Intended for healthcare professionals

Student Life

Spotlight on: Get up and NGO

BMJ 2004; 328 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/sbmj.0406250 (Published 01 June 2004) Cite this as: BMJ 2004;328:0406250
  1. Kate Polling1,
  2. Tara Kessaram, medical students intercalating in international health1
  1. 1University College, London

Although having an appealing altruistic ethos attracting inward investment, healthcare aid agencies can actually do more harm than good. Kate Polling and Tara Kessaram look at how non-governmental organisations conduct their work

The work of non-governmental organisations (NGOs) is founded on humanitarian principles that few people would want to question. Although public faith in many other public organisations has declined in the past few decades, a recent report by the National Council for Voluntary Organisations says that charities are still trusted and respected.1 NGOs are perceived as efficient, in touch with the needs of the populations they serve, and necessary to fill voids in state services. This image attracts many medical students who wish to work in health services in developing countries. However, the same organisations have been the target of criticism--described both as “an unruly mélange”2 and “badly out of control… [characterised by] gross naivety and amateurism.”3

NGOs encompass a huge diversity of organisations, but tend to have two features in common--they are mainly independent of governments or inter-governmental agencies, such as the United Nations, and principally have humanitarian rather than commercial interests. They have usually evolved from one of three historical traditions--religious, Dunantist, and Wilsonian.

NGO styles

Religious organisations, such as Christian Aid, originated in missionary work but now do not undertake direct evangelism and usually work to serve all communities. The Wilsonian tradition--named after American president Woodrow Wilson--often characterises US NGOs, and aligns humanitarian objectives with US foreign policy aims. Dunantist organisations--after Red Cross founder Henry Dunant--include Red Cross International and Save the Children. They seek to position themselves outside state interests and express principles of impartiality, neutrality, and independence.4

NGOs involved in health achieve their objectives in two main ways--advocacy and provision of services. As advocates, NGOs can use their experience in the field …

View Full Text

Log in

Log in through your institution

Subscribe

* For online subscription