Intended for healthcare professionals

Student Reviews

Yes, I'm Asian

BMJ 2007; 334 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/sbmj.070143b (Published 01 January 2007) Cite this as: BMJ 2007;334:070143b
  1. Robin Som, final year medical student1
  1. 1Imperial College, London

It's happened often enough to get slightly irksome. I meet someone new; I go through the formalities of small talk; and the question of what I study arises. I say that I'm a medical student. Then there it is-the smirk-followed by, “Oh, I should've guessed.”

Why don't they smirk at him?

This isn't because every time I meet someone I take their history. No, it's because I'm Asian. I'm not paranoid-press the irritant on their reasoning, and they'll honestly state that my ethnicity is the give away.

The assumption that a lot of Asians study medicine, though somewhat unreasonable, should be expected. In 2003, 22% of medical students accepted were Asian-that is, originally from the Indian sub-continent-according to a 2004 BMA discussion paper.

Talking to many medical students, it seems that the freedom to make the choice of medicine or not is race related. Non-Asian medical students normally say that their parents were happy for them to choose whatever course they wanted. The story is different for Asian medics. Those that I have spoken to state that it was medicine and nothing else for them-the consensus being that most courses are disapproved of while medicine is placed on a pedestal. “I wanted to be a teacher, but my parents said that wasn't good enough for me…….medicine would make me unique and better,” said a colleague, because “medicine gives you the respect of others; you'll have a job for life.” Job stability and respect are clearly valued in the Asian community.

There is a perceived hierarchy of subjects that exists in Asians-at the bottom lie …

View Full Text

Log in

Log in through your institution

Subscribe

* For online subscription