Migraine with aura and risk of cardiovascular and all cause mortality in men and women: prospective cohort studyBMJ 2010; 341 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.c3966 (Published 24 August 2010) Cite this as: BMJ 2010;341:c3966
- Larus S Gudmundsson, doctoral student1,
- Ann I Scher, associate professor2,
- Thor Aspelund, associate professor34,
- Jon H Eliasson, neurologist5,
- Magnus Johannsson, professor1,
- Gudmundur Thorgeirsson, professor46,
- Lenore Launer, senior investigator7,
- Vilmundur Gudnason, professor34
- 1Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology, University of Iceland, Hagi Hofsvallagata 53, IS-107 Reykjavik, Iceland
- 2Department of Preventive Medicine and Biometrics, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, MD, USA
- 3Icelandic Heart Association, Holtasmara 1, IS-201 Kopavogur, Iceland
- 4University of Iceland, Reykjavik, Iceland
- 5Reykjalundur Rehabilitation Centre, Mosfellsbær, Iceland
- 6Landspitali University Hospital, Reykjavik, Iceland
- 7Laboratory of Epidemiology, Demography, and Biometry, National Institute on Aging, Bethesda, MD, USA
- Correspondence to: L S Gudmundsson , V Gudnason
- Accepted 12 July 2010
Objective To estimate whether migraine in mid-life is associated with mortality from cardiovascular disease, other causes, and all causes.
Design Population based cohort study.
Setting Reykjavik, Iceland.
Participants 18 725 men and women, born 1907-35 and living in Reykjavik and adjacent communities.
Main outcome measures Mortality from cardiovascular disease, non-cardiovascular disease, and all causes. Questionnaires and clinical measures were obtained in mid-life (mean age 53, range 33-81) in the Reykjavik Study (1967-91). Headache was classified as migraine without aura, migraine with aura, or non-migraine headache. Median follow-up was 25.9 years (0.1-40.2 years), with 470 990 person years and 10 358 deaths: 4323 from cardiovascular disease and 6035 from other causes. We used Cox regression to estimate risk of death in those with migraine compared with others, after adjusting for baseline risk factors.
Results People with migraine with aura were at increased risk of all cause mortality (adjusted (for sex and multivariables) hazard ratio 1.21, 95% confidence interval 1.12 to 1.30) and mortality from cardiovascular disease (1.27, 1.13 to 1.43) compared with people with no headache, while those with migraine without aura and non-migraine headache were not. Further examination of mortality from cardiovascular disease shows that people with migraine with aura were at increased risk of mortality from coronary heart disease (1.28, 1.11 to 1.49) and stroke (1.40, 1.10 to 1.78). Women with migraine with aura were also at increased risk of mortality from non-cardiovascular disease (1.19, 1.06 to 1.35).
Conclusions Migraine with aura is an independent risk factor for cardiovascular and all cause mortality in men and women. The risk of mortality from coronary heart disease and stroke mortality is modestly increased in people with migraine, particularly those with aura.
In recent years, numerous studies have suggested that migraine, particularly migraine with aura, is a risk factor for clinical and subclinical cardiovascular disease.1 2 3 4 5 6 Both we and others have examined the relation between cardiovascular risk factors and migraine, showing differences in risk factors between those with and without migraine.7 8 9 10 Less well understood is the degree, if any, to which migraine is related to the risk of all cause or cardiovascular mortality. Few articles have been published on migraine and cardiovascular disease or overall mortality, with somewhat conflicting findings, depicting migraine as a risk factor, neutral, or a protective factor.4 6 11 12 13 14 Because of insufficient data, a recent meta-analysis could draw no conclusions regarding the risk of mortality associated with migraine with aura.6 We estimated the risk of mortality from cardiovascular disease, non-cardiovascular disease, and all causes associated with having migraine with or without aura at mid-life during up to four decades of follow-up in a population based cohort.
Detailed descriptions of the Reykjavik Study have previously been published.15 16 In brief, the Reykjavik Study is a population based cohort study established in 1967 by the Icelandic Heart Association to prospectively study cardiovascular disease in Iceland.16 The cohort included a random sample of men and women born in 1907-35 and living in Reykjavik. The first examination of each person occurred between 1967 and 1991, the average year of examination was 1975 (see appendix 1 on bmj.com).
Participants were asked about current headache symptoms.8 Those reporting headache once or more a month were asked whether the headaches were accompanied by any of the following five features of migraine: nausea or vomiting, unilateral location, photophobia, visual disturbance during or preceding headache, and unilateral numbness preceding headache.
We classified participants into four mutually exclusive categories of headache: no headache once or more a month (reference category), non-migraine headache, migraine without aura, and migraine with aura. The category of migraine without aura included individuals with headache with at least two of the three non-aura symptoms (nausea, unilateral location, photophobia). The category of migraine with aura included those who reported visual aura or sensory aura, or both. Individuals with headache but no non-aura symptoms or only one non-aura symptom were defined as having non-migraine headache. Aura symptoms took precedence over other symptoms. The classification scheme represents an approximation of the 2004 diagnostic criteria of the International Headache Society (IHS)17 for migraine with or without aura, which were formalised after the Reykjavik Study data were collected. Features for migraine without aura that are missing from these IHS criteria include pulsatility, exacerbation with activity, and phonophobia. Criteria for migraine with aura missing from these criteria include duration of aura (aura symptoms must last between 5 and 60 minutes) and speed of onset (aura symptoms must develop gradually over more than 5 minutes).
Assessment of demographic and cardiovascular factors
Assessment of cardiovascular risk was performed at the same time as the migraine assessment. Nurses administered questionnaires, made physical measurements, performed spirometry and electrocardiography, and collected venous blood samples.
After entering the study, participants were followed for up to 40 years (until the end of 2007). Statistics relating to the cause of death, given by an ICD (international classification of disease) code, were obtained from Statistics Iceland. The main end points in our study were deaths from cardiovascular disease, non-cardiovascular disease, and all causes. We also defined three additional cardiovascular end points: fatal coronary heart disease, fatal stroke, and other fatal cardiovascular disease (such as non-coronary heart disease and non-stroke), based on diagnostic codes as defined in the SCORE project (systematic coronary risk evaluation project).18 In the current study we split mortality from non-coronary atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (non-coronary heart disease-cardiovascular disease) into mortality from stroke and other cardiovascular disease. An end point for fatal coronary heart disease was obtained from hospital records, which were systematically reviewed according to the monitoring of trends and determinants in cardiovascular disease (MONICA) protocol.19
For stroke mortality we used ICD-9 (ninth revision) codes 431, 433, 434, 436, and 438 and ICD-10 (10th revision) codes I61, I63, I64, I66, and I69.
At the start of the study, there were 18 903 participants, of whom 68 (0.36%) were lost to follow-up for cause specific mortality and 110 (0.58%) had missing data on blood pressure, cholesterol concentration, or body mass index (BMI) and were omitted. This left a sample of 18 725 (99%), with 470 990 years of follow-up during which 10 358 participants died. For cause specific mortality, 4323 died from cardiovascular disease and 6035 from non-cardiovascular disease. The 4323 deaths from cardiovascular disease consisted of 2810 deaths from coronary heart disease, 927 from stroke, and 586 from other forms of cardiovascular disease.
We used Cox proportional hazards to estimate the relative risk of death (hazard ratio) after adjusting for demographic and baseline risk factors for cardiovascular disease. Significance testing was two sided and based on a 5% probability level. Risk factors for mortality were entered into the Cox model in a stepwise manner, including those with P values under 0.2 for multivariable adjustment. For all cause mortality, we adjusted for age, BMI, education (primary, secondary, junior college, or university), smoking (none, current, previous), and systolic and diastolic blood pressure. For mortality from cardiovascular disease we additionally adjusted for current diabetes mellitus, cholesterol concentration, self reported history of coronary event, self reported current use of antihypertensive drugs, and use of oral contraceptives in women.
We tested the Cox models for possible violations of the proportional hazards assumption.20 21 The assumption was not violated except for men with migraine without aura when death from coronary heart disease was the end point. When participants were censored after 30 years of follow-up, the proportional hazards assumption held. This resulted in somewhat lower hazard ratio for all three categories of headache compared with when the follow-up was up to 40 years. We also used a log−log plot. The curves for the groups in the current study were roughly parallel, indicating no violation of the proportionality of the hazards assumption.
We also estimated median life expectancy at age 50 by headache status from a Cox model adjusted for age. Men and women were compared descriptively with respect to headache/migraine status and mortality from cardiovascular disease through Nelson-Aalen cumulative hazard curves.22 23 We estimated the absolute 10 year risk of mortality from all causes and cardiovascular disease by sex and headache status from the Cox model at ages 50, 60, and 70. The software package used was Stata version 9 (StataCorp LP, College Station, TX, USA) and SAS/STAT software version 9.2.
Table 1⇓ shows the characteristics of the study participants. There were 9044 men and 9681 women, with an average age of 52.8 (range 33-81) at study entry. Overall, 11% (2023) of the participants (6% (571) of men, 15% (1452) of women) were classified as having migraine, including 3% with migraine without aura (1% (128) of men, 5% (498) of women) and 8% with migraine with aura (5% (443) of men, 10% (954) of women). Among participants with aura, the proportion with visual aura, sensory aura, and both visual and sensory aura was 72%, 17%, and 11% for men and 65%, 17%, and 19% for women, respectively. Within the migraine with aura group, 81% (358) of the men and 89% (849) of the women reported having at least one other migraine symptom.
Participants with migraine and headache were significantly younger than those without headache. Systolic blood pressure was lower among men with migraine than among men without headache (adjusted for age and use of antihypertensive drugs). Pulse pressure was lower among men and women with migraine than those without headache and lower among men with non-migraine headache than those without headache (table 1⇑). Compared with those without headache, people with migraine or with migraine with aura had less education and were more likely to be taking antihypertensive drugs or hormone treatment, or both.
Migraine and non-migraine headache
Compared with people with no headache, those with migraine were at significantly increased risk of mortality from all causes (hazard ratio 1.15, 95% confidence interval 1.08 to 1.23, P<0.001, table 2⇓) and from cardiovascular disease (1.22, 1.10 to 1.36, P<0.001, table 3⇓). The risk was similar with and without adjustment for risk factors for cardiovascular disease. In models stratified by sex, men and women with migraine were at similarly increased risk of all cause mortality (P=0.87 for interaction by sex), but for mortality from cardiovascular disease men were at marginally higher risk than women (P=0.057 for interaction by sex). Women, but not men, with non-migraine headache were also at increased risk of mortality from cardiovascular disease. The above results were similar when we excluded the 266 people with a history of coronary artery disease from the model. Table 4 shows results for mortality from non-cardiovascular cause.⇓
When we divided cardiovascular disease mortality into deaths from coronary heart disease, stroke, or other cardiovascular disease, people with migraine were at increased risk of death from coronary heart disease (sex and multivariable adjusted hazard ratio 1.22, 1.07 to 1.39, P=0.003, table 5⇓) and stroke (1.30, 1.05 to 1.61, P=0.017, table 6⇓). Risk of death from coronary heart disease and stroke, however, was significant only for men with migraine in the sex stratified models. Men and women with migraine were not at increased risk of mortality from other cardiovascular diseases (table 7⇓).
Migraine with aura and without aura
Among people with migraine, those with migraine with aura were at increased risk of mortality from all causes and cardiovascular disease (tables 2 and 3⇑ ⇑), but no increased risk was seen in those with migraine without aura. We studied the long term effects of migraine on mortality from cardiovascular disease using cumulative hazard curves. Men with migraine with aura were at marginally higher risk than women with migraine with aura (figure⇓); this is also reflected in table 3⇑, but this difference was marginally significant (P=0.053 for interaction by sex). Women with migraine with aura were still at marginally significantly increased risk of cardiovascular disease mortality compared with women with no headache (1.18, 1.00 to 1.40, P=0.053, table 3⇑).
The increased risk of mortality from cardiovascular disease in people with migraine with aura was higher among men than women for coronary heart disease and stroke, although not significantly; hazard ratios were 1.43 in men versus 1.17 in women for mortality from coronary heart disease (table 5⇑) and 1.76 in men versus 1.26 in women for mortality from stroke (table 6⇑) (P=0.12 and 0.15 for interaction by sex for coronary heart disease and stroke mortality). To investigate this finding further, we divided non-cardiovascular disease into cancer and non-cancer and found that the risk was increased only for mortality other than cancer 1.33, 1.13 to 1.57, P=0.001) (see appendix 2 on bmj.com).
Overall, using total mortality, our model suggests that at age 50 men and women with migraine with aura had a median loss of 1.5 and 1.4 years of life, respectively, compared with those without headache (see appendix 3 on bmj.com).
At age 50 the absolute risk of all cause mortality was low but still considerably higher for men than for women. For example, the 10 year risk for men aged 50 was 6.8% in those with no headache and 8.0% in those with migraine with aura; the corresponding values for women were 3.0% and 3.6%. At age 70 the absolute 10 year risk had risen to 40.6% and 46.1% for men and 24.1% and 27.9% for women (see appendix 4 on bmj.com).
In this cohort study with over 470 000 person years and a median follow-up of 26 years, men and women with migraine with aura were shown to be at increased risk of mortality from all causes and cardiovascular disease, while those with migraine without aura were not at increased risk. Risk of mortality from cardiovascular disease was marginally more increased in men than in women with migraine and aura. Migraine with aura is an independent risk factor for cardiovascular and all cause mortality in men and women but weaker than major established risk factors, such as cigarette smoking, diabetes, and high blood pressure.
Strengths and limitations
This study had a large cohort, with a broad age range, long follow-up, and comprehensive data on conventional risk factors for cardiovascular disease at baseline as well as high ascertainment (>99%) of cause specific mortality. The cohort is population based, which adds to the generalisability of our results. Although our classification of migraine precedes the 2004 IHS criteria, the questions are similar to those currently asked in the IHS criteria and cover the most common symptoms of migraine.
We did not ask about symptoms of migraine in those who reported having headache less than once a month and so are therefore likely to capture only those with higher attack frequency. People who had migraine aura exclusively, without headache, would be included in the “no headache” group because of our screening question. We cannot draw any conclusions from the current study about the risk of mortality for people with migraine with low frequency of attacks (less than once a month) and those with migraine aura without headache.
The risk of cardiovascular outcomes might be higher in people with more frequent attacks of migraine. Kurth et al looked at frequency of attacks and risk of cardiovascular disease in a cohort of US women.24 They reported a J-shaped association between attack frequency and risk. If this J-shaped association applies to our current study, our estimates might be somewhat lower than we would have found if we had included everyone with migraine, although this is speculative.
The prevalence of aura (as a proportion of the total migraine population) is higher than has been reported in other population studies and might include commonly occurring non-specific visual symptoms such as blurring. The result of this misclassification would probably attenuate the relation between migraine with aura and mortality. We note that our prevalence of migraine overall (with and without aura combined), however, is highly consistent with previous studies.25
Finally, the combination of visual symptoms and headache can be symptoms of a transient ischaemic attack. If this were misclassified as migraine with aura in our study, it might exaggerate the association between migraine and mortality from cardiovascular disease. Our diagnosis of migraine, however, required headache at least once a month in the past 12 months, which is not a feature of transient ischaemic attack. Therefore we believe it is unlikely that this type of misclassification would have appreciably affected our results.
As we have data on vascular risk factors only at baseline, we did not adjust for potential changes in such risk factors that might have developed after the start of the study. These risk factors in adults tend to track over time26—that is, those at high risk tend to stay at high risk during follow-up and those at low risk tend to stay at low risk. While residual confounding because of imperfect control for vascular risk factors at baseline or after the start of the study is a possibility, we note that the hazard ratios scarcely changed after adjustment, arguing against a strong role for this sort of error.
Although about only 2% of affected people have new onset migraine over the age of 50,27 the younger people in the cohort might have developed migraine after the study started and not been counted. We suggest that such a low percentage of people with migraine would be unlikely to change the risk estimates in the current study. Neither data on migraine specific treatment, such as ergotamine and triptans, nor data on the use of analgesics or steroid treatment were available. We could not therefore estimate the potential modifying effects of these drugs on the association between migraine and cardiovascular disease.
Comparison with other studies
This population based cohort study measured mortality from all causes and cardiovascular disease in men and women with migraine separately by aura status. Our findings are consistent with the increasing evidence that migraine, particularly migraine with aura, is associated with cardiovascular disease.1 3 4 28 Previous reports in which migraine has been shown to be protective for all cause mortality11 12 14 could be explained by methodological differences with this study. For example, two of these studies12 14 were based on patient based rather than population based samples. Furthermore, one of these studies14 identified those with migraine based in part on their use of triptans, which are contraindicated in people with risk factors for cardiovascular disease. The aim of the two studies12 14 was not to compare risk in those with and without migraine but to assess possible risk of triptans in people with migraine. The fact that those two studies showed a protective effect could also explain why a recent meta-analysis of five studies (including those two studies) showed no risk for mortality from cardiovascular disease associated with migraine overall (with and without aura combined) (relative risk 1.03, 0.79 to 1.34).6 Only one study included in that meta-analysis estimated the risk of mortality separately in people with migraine with aura.4 This study suggested that women with migraine with aura were at about twice the risk of cardiovascular mortality compared with women without headache.
The hazard ratios for mortality for cardiovascular disease in men with migraine were somewhat higher than the corresponding values for all cause mortality. The risk was independent of traditional risk factors for cardiovascular disease measured at baseline. Several studies have reported greater risk of stroke in people with migraine1 6 28 than in others, especially for those with aura.1 4 6 28 The risk of coronary heart disease among people with migraine varies more between studies, from being lower than normal to being moderately increased.6 In our study the risk increase for mortality from coronary heart disease was mainly confined to men with migraine with aura.
The increased risk of overall mortality or mortality related to cardiovascular disease associated with migraine with aura is significant but modest: 20% for women and 20% for men, with respect to all cause mortality, and 18% for women and 42% for men, with respect to cardiovascular disease mortality.
We estimated that at age 50 men and women with migraine with aura had a median loss of 1.5 or 1.4 years of life compared with those without headache. By way of comparison with more established risk factors for all cause mortality, the median loss of life in the Reykjavik Study for those with untreated high blood pressure (≥160 mm Hg), type 2 diabetes, and smoking 15 cigarettes or more a day was, respectively, about 5, 5, and 13 years for men and 3, 3, and 9 years for women29 30 (see appendix 3 on bmj.com).
In people with migraine with aura, compared with those without headache, the excess absolute 10 year risk of all cause mortality at age 50 was low: 1.2% for men (8.0% v 6.8% risk of all cause mortality) and 0.6% for women (3.6% v 3.0%). At age 70, the excess absolute risk of all cause mortality in people with migraine with aura was higher, at 5.5% for men (46.1% v 40.6%) and 3.8% for women (27.9% v 24.1%).
Several mechanisms could explain the link between migraine and cardiovascular disease, though none has been definitively established. Migraine and ischaemic events have been linked through a genetic component.31 They might reflect associations between migraine with aura and vasculopathy32 and mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke (MELAS).33 Methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) is an important enzyme in the metabolism of homocysteine, derived from the amino acid methionine, and a risk factor for cerebral small vessel disease34 and migraine.35 Migraine could directly cause an ischaemic event that is from a migrainous infarct, but such events are rare, about 3% of all strokes,36 and can therefore account for only a small proportion of all strokes in people with migraine. There is increasing evidence that migraine is associated with coronary heart disease,4 37 and one study reported an association between migraine and an increased prevalence of conventional vascular risk factors.9 The current data show little difference in risk factors between those with and without migraine, which is in line with previous studies on people with migraine in the Reykjavik Study.7 8 Our results were similar with and without adjustment for conventional risk factors for cardiovascular disease, suggesting that the mechanism(s) linking migraine to cardiovascular disease are from a different pathway. Others have reported that people with migraine, even in the absence of conventional risk factors, are at increased risk of stroke37 and have decreased cerebral and peripheral vascular resistance, retinal microvascular signs, hypercoagulability, and inflammation,31 38 supporting the hypothesis that migraine might be a systemic disorder that is affecting vasculature.39 People with migraine have been shown to have altered vascular reactivity at a young age (under 25 years),40 which indicates that there might be a factor affecting both the onset of migraine and progression of cardiovascular disease early in life. A recent study reported that people with migraine without aura had reduced function and number of endothelial progenitor cells,38 which has been associated with higher Framingham risk scores in people with coronary heart disease41 and increased risk of mortality from cardiovascular disease.42
People with migraine, particularly those with migraine with aura, are at a modestly increased risk of mortality, independent of classic risk factors for cardiovascular disease measured in mid-life. The absolute risk is low, and the focus should be on conventional risk factors, such as hypertension, smoking, and adverse lipid profile, for reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease, regardless of migraine status.
More research is needed on the association between migraine and mortality from cardiovascular disease, non-cardiovascular disease, and all causes, including studies to identify whether there are specific subgroups of people with migraine who are at particular risk because of genetic or environmental factors. Future studies should assess aura status and frequency of attacks in detail, and prospective studies can monitor changes in the risk profile for cardiovascular disease over time to better understand the aetiology and pathophysiology of migraine in its development. Finally, studies are needed to determine if reducing the frequency of attacks with migraine preventive treatment might reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease.
What is already known on the topic
Individuals with migraine with aura (but not without aura) are at almost twice the risk of ischaemic stroke than other people
Individuals with migraine (with and without aura combined) are not at increased risk of death from cardiovascular disease
Compared with women without headache, women with migraine with aura (but not without aura) are at increased risk of death from cardiovascular disease after age 45
What this study adds
Migraine with aura is an independent risk factor for cardiovascular and all cause mortality in both men and women but is weaker than major established risk factors, such as smoking, diabetes, and high blood pressure
Women with migraine with aura were at increased risk of mortality from non-cardiovascular disease
People with migraine, particularly those with aura, were at increased risk of death from coronary heart disease and stroke
Cite this as: BMJ 2010;341:c3966
We thank all the employees of the Icelandic Heart Preventive Clinic (Hjartavernd) for their skilful contribution to the data collection.
Contributors: LSG, AIS, LL, and VG designed the study. LSG and TA analysed the data. LSG and VG drafted the paper. TA and VG acquired the data. LSG and TA take responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis. All authors had access to the data, interpreted the data, critically revised the draft for important intellectual content, and gave final approval of the manuscript to be published. LSG and VG are guarantors.
Funding: This study was funded by the University of Iceland Research Fund. The current study was conducted without any influence from the University of Iceland Research Fund.
Competing interests: All authors have completed the Unified Competing Interest form at www.icmje.org/coi_disclosure.pdf (available on request from the corresponding author) and declare that no company has supported the submitted work; LSG has received a travel grant from the Pharmaceutical Society of Iceland Science Fund, AIS has served on advisory boards for Endo Pharmaceuticals and OrthoMcNeil Neurologics, has received an honorarium and a travel grant from the National Headache Foundation and a travel grant from the American Headache Society; no other relationships or activities that could appear to have influenced the submitted work.
Ethical approval: This study was approved by the Surgeon General’s ethics committee 1969, and informed consent was given by all participants.
Data sharing: No additional data are available.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial License, which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non commercial and is otherwise in compliance with the license. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0/ and http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0/legalcode.