Covid-19: Risk of second wave is very real, say researchersBMJ 2020; 369 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m2294 (Published 09 June 2020) Cite this as: BMJ 2020;369:m2294
Lockdown measures may have averted 3.1 million deaths from covid-19 across 11 European countries, including 470 000 in the UK, a new modelling study indicates.1
However, the researchers warn that European countries are very far from achieving herd immunity, as less than 4% of their populations were infected with SARS-CoV-2 up to 4 May, when lockdowns started to be lifted. The estimated proportion of the total population infected varies between the countries from less than 1% in Norway, Germany, and Austria to 8% in Belgium (box 1).
Covid-19 infection rate in 11 European countries
Percentage of total population infected (95% credible interval) up to 4 May
Austria—0.76% (0.59% to 0.98%)
Belgium—8% (6.1% to 11%)
Denmark—1.0% (0.81 to 1.4%)
France—3.4% (2.7% to 4.3%)
Germany—0.85% (0.66% to 1.1%)
Italy—4.6% (3.6% to 5.8%)
Norway—0.46% (0.34% to 0.61%)
Spain—5.5% (4.4% to 7%)
Sweden—3.7% (2.8% to 5.1%)
Switzerland—1.9% (1.5% to 2.4%)
UK—5.1% (4% to 6.5%)
Seth Flaxman, a study author from the Department of Mathematics at Imperial College London, told a press briefing: “We are very far from herd immunity. The risk of a second wave if all interventions are abandoned is very real.” He added, “We are only at the beginning of this epidemic, and claims that it’s all over can be firmly rejected.”
The research, published in Nature, estimated that between 12 million and 15 million people were infected with covid-19 in Austria, Belgium, the UK, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, Norway, Spain, Sweden, and Switzerland up to the beginning of May.
Between 2 and 29 March European countries began implementing non-pharmaceutical interventions to control the covid-19 epidemic. These varied between countries but included social distancing, banning large gatherings, closing schools, and stopping all but essential travel. The study points out that most interventions were implemented in rapid succession in many countries and so it is difficult to disentangle the individual effect sizes of each intervention.
The model found that lockdown measures had successfully reduced the reproduction number (R value) to less than 1 in all the countries studied, ranging from a mean of 0.44 for Norway to 0.82 for Belgium. The average R value across the 11 countries was 0.66, an 82% reduction from the figure before the lockdowns.
Study author Samir Bhatt, from the faculty of medicine at Imperial College London, said, “Lockdown has had a really dramatic effect on reducing the rate of transmission, and without it there would have been many more deaths from covid-19.”
A second study, also published in Nature, estimated that lockdown policies implemented in China, South Korea, Italy, Iran, France, and the US prevented or delayed around 530 million covid-19 infections.2
The US researchers estimated that without anti-contagion policies in place, early rates of SARS-CoV-2 infection grew by 68% a day in Iran and an average of 38% a day across the other five countries. Using econometric modelling normally used in assessing economic policies, they found that lockdown measures significantly and substantially slowed this infection rate.
This article is made freely available for use in accordance with BMJ's website terms and conditions for the duration of the covid-19 pandemic or until otherwise determined by BMJ. You may use, download and print the article for any lawful, non-commercial purpose (including text and data mining) provided that all copyright notices and trade marks are retained.https://bmj.com/coronavirus/usage