Would you advise anyone to become a doctor?
BMJ 2008; 337 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.a2739 (Published 25 November 2008) Cite this as: BMJ 2008;337:a2739All rapid responses
Rapid responses are electronic comments to the editor. They enable our users to debate issues raised in articles published on bmj.com. A rapid response is first posted online. If you need the URL (web address) of an individual response, simply click on the response headline and copy the URL from the browser window. A proportion of responses will, after editing, be published online and in the print journal as letters, which are indexed in PubMed. Rapid responses are not indexed in PubMed and they are not journal articles. The BMJ reserves the right to remove responses which are being wilfully misrepresented as published articles or when it is brought to our attention that a response spreads misinformation.
From March 2022, the word limit for rapid responses will be 600 words not including references and author details. We will no longer post responses that exceed this limit.
The word limit for letters selected from posted responses remains 300 words.
I enjoyed this thought provoking article.
I am an inveterate promoter of medicine. I teach and
encourage and try to enthuse school students as well as
those in medical school.
When talking to prospective medical students applying to
University I always tell them that I look for the element
of "passion" to become a doctor. I often see it at
interview and later. Somewhere though , many do lose this
enthusiasm.
Medicine is fascinating, rewarding as well as fun and all
the patients who had waited an hour to see me at my pain
clinic which ran late the other night , were pleasant and
appreciative of my time with them.
When anaesthetising a young woman recently she commented
on the way in which we were chatting and laughing with her,
which was very different from the minimal communication
going on in the ward.
Why do others not find pleasure, interest and reward in
their practice?
Over time I have observed that there are many doctors who
lose interest in medicine as a subject and in patients as
people to meet. Some see it as a 9-5 job. Others become
negative to all and sundry and constantly moan although
this is rarely about clinical activity.
Whilst my generation worked far longer hours than the
current one yet the dissatisfaction with the career seems
to be in the latter.
I feel this is something that needs exploring, challenging
etc. I don't know what can be done and I hope we can find a
way to encourage those who are losing interest younger ( I
have a vested interest at my time of life).
Willy Notcutt
Consultant in Anaesthesia and Pain Medicine
Great Yarmouth
Competing interests:
A happy doctor
Competing interests: No competing interests
I think medicine is a great fulfilling career, it requires a good
knowledge of a fairly vast and intricate science, acquisition of multiple
skills, applying the knowledge and the skills that are constantly refined
and practiced in helping patients, which can be extremely rewarding, and
personally fulfilling.
I think to be happy you have to feel good about yourself, and being a
doctor does not fall short of achieving the latter.
Nothing can be more satisfying for a civilised human being than
employing his intelligence, skills, and efforts in helping other fellow
human beings, let alone the respect, the job stability, the financial
security, and the social status being a doctor brings.
Having said that there are some disadvantages of being a doctor which
I believe cannot outweigh the advantages no matter how numerous they are.
Difficulties of being a doctor in General:
1) Guilt and Worry:
Worried doctors might suffer sleepless nights in wonder of whether there
was anything they could have done better or whether they were negligent or
failed to pick up an important clue or symptom.
2) Mistakes:
Doctors are human beings, and they are bound to make mistakes, which can
be as serious as costing a life, therefore; it is their duty to ensure
that they are 100% vigilant and keeping their mind on the job (no matter
how difficult their circumstances are), otherwise they are risking their
patients’ lives by delivering suboptimal care.
3) Frustration:
It can be frustrating sometimes not to reach a conclusive diagnosis (i.e.
no organic cause identifiable) or not to be able to cure the patient (i.e.
metastatic cancer, parkinson’s, MS, MND, CF, etc…)
4) Social life:
Most doctors in their training years are on the move, which makes it
difficult to settle in one place, and even more difficult to build long
term friends and relationships, and if they choose a competitive specialty
their career demands may supersede and overwhelm their social needs.
5) Maintaining knowledge:
being a successful doctor means maintaining a good level of knowledge to
support his/her decisions during his/her daily work, which requires
constant reading as a routine practice, this means that the doctor’s job
does not end at 5 o’clock, but far beyond that.
6) Patient’s expectations:
Doctors are frequently stressed when they face very high or sometimes
false public expectations, which make room for patients’ dissatisfaction,
complaints, and litigations. (At the end doctors cannot perform miracles)
7) Offensive/ rude patients:
Every now and again doctors can encounter an offensive alcoholic patient,
an angry frustrated patient who is not getting immediate care, a
dissatisfied patient who has been waiting a long time to get his scan or
operation done, and unhappy relatives who are not content with management
plans or standards of care.
8) Litigation:
Doctors are always prone to litigations for a variety of reasons (chaperon
issues, poor documentation, improper communications, neglect, prescribing
errors, etc…); hence there are bodies that support doctors in these
situations (MDU, MPS, etc…)
Difficulties of being a junior doctor:
1) Boring/paper work:
Taking bloods, inserting IV cannulas, filling request forms, writing
referrals, writing prescription charts, etc..
2) Hierarchy system:
Sometimes junior doctors have to handle the stress of speaking to an angry
senior for an advice or a patient review, or the stress of persuading the
busy consultant radiologist to perform an urgent CT scan.
also junior doctors are often required to be up to date and able to answer
all the senior’s questions regarding ward patients
3) Career development:
Junior doctors have to ensure that their CV is developing as they go
along, be it a tough exam they have to pass, an expensive course they have
to attend, or a looming deadline they have to deliver on, and if they fail
to show a good progress they may not be promoted or they might not be able
to secure a training post.
4) Extra / long unsociable hours:
Given the humane nature of the profession, junior doctors rarely finish
work on time, it is not uncommon for a junior doctor to be attending to a
sick patient when s/he is supposed to be at home eating his/her pizza and
drinking his/her glass of wine, and doctors rarely keep a log book to
claim all the extra hours they work.
Being on night shift can be depressing and lonely time, as much as being
on call during weekends.
Difficulties of being a Consultant: (consultant surgeon for
instance):
1) Time pressure:
Operating consultants are required to finish their list at the right time
to avoid any unnecessary cancellations and patients/relatives
disappointments, and this can be particularly difficult if they are
required to train their junior registrar or SHO simultaneously.
2) responsibility:
Consultants take the bigger share of responsibility for any mortality or
morbidity occurring in patients under their care which sometimes means
consultants having to attend in court or answer to a complaint filed by
patients or their relatives, equally so, consultants sometimes make a very
difficult decisions regarding patients care, like deciding on the
resuscitation status after discussion with patients, or deciding on
withholding active treatment,
3) Emergencies:
In cases of extreme emergencies consultant surgeons can be called in the
middle of the night to perform an emergency operation,
4) Personal life:
Many specialties require long hours of hard work and devotion, as well as
participation in national and international academic work, which can
prevent consultants from spending a much required time with their families
5) Maintaining efficiency:
Consultants are required to maintain their knowledge and skills up to
date, to ensure a service of high quality, minimal complications and
steady quantity.
Having said that very few doctors regret their choice of career, and
very few doctors are made redundant or left medicine, and even the ones
who do so, I believe they do it because they realise that they chose a
medical career for all the wrong reasons.
Competing interests:
None declared
Competing interests: No competing interests
Relative job security, good pay, respect from the general public:
there are still many good reasons to become a doctor despite the more
cynical views of many members of our profession.
However, more than anything else, I prefer to quote the words of the
eminent British neurosurgeon, Henry Marsh, when people ask me whether they
should study medicine. During the acclaimed BBC documentary "Life in their
Hands" he was shown working long, often stressful hours whilst having to
overcome the many limitations imposed by NHS practice. "Is it worth it?"
he reflected at one point during the programme. "Well a lot of people go
home from work and wonder whether they have made a difference. At least I
don't have that problem."
That, for me, remains a good enough reason to want to be a doctor.
Competing interests:
None declared
Competing interests: No competing interests
Ask to your self if you want to do it
Medicine is one of the most respectable profession in the history of
mankind. But one has to consider few things before going for it. You
should ask yourself "DO U REALLY WANT TO BE A PHYSICIAN?" what were your
DEFAULT area of interest since your childhood e.g some people are good in
artistic work, some are good at technical stuff.. So you are the person
who can guess what is best for you.
After deciding that medicine is your choice who have to keep this thing in
mind that Medicine is not a field where there is a full stop..its an
evolving field and it requires more hard work than most of the other
professions, you get the reward and a big one in terms of finances and
respect but you get it a bit late, with lots of hard work &
exams/boards. But at the end of the day if your really wanted to do it you
ll' love it....
Hammad Akram M.D, M.P.H
Competing interests:
None declared
Competing interests: No competing interests