Views And Reviews Acute Perspective

David Oliver: Hotel chains are no answer to hospital bed crises

BMJ 2017; 356 doi: (Published 17 February 2017) Cite this as: BMJ 2017;356:j730
  1. David Oliver, consultant in geriatrics and acute general medicine
  1. Berkshire
  1. davidoliver372{at}

Roy Lilley, the ubiquitous health pundit, wrote in January of the need for radical solutions to current NHS crises rather than medical colleges endlessly campaigning for more resources.1

Lilley then set out some big, audacious ideas of his own. One was that, to “get the thousands [of people] marooned in hospital home safely,” we should “Block-book Premier Inns; create step-down care. It’s £45 a night. Include a matron and some care assistants and you’ll do it for £150. Hospitals cost £400.”2

Does this idea bear scrutiny? Who are these patients stranded in hospital, and will it help them?34

Many are awaiting transfer to care homes. They are often still very unwell and dependent on care. Dementia, severe frailty, impaired continence, and mobility are the norm in long term care, along with multiple comorbidities.5 Median survival time from entering a UK nursing home is only nine months, so end of life care is key, and acute admissions to hospital are frequent.6 Are budget hotel chains geared up for such needs—even with care assistants?

Then we have those patients waiting for step-down intermediate care, whether at home or in community facilities. They aren’t going for convalescence or a rest cure, but for rehabilitation requiring a skilled multidisciplinary approach.7 Without comprehensive assessment and rehabilitation, long term disability and dependence and the inability to return home are more likely.8

Packing patients off for a bed-to-chair existence, with no moving equipment or pressure relieving mattresses or physiotherapy, isn’t the smartest move

We know that bed rest carries a whole range of harms and risks, especially for older, frailer people.9 Packing patients off for a bed-to-chair existence, with no moving or handling equipment or pressure relieving mattresses and no physiotherapy, isn’t the smartest move. Soon we’d see “exit block” from the hotel too, when they were so dependent that no facility could take them.

In practice, patients on step-down hospital wards, in community hospitals, or in step-down beds in care homes still require skilled medical input—which is unsurprising in view of their medical complexity and risk of further deterioration.

Given the workforce and workload crises in general practice and community nursing, as well as struggles in providing clinical input to existing facilities,10 where would clinical input come from for patients decanted into budget hotels? We also have a national recruitment crisis among care assistants.1112 Moving a few of them from home care to hastily commissioned hotel beds will solve nothing.

Lilley’s idea doesn’t stand up. Sometimes the radical idea was in fact the obvious one all along. We need to resource social and community health services properly to enable patients to leave hospital. And clinicians have a professional imperative to keep saying so, even if those such as Lilley might find it boring.



View Abstract