Diagnosis, treatment, and management of echinococcosisBMJ 2012; 344 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e3866 (Published 11 June 2012) Cite this as: BMJ 2012;344:e3866
- Donald P McManus, National Health and Medical Research Council (Australia) senior principal research fellow; laboratory head1,
- Darren J Gray, Australian Research Council fellow (DECRA); visiting scientist12,
- Wenbao Zhang, senior research officer1,
- Yurong Yang, Griffith University research fellow; professor; visiting scientist134
- 1Queensland Institute of Medical Research, Herston, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
- 2School of Population Health, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia
- 3Griffith Health Institute, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia
- 4Ningxia Medical University, Yinchuan, Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, People’s Republic of China
- Correspondence to: D P McManus
Echinococcosis is a parasitic zoonosis caused by Echinococcus cestode worms
The two major species of medical importance are Echinococcus granulosus and E multilocularis, which cause cystic echinococcosis (CE) and alveolar echinococcosis (AE), respectively
CE and especially AE are life threatening chronic diseases with a high fatality rate and poor prognosis if careful clinical management is not carried out
Human CE is cosmopolitan and the more common presentation, accounting for most of the estimated two to three million global echinococcosis cases. AE has an extensive geographical range in the northern hemisphere
Diagnosis is based on clinical findings, imaging (radiology, ultrasonography, computed axial tomography, magnetic resonance imaging), and serology
Treatment options for CE are: surgery, percutaneous sterilisation, drugs, and observation (watch and wait). Surgery is the basis of treatment for early AE, but patients not suitable for surgery and those who have had surgical resection of parasite lesions must be treated with benzimidazoles (albendazole, mebendazole) for several years
Echinococcosis (hydatid disease) is caused by the larvae of dog and fox tapeworms (cestodes) of the genus Echinococcus (family Taeniidae).1 2 3 This zoonosis is characterised by long term growth of metacestode (hydatid) cysts in humans and mammalian intermediate hosts. The two major species that infect humans are E granulosus and E multilocularis, which cause cystic echinococcosis (CE) and alveolar echinococcosis (AE). A few reported cases of polycystic echinococcosis in Central and South America are caused by E vogeli and E oligarthrus.2 w1 w2 The clinical potential of two other Echinococcus species (E shiquicus and E felidis) is unknown.1 2
Sources and selection criteria
We obtained information from personal reference archives, personal experience, and extensive literature searches of the PubMed and Cochrane databases. We sourced English language papers that were fully published mainly between 2000 and March 2012 using appropriate index terms. Keywords included: “Echinococcus”, “Echinococcus granulosus”, “Echinococcus multilocularis”, “echinococcal cysts”, “hydatid cysts”, “hydatid disease”, “cystic echinococcosis”, “alveolar echinococcosis”, “hydatidosis”, “hydatid”, “surgery”, “liver transplant”, “mebendazole”, “albendazole”, “benzimidazole”, “chemotherapy”, “PAIR”, “percutaneous treatment”, “percutaneous drainage”, “ultrasound”; and “Echinococcus” with “diagnosis”, “serology”, “treatment”, “clinical”, “review”, “meta analysis”; and “echinococcosis” with diagnosis”, “serology”, “treatment”, “clinical”, “review”, and “meta analysis”.
Cystic echinococcosis (CE) and alveolar echinococcosis (AE) are serious chronic diseases with poor prognosis and high mortality if managed inadequately.1 2 3 Of the estimated two to three million cases of echinococcosis globally, most are cystic.2 4 Published reports and the Office International des Epizooties databases suggest that the global burden for human CE exceeds one million disability adjusted life years (DALYs), resulting in a loss of $760m (£490m; €612m) a year,4 although these figures are probably underestimates.2 Case series and small clinical trials show a mortality rate of 2-4% for CE, but this increases markedly with poor treatment and care.5 6 There are 0.4 million cases of human AE, and survival analysis has shown that, if untreated or if treatment is limited, mortality exceeds 90% 10-15 years after diagnosis.5 7 About 18 000 new cases of AE occur annually, with a total annual burden of 666 434 DALYs.8
Here, we introduce the Echinococcus parasites and the diseases they cause, and we discuss current methods for the diagnosis, treatment, and management of both types of echinococcosis. The life cycle characteristics of Echinococcus spp and the causes and immunology of echinococcosis have been described extensively.1 2 3 9 10 11 12 13 14 w3-w16
Where and how is echinococcosis acquired?
Figure 1⇓ shows the distribution of echinococcosis, according to statistics from the World Health Organization. E granulosus occurs worldwide, with high endemic areas concentrated in north east Africa, South America, and Eurasia.10 12 E multilocularis is restricted to the northern hemisphere.10 12 Figure 2⇓ illustrates the E granulosus and E multilocularis life cycles and shows how humans become infected. Human co-infection with E granulosus and E multilocularis is not common, although these two species are co-endemic in some specific foci, notably the northwest of the People’s Republic of China.10 Figure 3⇓ is an ultrasound image of a patient with both types of echinococcosis.
What are the clinical features of echinococcosis?
Most (>90%) CE cysts occur in liver, lung, or both organs.12 w17 In general, the initial stages of CE do not cause symptoms—small cysts can remain asymptomatic for many years.1 Because of the parasite’s slow growth most cases are diagnosed in adults.3 The onset of symptoms depends on the infected organ, the size and position of the cyst(s), their effect on the organ and adjacent tissues, and complications arising from the rupture of a cyst or a secondary infection.1 12 Recurrent (secondary) CE can arise after primary cyst surgery, owing to spillage of the cyst contents, or if there is spontaneous or trauma induced cyst rupture and release of larvae, which can grow into secondary cysts.10 Leakage or rupture of CE cysts can induce systemic immunological reactions and other complications, including cholangitis.1 12
AE generally has a longer latent phase (up to 15 years) before the onset of chronic disease.1 12 w18 E multilocularis usually develops in the right liver lobe and AE lesions range from a few millimetres to 15-20 cm in diameter in areas of infiltration.1 12 Extrahepatic primary disease is uncommon.1 12 w18 w19 Metastasis formation leads to secondary AE with infiltration of the lung, spleen, or brain. Symptoms of AE usually include epigastric pain or cholestatic jaundice.12
How is echinococcosis diagnosed?
The box shows the best indicators of disease. The diagnosis of CE is based on clinical findings, imaging results, and serology.1 2 3 6 7 11 12 15 16 17 Clinical manifestations may indicate cyst rupture, secondary bacterial infection, allergic reactions, or anaphylaxis.1 17 Patients with symptoms should immediately be advised to undergo imaging and serology.
Key indicators for a positive diagnosis of echinococcosis
Have you travelled to or emigrated from an endemic country (about five to 10 years ago)? If so, from where? (fig 1)
Have you had contact with dogs, foxes, or livestock during the past five to 10 years?
Have you worked in a pastoral area where you may have had contact with wildlife during the past five to 10 years?
Have you worked in an abattoir during the past five to 10 years?
Upper abdominal discomfort
Vague abdominal pain (right upper quadrant; 30% cases) (most cases originate in the liver)
Jaundice (25% cases)
Fatigue, weight loss, fever, chills
On palpation of the abdomen a mass may be found on the surface of organs (the liver is affected in two thirds of patients); hepatomegaly or abdominal distension may also be seen
Chest pain, cough, and haemoptysis can be indicative of cysts in the lung; cyst rupture into the bronchi may result in the expulsion of hydatid material and cystic membranes
Cyst rupture can induce fever, urticaria, eosinophilia, and anaphylactic shock
On palpation of the abdomen, hepatomegaly may be detected
Splenomegaly may be present in cases complicated by portal hypertension
Collateral circulation between the inferior and superior vena cava may be present on the skin in the thoracic and abdominal regions in advanced cases
Other physical symptoms are dictated by the location of metastatic legions (see lung involvement for cystic echinococcosis)
General laboratory investigations show non-specific results
Serology can help form a definitive diagnosis
Ultrasound guided fine needle biopsy can also be used to examine hydatid cyst fluid for the presence of protoscoleces or DNA using molecular techniques (polymerase chain reaction)
Ultrasound (figs 4 and 5), computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging are the procedures of choice for the definitive diagnosis of echinococcosis
Imaging should be used to examine not only the liver but also the entire abdomen and thorax, and they are able to determine metastatic locations in alveolar echinococcosis
Ultrasound is a crucially important tool for the diagnosis, staging, and follow-up of abdominal CE cysts, although it has low sensitivity for detecting small cysts. The first generally accepted ultrasound classification for CE was developed in 1981.w21 A series of meetings by a WHO informal working group on echinococcosis (WHO-IWGE) resulted in an international standardised ultrasound classification of CE cysts into three groups (fig 4⇓).6 12 16 Microscopy of cystic fluid for brood capsules or protoscoleces provides proof of infection and cyst viability.6 Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of biopsy material can also provide a definitive diagnosis.6 High field magnetic resonance spectroscopy is also useful for determining cyst viability and for staging.1 w22
CE serology is a helpful diagnostic adjunct and can be used to monitor patients after surgery or drug treatment. However, although used widely, particularly in developing countries where imaging techniques may not be readily available, questions remain with regard to its effectiveness for clinical detection and screening.17 w23 w24 Serum antibody measurement is more sensitive than detection of circulating E granulosus antigens,1 11 w8 but available tests lack standardisation.11 17 Current serology for human CE mainly tests for IgG antibodies against native or recombinant antigen B by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay or western blotting.2 11 w25 Test specificity is affected by immunological crossreactivity with antigens found in other helminth infections, cancers, and liver cirrhosis and by the presence of anti-P1 antibodies.2 11 Although not thoroughly tested,17 serodiagnostic performance seems to depend also on cyst location, cyst size, and stage.
The seriousness of human AE means early detection is crucial so that treatment can start.1 5 12 Diagnosis is analogous to that for CE including clinical findings and use of imaging techniques and serology.1 5 12 Ultrasound is the main diagnostic test for AE in the abdomen,5 and the imaging based WHO-IWGE PNM classification system (table 1⇓; fig 5⇓) is the recognised benchmark for standardised evaluation of diagnosis and treatment.5 12 18
As with CE, serodiagnosis of AE is used as an adjunct to other detection procedures.11 w8 w26 w27 Conventional PCR can detect E multilocularis specific nucleic acids in tissue biopsies and real time PCR can be used to assess viability.5 w28 w29 Notably, however, for both diseases a negative real time PCR result does not reflect complete parasite inactivity and a negative PCR cannot rule out disease.5 w29
How is CE treated and managed?
The WHO-IWGE classification provides the basis for choosing basically four treatment and management options for CE: surgery, percutaneous sterilisation, drug treatment, and observation (watch and wait).5 6 17 However, there is no optimum treatment for CE and no clinical trials have compared the different modalities.5 Table 2⇓ shows the current expert consensus on the management of liver CE.5
Surgery is the classic treatment but, despite being curative, it does not totally prevent recurrence.5 Furthermore, in the absence of specific clinical trials, the evidence for the surgical treatment of complicated liver and disseminated CE is limited.5 w30 Surgery is, however, the choice for large or infected cysts, cysts likely to rupture, and cysts in important organ locations.1 5 Surgery may not be practical for patients with multiple cysts in several organs.1 5 Open cystectomy, pericystectomy, partial hepatectomy or lobectomy, cyst extrusion (Barrett’s technique), and drainage of infected cysts are some of the surgical options available.1 In cases where cyst resection is incomplete, or if small lesions remain undetected, disease can recur.1 Postoperative fatality is about 2% but can be higher if additional surgery is needed or if medical facilities are inadequate.12 15
Percutaneous sterilisation techniques
These include PAIR (puncture, aspiration, injection, reaspiration), which destroys the cyst’s germinal layer,w31-w33 and modified catheterisation approaches, which evacuate the complete cyst.1 5 12 PAIR, developed in the 1980s, involves ultrasound assisted percutaneous needle puncture aspiration of the cyst, followed by injection of a suitable protoscolicide (such as 20% sodium chloride or 95% ethanol) and cyst reaspiration after 15-20 minutes.1 Anaphylaxis is a risk. Assess cyst fluid for protoscoleces and bilirubin, and, to minimise the risk of secondary CE, co-administer benzimidazole. CE2 and CE3b stages (fig 4) are problematic because they have many compartments that require individual puncture, and these commonly relapse after PAIR.17 Large bore catheters, combined with suitable aspiration equipment, may in future replace PAIR for these stages,17 but their true effectiveness needs to be established.5 The choice of between surgery or percutaneous sterilisation can be difficult. Comparison of the two procedures requires large carefully designed clinical studies, which have yet to be done.17
Antiparasite drug treatment
The benzimidazoles—albendazole and mebendazole—are generally regarded as the most effective drugs for treating uncomplicated CE cysts and as an alternative to invasive surgery. Mebendazole was used in the 1970 and 1980s, but albendazole is now the drug of choice. It is administered in 10 mg/kg doses (usually 400 mg) twice daily; mebendazole (40-50 mg/kg a day in three doses) is less effective than albendazole.19 However, studies carried out with both drugs have been small, and heterogeneity in methodology has prevented meta-analysis.17 Furthermore, a recent pooled study of individual data from patients with CE (six treatment centres; five countries) suggested that the overall efficacy of these drugs may have been overstated.20 Systematic randomised controlled trials that compare standardised treatment with benzimidazoles at different cyst stages with other options are needed,20 especially as these drugs seem to work better against some cyst stages (such as small CE1 cysts). Indeed, benzimidazoles are not effective against large cysts (>10 cm), being diluted by the volume of fluid present.5 The degree and type of side effects of sustained use of benzimidazoles also warrant rigorous study.5 Benzimidazoles should not be used in early pregnancy or against cysts at risk of rupture.1 5 Thorough assessment of other anthelmintics (such as praziquantel and nitazoxanide) and combinations of anthelmintics (such as albendazole plus praziquantel) that have been used to treat CE is also needed.w34-w37
Watch and wait
Leaving uncomplicated cyst types (CE4 and CE5) untreated and just monitoring them by imaging (particularly ultrasound) is a logical management option given that a proportion of cysts calcify over time and become completely inactive; such cysts do not compromise organ function or cause discomfort.15 w38 Such an approach is attractive but requires systematic study to define fully its indications and limitations.
A patient’s perspective
I am a 31 year old farmer of the Hui minority from Ningxia, China. I was first admitted to hospital in May 2003 with extreme fatigue, cough, and difficulty breathing. A chest radiograph showed that my lungs were scattered with dark shadows and the doctors diagnosed me with a form of cancer and sent me home. In September 2003 a specialist doctor reviewed my case and asked me to come back to the hospital for further tests. The specialist doctor asked me many questions, performed a physical examination, and ran some tests including an ultrasound. The ultrasound and blood test showed that I did not have cancer but had alveolar echinococcosis. The parasite started in my liver and had spread to my lungs. I was given daily treatment with a drug called albendazole and after six months another chest radiograph showed that my lungs were clear and I felt much better. I was told to continue taking the drug to stop the parasite spreading from my liver to other organs. Today I am still taking albendazole and am feeling well.
Zhang Yin Gui, Xiji County, Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, Peoples’ Republic of China
How is AE treated and managed?
Table 3⇓ details a stage specific approach to treating AE. Historically, surgery has been the recommended treatment for early disease.1 5 Early diagnosis reduces the need for radical surgery and results in fewer unresectable lesions.1 5 Long term treatment with benzimidazoles is essential for patients with inoperable AE or after resection of E multilocularis lesions.1 5 12 Benzimidazoles are parasitostatic—they inhibit larval proliferation but do not kill metacestodes.w39 They should be given for a minimum of two years and patients monitored for at least 10 years for relapse.w40 Benzimidazoles are not recommended before surgery.5 As for CE, the drugs are given orally with fat-rich meals (10-l5 mg/kg/day, in two doses), although they have been given at a higher dose of 20 mg per kg per day for 4.5 years.5 Continuous treatment with albendazole is tolerated well, having been used for more than 20 years in some patients; intermittent use is not recommended.5 Mebendazole, given at a dose of 40-50 mg per kg per day over three days with a fatty meal, is an alternative to albendazole.5 Figure 6⇓ shows the effect of albendazole treatment on a P4 AE lesion. Neither praziquantel nor nitazoxanide is clinically effective against AE.5 w41-w43
Allotransplantation of the liver has been carried out in patients with end stage AE.w44-w46 However, the essential use of immunosuppressive treatment can stimulate the proliferation of parasitic remnants in the lung or brain.w45 A long term prospective follow-up of patients with AE treated by palliative liver transplantation in the 1980s found that some patients survived for 20 years.21 Ex vivo liver resection, followed by autotransplantation of AE-free lateral segments,22 may offer a radical approach to improving prognosis, but this procedure needs to be fully evaluated.
What are the future challenges?
Considerable recent progress has been made in the diagnosis, treatment, and management of echinococcosis, but challenges remain. Clinical trial data systematically evaluating existing treatments are not available and ideal treatment options are lacking. Treatment indicators are often complicated, being based on cyst characteristics, availability of medical and surgical expertise and equipment, and patient compliance in long term monitoring programmes.5
Comparable and standardised procedures and terminology need to be established by the medical fraternity.5 PAIR should be undertaken only by experienced doctors and trained teams capable of managing anaphylactic shock.1 PAIR needs to be studied systematically, via randomised controlled trials, to assess its efficacy compared with surgery and other available options for treatment of uncomplicated hepatic cysts.23
The WHO-IWGE consensus recommendations for the ultrasound imaging based classification of CE cysts need to be more wider disseminated to clinicians because they are useful when choosing treatment options.5 Similarly, the WHO-IWGE classification for AE should be advocated as the international classification because it can help determine whether an E multilocularis lesion should be excised or otherwise treated, give some indications for improved prognosis, and help determine the best treatment option for the individual patient.5
The current clinical diagnosis of AE and CE relies mainly on the detection of parasite lesions by imaging methods, but the procedures are expensive and are generally not available in resource poor settings. Furthermore, they are not useful for detecting the early stages of infection, which is a major disadvantage because earlier diagnosis results in more effective and successful treatment. Serodiagnosis can play a role in early detection because specific anti-Echinococcus antibodies appear in the blood system four to eight weeks after infection. Most available immunodiagnostic techniques have been used in the diagnosis of echinococcosis.11 However, most of these tests have not been systematically compared by independent laboratories, they are mainly used for research purposes, and few have found general acceptance by clinicians.
Tips for non-specialists
Refer symptomatic patients who travelled to, or emigrated from, an echinococcosis endemic area about five to 10 years ago, and had contact with dogs or wildlife, to an infectious disease physician
Serology provides supportive information for diagnosis but imaging studies provide the definitive diagnosis
Differential diagnosis is important because alveolar echinococcosis often presents with cancer-like symptoms
Imaging studies should examine the entire thorax and abdomen, not just the liver
Treatment may involve the use of drugs (albendazole, mebendazole) or surgery (or both)
Additional educational resources
Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echinococcosis)—Information on the Echinococcus parasites and echinococcosis for patients and the public
Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alveolar_hydatid_disease)—Brief fact sheet on alveolar echinococcosis for patients and the public
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (http://www.cdc.gov/parasites/echinococcosis/)—Fact sheet on the Echinococcus parasites and echinococcosis for professionals, patients, and the public
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (www.dpd.cdc.gov/dpdx/HTML/Echinococcosis.htm)—Description of the Echinococcus parasites and echinococcosis for professionals, patients, and the public
Patient.co.uk (www.patient.co.uk/doctor/Hydatid-Disease.htm)—Fact sheet of the Echinococcus parasites and echinococcosis for professionals, patients and the public
Nunnari G, Pinzone MR, Gruttadauria S, Celesia BM, Madeddu G, Malaguarnera G, et al. Hepatic echinococcosis: clinical and therapeutic aspects. World J Gastroenterol 2012;18:1448-58. Review of the clinical and therapeutic aspects of hepatic echinococcosis for professionals
Cite this as: BMJ 2012;344:e3866
We thank Mimi Kersting and Simon Forsyth for graphical support and Hawys McManus for help in editing drafts of the manuscript.
Contributors: DPMcM conceived the manuscript and is guarantor. DPMcM, DJG, WZ, and YY prepared individual sections of the article and jointly prepared drafts of the paper. DPMcM and DJG finalised the article. All authors approved the final version of the manuscript.
Funding: The authors’ studies on echinococcosis have received financial support from the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia and the Queensland Institute of Medical Research.
Competing interests: All authors have completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form at www.icmje.org/coi_disclosure.pdf (available on request from the corresponding author) and declare: all authors had financial support from the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia for the submitted work; no financial relationships with any organisations that might have an interest in the submitted work in the previous three years; no other relationships or activities that could appear to have influenced the submitted work.
Provenance and peer review: Commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Patient consent obtained.