Transforming the food system to fight non-communicable diseasesBMJ 2019; 364 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l296 (Published 28 January 2019) Cite this as: BMJ 2019;364:l296
- Francesco Branca, director1,
- Anna Lartey, director2,
- Stineke Oenema, global coordinator3,
- Victor Aguayo, director of nutrition4,
- Gunhild A Stordalen, founder and executive chair5,
- Ruth Richardson, executive director6,
- Mario Arvelo, chair7,
- Ashkan Afshin, assistant professor of health metrics sciences8
- 1Department of Nutrition for Health and Development, WHO, Switzerland
- 2Nutrition and Food Systems Division, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Italy
- 3United Nations System Standing Committee on Nutrition secretariat, Italy
- 4UNICEF Programme Division, USA
- 5EAT, Norway
- 6Global Alliance for the Future of Food, Canada
- 7Committee on World Food Security, Italy
- 8Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, USA
- Correspondence to: F Branca
Cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, cancers, and diabetes are responsible for 71% of global deaths (41 million) each year.1 Around 85% of premature deaths from non-communicable diseases (NCDs) now occur in low and middle income countries,2 where people also bear the greater burden of undernutrition and infectious disease.1 In wealthier countries, NCDs disproportionately affect vulnerable and disadvantaged groups.2
Malnutrition is a key risk factor for NCDs.3 Globally, nearly one in three people has at least one form of malnutrition,4 and this will reach one in two by 2025, based on current trends.5 Malnutrition includes nutritional disorders caused by deficient intake of energy or nutrients, such as stunting, wasting, and micronutrient deficiencies. It also includes excessive and imbalanced intake, leading to overweight, obesity, and diet related NCDs. Both categories of malnutrition are caused by unhealthy, poor quality diets, and they can be linked. Undernutrition in childhood, in addition to affecting survival, growth, development, health, and educational or economic outcomes, is a risk factor for overweight and NCDs in later life.6 Around 151 million children whose stunted growth is caused by undernutrition and 38 million children under five who are currently overweight are at increased risk of NCDs in adulthood.4
How unhealthy diets and food systems relate to NCDs
Unhealthy diets, malnutrition, and NCDs are closely linked. They are the logical consequences of, among other factors, today’s food systems, which have changed dramatically in the past 50 years. A focus on efficiency has seen an increase in the availability of inexpensive, high calorie foods, often from staple cereal crops, which has reduced hunger for many. This has, however, often been at the expense of diversity and has displaced local, often healthier, diets. Access to diverse, micronutrient rich foods—such as fresh fruits, vegetables, legumes, pulses, and nuts—has not improved equally for everyone, and unhealthy foods with salt, sugars, saturated fats, and trans fats have become cheaper and more widely available.3 Furthermore, global demand for and supply of meat, dairy products, sugar sweetened drinks, and processed and ultra-processed foods has increased dramatically.3
A variety of drivers and policies (or the lack thereof) shape food systems (fig 1). Food systems worldwide face major challenges, such as population growth, globalisation, urbanisation, and climate change. Agricultural, economic, trade, environmental, and international development policies create incentives, and disincentives, for the production of particular types of food. Rural development, urban planning, and transport policies affect what food reaches which consumers and at what price. Many factors influence consumers’ dietary behaviours, from personal—such as culture, knowledge, skills, dietary preferences, and time for food preparation—to economic and political—such as the cost or availability of food. Information about food, whether through education or marketing, also influences choices. Marketing, labelling, and policies that impact on price all affect consumer demand. Economic and social protection policies determine whether vulnerable populations can access healthy and sustainable diets. The nutritional quality of the foods available in the places we live affects the health of people and the planet.
Today’s food systems are broken and do not deliver nutritious, safe, affordable, and sustainable diets; worse, they undermine nutrition in several ways, particularly for vulnerable and marginalised populations. Good nutrition—particularly in the 1000 days from conception to a child’s second birthday—is critical, but aggressive marketing of formula and baby foods compromise breastfeeding and feeding practices in early childhood. Diets lacking a range of nutrient rich foods are a major cause of stunting: two thirds of the world’s children are not eating the recommended minimum number of food groups and only one in six children is receiving a minimum acceptable diet.8 Billions of dollars are spent annually marketing foods high in calories, fats, sugars, and salt, and intake has increased globally, including in low income countries. Meanwhile, more than a quarter (27.5%) of the world’s population are now insufficiently physically active.9 The prevalence of adult obesity has nearly tripled since 1975 and, by 2016, more than 1.9 billion adults were overweight or obese,10 while there has been a ten fold increase in overweight and obesity among children and adolescents over the same period.11 In 2014, 422 million people were affected by diabetes, up from 108 million in 1980.12
The burden and true costs of malnutrition and diet related NCDs
Maternal and child malnutrition and poor diets are the two major risk factors for disease burden—as measured by disability adjusted life years (DALYs)—worldwide, according to the 2017 Global Burden of Disease data (fig 2).13 Poor diet, as defined by a cluster of dietary risks, is the leading cause of death (fig 3) and is the first or second biggest contributor to NCD disease burden in all six World Health Organization regions.13
Of these dietary risks, the biggest contributors to the global burden of disease in 2017 were diets that are low in whole grains, high in sodium, or low in fruits, nuts and seeds, or vegetables (fig 4). Additionally, there is an effect of higher body mass index on disease outcomes.13
As well as human loss and suffering, malnutrition and diet related NCDs pose a substantial economic burden (fig 5). Countries face the implications of a workforce that never reaches its full productive potential, as well as the costs of treating and managing long term NCDs. Families are affected when wage earners cannot work or healthcare costs push households into poverty.
Yet, even the numbers in figure 5 do not represent the true costs of modern food systems, whose heavy environmental impact threatens the health of the planet and future generations. Global food production, responsible for up to a third of greenhouse gas emissions, is a major source of soil, air, and water pollution, while accounting for more than 70% of freshwater use and 40% of land use, and contributing to biodiversity loss.1516 These effects could rise by 50-90% by 2050 unless food systems are transformed.17 The type of food produced is also important—the impact of ruminant meat production is around 100 times those of plant based foods.15
Transforming food systems to tackle NCDs
Real progress to prevent diet related NCDs across the life cycle requires radical food systems transformation so that nutritious, safe, affordable, and sustainable diets are available to all.
Food systems and the infrastructure on which they depend must be restructured. Reforms to the supply side of food systems in order to improve the availability of healthy sustainable diets are needed—from research and production through to processing, storage, transportation, marketing, and retailing.
Food, agriculture, and trade policies—which were often originally devised to ensure quantity rather than quality of food—must remove incentives to produce less healthy foods and create incentives to produce diverse and nutritious foods using sustainable practices.
Investment must be made in green transport, storage, and distribution infrastructure to give access to perishable, nutrient rich foods, such as fruits and vegetables. Measures that affect demand for certain foods—what we buy, how we prepare it, and what we eat or throw away—are urgently needed. These should include actions to create healthy food environments, supported by nutrition education, especially in schools,1819 to ensure that even the most vulnerable people can access healthy diets. Taxes and subsidies—along with regulatory measures on food composition, marketing, labelling, and nutrition standards for food in schools and other public institutions—are among the tools available.
Although it is increasingly clear what needs to be done, less than a third of countries have fully implemented measures recommended by WHO—such as restricting marketing of unhealthy foods to children, taxing sugar sweetened drinks, or banning industrial trans fats (see box). Commercial interests, including the agri-food and drink industries, have large budgets to use on a variety of tactics—from lobbying decision makers to stirring public resistance—to undermine public health policy.20 Mechanisms are needed to protect governments against vested interests and ensure partnerships are in the interest of public health.
The challenges of achieving policy coherence and implementing multisectoral action across governments—in the face of competing priorities and budgetary constraints, short term political gain, and lack of accountability—should also be acknowledged, along with the challenges of collecting reliable data to inform policy and report on progress, or its lack. The role of activists in advocating for strong nutrition action, building public support, and holding government to account on their commitments is vital.
To accelerate progress, the United Nations Decade of Action on Nutrition (2016-2025), along with the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda and Goals, and the Paris Agreement, present an unprecedented opportunity to transform food systems, eliminate malnutrition in all its forms, prevent diet related NCDs, and realise the human rights to food and health.2122
Actions to create healthy food environments
While most countries report having dietary guidelines, labelling legislation, media campaigns promoting healthy diets, or nutrition counselling through primary healthcare,23 they could do more to create healthy food environments.
Structural actions to improve the food environment include—among others—implementing a ban on industrially produced trans fats; effective restrictions on marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages to children; ending inappropriate promotion (to parents) of foods for infants and young children; taxing sugar sweetened beverages or unhealthy foods; mandating simplified, interpretive front-of-pack nutrition labelling; and introducing nutrition standards for food served or sold in schools, hospitals, and other public institutions. These types of action are much less common—not one of the examples given has been implemented in more than a third of countries.23242526
The synergies of an approach to tackle multiple forms of malnutrition can be realised through “double duty” actions that tackle several forms of malnutrition at the same time. Examples include:
Protection and promotion of optimal breastfeeding* and complementary feeding. This protects against undernutrition and can reduce the risk of developing overweight and diet related NCDs later in life, while breastfeeding can also protect mothers against some forms of cancer and other NCDs. Measures to promote breastfeeding, including banning advertising of breastmilk substitutes and extending paid maternity leave, increased exclusive breastfeeding in Vietnam, for example, from 20% to 62% in five years.27
Enabling better access to safe drinking water protects against infectious diseases which exacerbate undernutrition while helping prevent obesity by providing an alternative to sugar sweetened beverages. Around 85 countries have taken measures, for example, to ensure that safe drinking water is available free of charge in schools.23
School nutrition programmes can ensure children access diverse diets needed for healthy growth and development, while limiting their exposure to unhealthy foods, and can even work towards broader development goals. Brazil, for example, introduced nutrition standards for school food that require at least 30% of school food budgets to be spent buying from local family farmers.
*Defined as initiation of breastfeeding within one hour of birth, exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months of life, and introduction of nutritionally adequate and safe complementary solid foods at six months together with continued breastfeeding up to two years of age or beyond
Poor quality diets, malnutrition in all its forms, and NCDs are closely linked. Unhealthy diets are now the biggest risk factor for NCDs
Poor quality diets, malnutrition, and NCDs are the logical consequences of, among other factors, major changes to how food is produced, sold, marketed, and consumed around the world in the past half century
Transformation of current food systems to improve availability, affordability, and uptake of nutritious, safe, affordable, and sustainable diets is key to tackling malnutrition in all its forms and diet related NCDs
Policy options to tackle the different forms of malnutrition and diet related NCDs can also help create food systems that are sustainable, benefitting planetary health
The United Nations Decade of Action on Nutrition, along with the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda and Goals, are a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to simultaneously and cost effectively improve diets, eliminate malnutrition, reduce death and disability from NCDs, and promote sustainable development
We thank Karen McColl, Lina Mahy, and Jørgen Torgerstuen Johnsen for their contribution to this paper.
This article is part of a series proposed by the WHO Global Coordination Mechanism on NCDs and commissioned by The BMJ, which peer reviewed, edited, and made the decision to publish. Open access fees are funded by WHO.
For other articles in the series see www.bmj.com/NCD-solutions
Contributors and sources: FB, AL, SO, VA, GS, RR, MA, and AA all participated in the drafting and reviewing of the paper. FB coordinated the overall preparation of the manuscript. AA analysed the data and provided the respective figures. All have read and agreed to the final version. The corresponding author attests that all listed authors meet authorship criteria and that no others meeting the criteria have been omitted. The authors alone are responsible for the views expressed in this article, which does not necessarily represent the views, decisions, or policies of WHO or the institutions with which the authors are affiliated.
Competing interests: We have read and understood BMJ’s policy on declaration of interest and have no relevant interest to declare.
Provenance and peer review: Commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution IGO License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/), which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.