National Statistics Covid-19 Infection Survey in March 2023, and the gradual reduction of SARS-CoV-2 testing in hospitals since August 2022.123 However, all indications are that prevalence reached its lowest level this June/July since the summer of 2020. Weekly deaths with covid on the death certificate from that period are at the lowest recorded level since the start of the pandemic.4
But since the start of July 2023, daily hospital admissions with covid have been increasing (more than doubled as at 4 August compared to four weeks earlier), and the number of patients in hospital primarily because of covid has also doubled in that time.56 Secondary indicators such as the Zoe Symptom Tracker app and Google Trends of searches for covid-19 symptoms have also been increasing since early July.78 So it is reasonably certain that we have entered another covid-19 wave. But what are the implications?
While 2022 saw three enormous covid-19 waves by August, driven by different Omicron variants (BA.1 in January, BA.2 in March, and BA.5 in July, peaks 6-8% prevalence9), followed by two more waves in October and December, 2023 has been quieter so far. January saw high prevalence from the winter 2022/2023 wave (peak 4% prevalence) and a smaller wave in March 2023 (likely about 3% peak prevalence), but little else until now.1011 In the absence of any mitigations, this is likely because the variants since BA.5 (mostly BQ and XBB strains) have not been sufficiently different to drive very large waves in the presence of a highly vaccinated and highly previously infected population.
The variants currently increasing in the UK are still XBB Omicron substrains, and on their own there is no reason to think they will cause a large wave.12 However almost all under 50s have not had a vaccine dose for 18 months, and most under 75s not for a year.13 Protection from previous infection will also be waning in the absence of a large wave for several months. It is thus likely that this wave is hitting a more susceptible population than the last few, and this might be enough to drive a large wave this September when coupled with return to school and work and more time spent inside, where the virus spreads most easily.
Given protection from vaccines and past infection, it is unlikely that this wave will cause a large surge in hospital admissions or deaths. However, any increase in hospital burden is bad news, given record waiting lists for diagnosis and treatment and persistently high waits in hospitals for admission.14 Infection is also not harmless simply because it’s causing fewer hospital admissions—long covid remains an ongoing significant problem, damaging people’s lives (e.g. through persistent fatigue or brain fog), as well as taking them out of the workforce.1516
There are two major concerns. The first seems, unfortunately, quite plausible—a repeat of last winter’s unprecedented NHS crisis of covid, flu, and respiratory syncytial virus hit all around the same time, especially with 50-65 year olds now not being offered either the flu or covid vaccine this autumn.17
The second is less likely but would have a bigger impact—another Omicron like event where a new variant emerges, very different from previous strains so that our hard won protection is much less protective. Given few, if any, mitigations worldwide and much lower surveillance, such a variant could spread a long way before we realised it was a problem.
The resulting covid wave in the UK winter from such an event could cause major difficulties for the NHS and cause widespread workplace disruption if significant numbers of people are off work ill. Earlier this year, experts put the chance of this happening at about 20% within two years.18 The current growing variant in the UK (EG.5.1 or “Eris”) is not that variant.19 However, the last couple of days have seen a new, as yet unnamed, variant show up in Israel and Denmark which has caught the attention of many experts because it has so many new mutations, some long associated with increased fitness and immune escape, and others entirely new.2021 So far, we have only three sequences although geographic spread means community transmission has occurred. It is still quite possible that this fizzles out—either because its hosts don’t happen to infect anyone or because, despite its novelty, it does not outcompete the current dominant XBB strains. However, this should act as a reminder that without ramping up surveillance, and in the face of waning immunity, we are travelling into winter more vulnerable and with blinkers on.
Footnotes
Competing interests: CP is a member of Independent SAGE.
Provenance and peer review: commissioned, not externally peer reviewed.