The use of human donor milk
BMJ 2020; 371 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m4243 (Published 17 November 2020) Cite this as: BMJ 2020;371:m4243
- Hoang Thi Tran, neonatologist1,
- Tuan T Nguyen, medical doctor and researcher in paediatric nutrition2,
- Roger Mathisen, registered clinical nutritionist and dietitian2
- 1Da Nang Hospital for Women and Children, Da Nang, Vietnam
- 2Alive & Thrive Southeast Asia, FHI 360, Hanoi, Vietnam
- Correspondence to: T T Nguyen tnguyen{at}fhi360.org
What you need to know
When a mother’s own milk is unavailable for preterm or low birthweight infants, pasteurised donor milk protects against necrotising enterocolitis compared with formula milk
Pasteurised donor milk can also be used to supplement the mother’s own milk in order to meet an infant’s nutritional needs and can be administered in the same ways as the mother’s own expressed milk
The only absolute contraindication to the use of pasteurised donor milk is galactosaemia. Mothers with active pulmonary tuberculosis or herpes simplex lesions on the breast should be encouraged to feed expressed breast milk, while mothers with covid-19 should be advised to continue breastfeeding
A 25 year old woman gave birth to her first child prematurely, at 27 weeks gestation, at Da Nang Hospital for Women and Children, in central Vietnam. The male infant weighed 980 grams and required continuous positive airway pressure respiratory support in the neonatal intensive care unit. Neonatal care nurses provided breastfeeding counselling and support to the mother, and the infant received mother’s own milk as well as pasteurised donor milk in the first four days of life. From the fifth day of life, the mother was able to produce enough breast milk to meet her son’s nutritional needs. During the hospital stay, the neonatal nurses encouraged the mother to breastfeed, store breast milk for her son, and donate her surplus breast milk to the human milk bank. She became a breast milk donor when her son was 45 days old and still hospitalised. The mother continued donating breast milk once she returned home, ultimately donating 62 L of breast milk over five months. The mother was proud to be a breast milk donor to newborns in need.
In line with global recommendations from the World Health Organization (WHO), the UK National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and other national infant feeding guidelines emphasise that breast milk is the best nutrition for infants, and infants should be exclusively breastfed in the first 6 months of life.12 Indeed, high quality trials and meta-analyses show that breastfeeding is associated with reduced child mortality from diarrhoea and pneumonia and reduced risk for childhood obesity and diabetes,3 as well as economic savings.4 However, some infants do not have access to their biological mother’s milk for a range of reasons. Historically, wet nursing and animal milks were used to feed these infants.5 Innovation in infant bottles, advances in hygiene, and the invention of formula milks over the 19th century greatly expanded artificial infant feeding, and breastfeeding rates declined globally in response to greater availability and marketing of infant formula milk.5 Since 1979, however, WHO and Unicef have recommended the use of pasteurised human milk from a human milk bank to feed low birthweight and preterm infants as the first alternative when mothers are unable to provide their own milk.6
What is the rationale for using human donor milk?
Pasteurised donor milk provides the nutritional and immunologic benefits of breast milk and reduces infectious complications in preterm or low birthweight infants compared with formula milk. In a systematic review, the use of pasteurised donor milk was associated with a 46% reduction in the incidence of necrotising enterocolitis compared with infant formula (term or preterm) in preterm or low birthweight infants.7 Pasteurised human breast milk has also been associated with a 19% reduction in the odds of developing sepsis for every 10 mL/kg consumed each day in the first 28 days of life in very low birthweight infants compared with infant formula.8 Among preterm infants who receive some of their mother’s own milk, those who were supplemented with donor human milk had a 22% lower incidence of bronchopulmonary dysplasia and required almost three fewer days of ventilator support than preterm infants who were supplemented with preterm formula.9
The use of donor breast milk and presence of a human milk bank are also associated with higher rates of breastfeeding beyond delivery, even for infants who are admitted to neonatal intensive care units.910 In a study of 83 neonatal intensive care units in Italy, for example, the prevalence of exclusive breastfeeding at discharge was 14 percentage points higher in the units with a human milk bank than in those without.11 And, in the US, a small study of 122 infants hospitalised for the treatment of hypoglycaemia, hyperbilirubinemia, and >8% weight loss at 40 hours of life found that newborns who received donor breast milk had five times greater odds of exclusive breastfeeding at 6 months old compared with those who received formula.12
What is a human milk bank?
A human milk bank is a service that recruits breast milk donors; collects, pasteurises, and stores donor milk; tests the milk for bacterial contamination; and then distributes donor milk to recipient infants and families.13 Human milk donors are typically healthy breastfeeding postpartum women with a surplus of milk who volunteer to donate milk.13 Pasteurisation essentially eliminates the risk of toxic, bacterial, or viral (including HIV and SARS-CoV-2) contamination while maintaining the nutritious and immunologic qualities of breast milk.131415
The global human milk bank network expanded from less than 10 in 1979 to 700 human milk banks in more than 60 countries in 2020.1316 The demand for donor milk from even new milk banks can be high. For example, in its first two years of operation, the first human milk bank in Vietnam at Da Nang Hospital for Women and Children—a facility with about 15 000 births each year—collected 4400 L of milk from 315 donors and distributed more than 3000 L of pasteurised human milk to 8100 babies.17 In Brazil in 2019, a network of 224 human milk banks collected 223 000 L of milk from 189 000 donors and distributed 192 000 L of pasteurised human milk to 215 000 babies.18
When should pasteurised donor milk be recommended?
If a mother’s own milk is not available, breastfeeding is contraindicated, or an infant’s mother is unable to provide sufficient quantities of her own breast milk after being provided with lactation support, pasteurised donor milk is indicated as a first alternative for any infant (box 1).2131925 Infants with severe medical conditions, premature infants, or very low birthweight babies (<1500 g) are prioritised when demand for donor milk exceeds supply.21319 Parental consent is typically required before the use of donor milk in most human milk banks, including those from Brazil, France, India, and North America.13
Common indications for use of pasteurised donor milk1319
Mother is absent due to separation, sickness, death, or abandonment1319
Mothers infected with HIV (in specific contexts), human T cell lymphotropic virus type I or II, untreated brucellosis, Ebola virus disease, or breast cancer with double mastectomy2021
Mothers who require medications that are contraindicated in breastfeeding such as amiodarone, chemotherapeutic or antineoplastic agents, chloramphenicol, ergotamine, gold salts, phenindione, radioactive pharmaceuticals, retinoids, tetracyclines (use for more than 3 weeks), and certain psychotropic medications222324
Mothers who use phencyclidine, cocaine, and cannabis may be candidates out of concern for long term neurobehavioral development in the infant222324
Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) couples, adoptive or other parents without lactating capacity1319
Mothers who do not have enough breast milk during the first days after birth despite lactation support1319
Are there any contraindications to pasteurised donor milk?
The only absolute contraindication to the use of pasteurised donor milk is classic galactosaemia, a rare congenital disorder of galactose metabolism (the sugar is found in breast milk and in normal formula).20 Expressed mother’s own milk is recommended for infants born to mothers with active, untreated pulmonary tuberculosis diagnosed before or after delivery, herpes simplex lesions on the breast, varicella from five days before through to two days after delivery, or H1N1 influenza.2226 Both WHO and the US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention recommended that mothers infected with SARS-CoV-2 should continue breastfeeding while using infection control practices such as handwashing and wearing a face mask to limit the risk of infecting their infant.2728
Is pasteurised donor milk recommended for infants of women infected with HIV?
Countries typically use or adapt guidelines on HIV infection and infant feeding from WHO,21 the American Academy of Paediatrics,22 and other organisations such as the British HIV Association.29 In high income countries such as the US and UK, mothers living with HIV regardless of maternal viral load and antiretroviral therapy are recommended not to breastfeed their children. Thus, pasteurised donor milk or infant formula is recommended.2229 In other settings, where clean water supply is insecure or human milk banks are not operational, WHO and Unicef recommend that women known to be infected with HIV and whose infants are not infected or of unknown HIV status exclusively breastfeed their infants for the first 6 months of life, introducing appropriate complementary foods thereafter, and continue to breastfeed for at least 12 months.21 We recommend that clinicians engage HIV-positive women in early discussions of risks and benefits of various infant feeding modalities in line with local guidelines.
How to feed pasteurised donor milk to infants
Pasteurised donor milk needs to be defrosted before use (box 2). Like any expressed breast milk, pasteurised donor milk can be fed by health staff or family members by means of cup, spoon, via small tubes that the infant suckles along with a nipple, or via gastric tubes, and should be given according to clinical guidelines.13 The required volume of donor milk is based on the newborn’s age, gestational age, and weight, as well as tolerance of feeding and weight gain (such as 15-20 g/kg/day) and represents the difference between recommended fluid intake and the available quantity of mother’s own milk (and transfused parenteral nutrition, if applicable). The recommended amount of fluid intake (table 1)30 is distributed across the number of feeds each day (such as 1-3 hourly feeds).2530 Decisions about the need for ongoing human donor milk are regularly reviewed, taking into account infant growth, fluid balance, and nutritional requirements.2530
How to prepare frozen pasteurised donor milk for feeding11325
Defrost donor milk containers slowly over 24 hours in a refrigerator at 4°C (with care to prevent the milk from reaching 8°C to prevent growth of microorganisms)
For urgent, exceptional cases, containers can be defrosted at room temperature or (less preferable) under warm water
Milk defrosted in the refrigerator should be used within 24 hours
Milk that underwent quick defrosting should be used right away and should not be re-refrigerated
Recommended fluid intake (mL/kg/day) during the first 30 days of life in preterm, low birthweight neonates30
Encourage mothers of infants in a neonatal intensive care unit to express breast milk as soon as they can.19 Once infants can coordinate sucking, swallowing, and breathing (around 32-34 gestational weeks), mothers can trial direct breastfeeding.31 In cases where mothers are unable to breastfeed, pasteurised donor milk can be provided beyond hospital discharge.
Use of donor milk complements other strategies to support breastfeeding
Pasteurised donor milk can and should be provided simultaneously with other measures to promote breastfeeding and newborn health in the immediate postpartum period, including skin-to-skin for healthy newborns and “kangaroo mother care” (prolonged skin-to-skin contact provided by mother or family members) for low birthweight or preterm infants in a stable condition.32 Although evidence supports the use of pasteurised donor milk in high and low income settings, and human milk banks are growing in number, the major limitations are the operating cost and, in some settings, societal norms relating to milk sharing.1733
Human donor milk recipient story
A 32 year old mother gave birth vaginally to her third child at 32 weeks gestation, weighing 1800 g, in a provincial hospital in the Central Highlands of Vietnam. He was diagnosed with respiratory distress and received continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) for 15 days. Antibiotics and prolonged parenteral fluid were given with no enteral feeding. The mother was separated from her son except for some daily visits, as per routine practice in that hospital for babies requiring respiratory support. On day of life 20, he was given some millilitres of his mother’s milk, but did not tolerate this feed.
He was transferred to Da Nang Hospital for Women and Children at 23 days of life to undergo evaluation for suspected intestinal obstruction. Once intestinal obstruction was ruled out, the baby was transitioned from parenteral nutrition to gradually increasing volumes of pasteurised donor milk through nasogastric tubes as his mother did not have breast milk. The mother was supported to provide kangaroo mother care, and she also received psychological and lactation support. She was able to re-initiate milk production, and her baby breastfed directly at 30 days of life. He was discharged home at 40 days of life to continue breastfeeding with pasteurised donor milk supplementation.
His mother continued breastfeeding and, by 65 days of life, was able to meet the full nutritional needs of her son with her own breast milk. She felt happy that she was able to breastfeed her son and saved about 2.5 million Vietnamese Dong (~US$110) per month, which is more than half of the parent’s income, by avoiding the use of infant formula.
How this article was made
This article was created using a combination of guidelines and expert advice (both neonatologists and general practitioners) and established literature (through Medline and Google Scholar literature searches up to August 2020 on “human milk bank, breastfeeding, preterm, and low birth weight.”
Education into practice
Are you familiar with your nearest human milk bank?
Can you think of infants in your practice who might have benefitted from pasteurised donor milk?
How could health staff maximise the benefits of a human milk bank?
How patients were involved in the creation of this article
The patient stories, from one donor and one recipient, were selected from a pool of case studies routinely collected by the Human Milk Bank in Da Nang Hospital for Women and Children. These stories show the importance of pasteurised donor milk for sick and small babies, helping mothers to feed their babies exclusively with human breast milk and maintain lactation during hospital stay, at discharge, and beyond.
Acknowledgments
We thank Amy Weissman from FHI 360 Asia Pacific Regional Office, Mackenzie Mayo from Alive and Thrive Headquarters, and reviewers and editors from The BMJ for their comments and suggestions to improve this manuscript.
Footnotes
Contributors: All authors conceptualised the study, drafted and revised the manuscript, and read and approved the final manuscript. HTT and TTN acquired relevant data; and HTT collected the case studies.
Funding: Staff time to write this manuscript was covered by the Da Nang Hospital for Women and Children (HTT) and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (Grant No OPP50838) and Irish Aid to Alive and Thrive/FHI 360 (TTN, RM).
Competing interests: We have read and understood BMJ policy on declaration of interests and have no relevant interests to declare.
Provenance and peer review: Commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Dissemination: The information will be disseminated to ministries of health, medical schools, professional medical associations, major maternity and paediatric hospitals, and other Alive and Thrive partners in South and South-east Asia and East and West Africa. We will also disseminate the information within global and regional networks focusing on human milk bank services and neonatal health.
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt and build upon this work, for commercial use, provided the original work is properly cited. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.