Dolly, human cloning, and bioethics
BMJ 2007; 334 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/sbmj.070128 (Published 01 January 2007) Cite this as: BMJ 2007;334:070128- Christos Tziotzios, fifth year medical student1
- 1University of Cambridge
Do you believe in God?
I don't. I describe myself as agnostic.
Which religious or philosophical view is closest to your beliefs?
I emphasise that I am not a philosopher. I would most accurately describe myself as a utilitarian. The basis on which I would consider ethical matters would be to ask what the effects are on people or the environment of what you are proposing to do.
When does life start: conception, day 14, or birth?
Life clearly begins at fertilisation, with the embryo having the potential to become a person. But to make ethical judgments you have to consider whether the value of that human being at fertilisation is the same as after birth. And I believe it is not. It is weeks before the primitive central nervous system forms: cortex and consciousness. The critical stage is clearly when that level is reached. I haven't actually tried to find out, but I don't think that anyone would know when that is. When it comes down to preimplantation embryos, I am confident that it is a long time after that.
Most geneticists think day 14 is the critical point
This is a conservative estimate. All you have then is first germ cells and then the blastocyst, and all you have on day 14 is the beginning of the primitive streak. It will be a long time until you have a functional central nervous system. My assumption would be that the Warnock committee, which decided and recommended this, was trying to establish a conservative boundary to provide reassurance to the public.
The Christian view is that life begins at conception
This …
Log in
Log in using your username and password
Log in through your institution
Subscribe from £184 *
Subscribe and get access to all BMJ articles, and much more.
* For online subscription
Access this article for 1 day for:
£50 / $60/ €56 (excludes VAT)
You can download a PDF version for your personal record.