Long term follow up study of survival associated with cleft lip and palate at birthBMJ 2004; 328 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.38106.559120.7C (Published 10 June 2004) Cite this as: BMJ 2004;328:1405
- Kaare Christensen, professor ()1,
- Knud Juel, senior researcher2,
- Anne Maria Herskind, paediatrician3,
- Jeffrey C Murray, professor4
- 1 Center for the Prevention of Congenital Malformations, Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, DK-5000 Odense, Denmark
- 2 National Institute of Public Health, DK-2100 Copenhagen, Denmark
- 3 Odense University Hospital, Department of Pediatrics, DK-5000 Odense, Denmark
- 4 University of Iowa, Department of Pediatrics, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA
- Correspondence to: K Christensen
- Accepted 1 April 2004
Objective To assess the overall and cause specific mortality of people from birth to 55 years with cleft lip and palate.
Design Long term follow up study.
Setting Danish register of deaths.
Participants People born with cleft lip and palate between 1943 and 1987, followed to 1998.
Main outcome measures Observed and expected numbers of deaths, summarised as overall and cause specific standardised mortality ratios.
Results 5331 people with cleft lip and palate were followed for 170 421 person years. The expected number of deaths was 259, but 402 occurred, corresponding to a standardised mortality ratio of 1.4 (95% confidence interval 1.3 to 1.6) for males and 1.8 (1.5 to 2.1) for females. The increased risk of mortality was nearly constant for the three intervals at follow up: first year of life, 1-17 years, and 18-55 years. The participants had an increased risk of all major causes of death.
Conclusions People with cleft lip and palate have increased mortality up to age 55. Children born with cleft lip and palate and possibly other congenital malformations may benefit from specific preventive health measures into and throughout adulthood.
Children with repairable anomalies such as cleft lip and palate are often presumed to have normal health and survival in adulthood. Some evidence, however, suggests an increased incidence of cancer early in life among children with some congenital malformations, including cleft lip and palate, and it is unknown whether this susceptibility continues into adulthood.1–3 Evidence indicates that parents of children with cleft lip and palate have an increased risk of cancer, which suggests a role for genetic factors.4 Population based studies from Scandinavia have found a higher risk of psychiatric diseases and behavioural problems in adults with cleft lip and palate that are associated with increased morbidity.5 6 We used data from Danish registers to assess the long term prognosis associated with cleft lip and palate, particularly overall mortality and cause specific mortality.
Materials and methods
The Danish cleft lip and palate register is described elsewhere.7–9 We excluded infants with malformations other than cleft lip and palate to eliminate the effect of multiple anomalies on increased mortality. Overall, 6627 people were born with cleft lip and palate in Denmark between 1943 and 1987; 6394 (96%) could be identified through the Danish civil registration system and Danish register of causes of death (see bmj.com for details of these registers). We excluded 1063 (17%) as they had associated anomalies, leaving 5331 people for analysis.
The Danish civil registration system has data on all people residing in Denmark from April 1968 onwards. Individuals are ascribed a unique 10 digit identifier. The register contains information on whether individuals are alive or dead or have emigrated and the date of death or emigration
The Danish register of causes of death contains information on all deaths and causes of death from 1943 to 1998 in Danish residents.15 Cause of death is coded according to revisions of the international classification of diseases: fifth (1943-50), sixth (1951-7), seventh (1958-68), eighth (1969-93), and 10th (1994-8).
We calculated the expected number of deaths by multiplying the observed person years with mortality stratified by sex, one year age groups, and five year calendar period.
We followed 5331 people with cleft lip and palate for a total of 170 421 person years. The expected number of deaths was 259, but 402 occurred: standardised mortality ratio 1.4 (95% confidence interval 1.3 to 1.6) for males and 1.8 (1.5 to 2.1) for females. The increased risk was almost constant for the three intervals of follow up (table 1).
Deaths from cancer (36 v 28 expected) and cardiovascular events (15 v 13 expected) were only marginally increased in people with cleft lip and palate. The risk of suicide, however, was significantly increased and of similar magnitude in both sexes (standardised mortality ratio 1.6). We found no increased risk for deaths due to accidents. Around half of overall deaths were attributed to “other causes.” This category comprised mostly “cleft lip and palate” as the cause of death and mainly deaths within the first year of life. We traced 79 of these death certificates. In 39% of cases cause of death was prematurity, whereas pneumonia and bronchopneumonia accounted for 28% of deaths and postoperative complications for 10%. The remaining cases included asphyxia, aspiration, sepsis, and unknown cause. Other causes of death were mainly attributed to respiratory diseases, infectious diseases, and diseases of the central nervous system. Unlike the other categories which showed increased but non-significant standardised mortality ratios (range 1.2-1.6), mortality due to diseases of the central nervous system showed a significant increased risk for females (9 observed v 2.6 expected). Of the nine cases, six were due to epilepsy (1.2 expected; standardised mortality ratio 8.3, 1.7 to 14.2).
We stratified the analysis for type of anomaly (cleft lip only, cleft lip and palate, cleft palate only). The cleft lip only group had only a slight and non-significant increased risk of mortality, whereas it was significant for those with cleft lip and palate and cleft palate only groups.table 3
Children born with cleft lip and palate and no other known malformations seem to have an increased risk of mortality not only in the first year of life but throughout childhood and adulthood. One explanation could be that we included people with discrete malformations associated with cleft lip and palate. This is unlikely since more than 80% of our cases were described by a surgeon who was a leading expert throughout the period of ascertainment.9 10
Adults with cleft lip and palate have an increased incidence of structural brain anomalies, including major differences in the sizes of the cerebrum and cerebellum associated with mild cognitive impairments.11 Such malformations may predispose to seizures, which were observed as an increased cause of death in this study. These anomalies of the midline are more commonly associated with cleft palate than with cleft lip. This is consistent with the higher risk of early mortality in patients with cleft palate than cleft lip only, as seen in this study. We also observed an increased risk of suicide in both sexes, and recognition of potential risk factors affords opportunities for prevention in people born with birth defects.
The increased risk associated with all major causes of death suggests that the cause of excess mortality is complex and multi-factorial. We did not have information on birth weight and gestational age, and it is possible that such factors could have attenuated the excess mortality for people with cleft lip and palate.
We hypothesised an increased mortality due to cancer on the basis of reports of an increased occurrence of cleft lip and palate in children with leukaemia and an increased risk of cancer in parents of children with cleft lip and palate.817 We found only a marginally increased mortality due to cancer among people with cleft lip and palate compared with the general population. Thus our data do not support these previous observations
Considerable attention is paid to the health of children born with congenital malformations or other disabilities, but this is concentrated on the first years of life. As more infants are surviving serious birth defects into adult life it will be increasingly important to understand the clinical course of these disorders to provide optimal preventive health care and to anticipate treatable causes of morbidity and mortality
What is already known on this topic
Infants with cleft lip and palate have an increased risk of mortality inthe first years of life
Cleft lip and palate may be associated with an increased risk of cancer
What this study adds
Cleft lip and palate is associated with an increased risk of mortality in infancy and up to age 55
The risk of mortality due to cancer is not substantially increased
The increased risk of mortality in people with cleft lip and palate was attributable to all major causes of death
Contributors KC was responsible for the content, conception, and design of the study, data collection and interpretation, drafting of the manuscript, obtaining funding, administrative support, and supervision. He will act as guarantor for the paper. AMH was responsible for part of the content, for conception and design, interpretation of data, critical revision of the manuscript, and technical support. KJ was responsible for part of the content, analysis and interpretation of the data, critical revision of the manuscript, and statistical expertise. JCM was responsible for the clinical perspective of the content, for analysis and interpretation of the data, critical revision of the manuscript, and supervision
Funding The Center for the Prevention of Congenital Malformations is supported by a grant from the Egmont Foundation. The Danish Cleft Lip and Palate Database has received support from the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research (grant No R01 DE 11948) and the Egmont Foundation.
Competing interests None declared
Ethical approval The Danish Scientific-Ethical Committee (project Nos 90/251 and 95/32).