Collusion in doctor-patient communication about imminent death: an ethnographic study
BMJ 2000; 321 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.321.7273.1376 (Published 02 December 2000) Cite this as: BMJ 2000;321:1376
Data supplement
Atypical cases Patients who refused chemotherapy
When Mr A fell ill, he had worked in a university hospital for 25 years. For many years he had transported or accompanied oncology patients from the ward to other places in the hospital (for example, for investigations). Most of these patients had been incurable. Years ago Mr A had decided that he would refuse treatment himself if he ever had an incurable disease.
Mrs B had served coffee on an oncology ward in a regional hospital. She had seen many incurable patients, and she had promised herself not to go through all that misery. She had just divorced and was rather gloomy about her prospects when she was diagnosed as having small cell lung cancer. She told the doctor immediately that she would not accept treatment. A few days later she said she wanted to die. After two weeks she experienced severe pain, which was treated with morphine. Nearly four weeks after the diagnosis she died in hospital.
Mrs C had a long history of coping with diseases such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and rheumatism. One of her legs had been amputated because of vascular disease. She had stayed in a nursing home when her husband could no longer care for her. Mrs C had suffered pain for many years. She refused treatment for her lung cancer and asked for euthanasia instead, which was refused. A week later she suffered tightness in the chest and a terrible pain. She received morphine and died two days later in the hospital.
Patients who did not show false optimism
Mr D was an architect, as his wife. They talked openly about the pressure on their family life due to his imminent death and about what they should do with their joint architecture office when he died. When the researcher relayed to them her interest in communication, Mrs D described spontaneously that she had observed "false hope" in other patients: "It’s incredible, they really seem to believe that they are going to be cured. We knew from the beginning that the therapy was just life prolonging and we wanted that time to settle up things."
Mr E was a retired lawyer. When the doctor told him that only life prolonging treatment was possible, he said that he would accept that option because he wanted to attend some important future events, the opening of his son’s office and the birth of his first grandchild. During his illness trajectory he repeated over and over again that he would be happy if his life could be prolonged only until those two events had happened.
Mrs F was not highly educated herself but her children were, and they had occupations in health care as well. Each time the doctor gave her some "good news" she would express her happiness. This happiness could not evolve into "false optimism" because her children continuously reminded her of what was said in the first (bad news) consultation: "Do you remember what the doctor said? Recovery is not possible."
Related articles
- This Week In The BMJ Published: 02 December 2000; BMJ 321 doi:10.1136/bmj.321.7273.0/c
- Research Published: 10 June 2010; BMJ 340 doi:10.1136/bmj.c2581
- Education And Debate Published: 02 December 2000; BMJ 321 doi:10.1136/bmj.321.7273.1400
- Research Published: 04 April 2011; BMJ 342 doi:10.1136/bmj.d1933
- Feature Published: 06 July 2015; BMJ 351 doi:10.1136/bmj.h3660
- Letter Published: 05 August 2015; BMJ 351 doi:10.1136/bmj.h4125
- Analysis Published: 10 February 2016; BMJ 352 doi:10.1136/bmj.i563
- Letter Published: 29 October 2020; BMJ 371 doi:10.1136/bmj.m4121
See more
- Distilling ethics, compassion, science and the art of medicineBMJ December 05, 2016, 355 i6510; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i6510
- Industry sponsorship—what do patients think?BMJ November 16, 2016, 355 i6010; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i6010
- Can safety-netting improve cancer detection in patients with vague symptoms?BMJ November 09, 2016, 355 i5515; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i5515
- Patient satisfaction with GPs is not related to consultation length, study findsBMJ October 28, 2016, 355 i5744; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i5744
- Rise of the machinesBMJ October 27, 2016, 355 i5777; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i5777
Cited by...
- Awareness of normal risk is not normal
- In defence of hope
- Advance care plans and hospitalized frail older adults: a systematic review
- Complex challenges for patients with protracted incurable cancer: an ethnographic study in a comprehensive cancer centre in the Netherlands
- 'When something is this rare ... how do you know bad really is bad...?--views on prognostic discussions from patients with advanced soft tissue sarcoma
- Training for Medical Oncologists on Shared Decision-Making About Palliative Chemotherapy: A Randomized Controlled Trial
- How Parents of Children With Cancer Learn About Their Childrens Prognosis
- Les besoins des patients avec un cancer en soins palliatifs lors des visites medicales: Une etude qualitative
- Needs of cancer patients in palliative care during medical visits: Qualitative study
- 'I cant tell my child they are dying. Helping parents have conversations with their child
- The patient who 'must not be told: demographic factors associated with collusion in a retrospective study in South India
- An open letter to The BMJ editors on qualitative research
- Outcomes of Prognostic Disclosure: Associations With Prognostic Understanding, Distress, and Relationship With Physician Among Patients With Advanced Cancer
- Twenty top papers--the ones that got away and the results of the top six poll
- Confronting Therapeutic Failure: A Conversation Guide
- Qualitative approach to patient-reported outcomes in oncology: protocol of a French study
- Parental Hope for Children With Advanced Cancer
- Discussing prognosis and end-of-life care in the final year of life: a randomised controlled trial of a nurse-led communication support programme for patients and caregivers
- Medical Expertise and Patient Involvement: A Multiperspective Qualitative Observation Study of the Patient's Role in Oncological Decision Making
- A retrospective analysis of factors associated with selection of end-of-life care and actual place of death for patients with cancer
- Communicating About Prognosis: Ethical Responsibilities of Pediatricians and Parents
- Social, psychological and existential well-being in patients with glioma and their caregivers: a qualitative study
- It Takes a Village
- Information of Imminent Death or Not: Does It Make a Difference?
- Understanding provision of chemotherapy to patients with end stage cancer: qualitative interview study
- Parents' Roles in Decision Making for Children With Cancer in the First Year of Cancer Treatment
- Understanding provision of chemotherapy to patients with end stage cancer: qualitative interview study
- What Patients Value When Oncologists Give News of Cancer Recurrence: Commentary on Specific Moments in Audio-Recorded Conversations
- Archetypal trajectories of social, psychological, and spiritual wellbeing and distress in family care givers of patients with lung cancer: secondary analysis of serial qualitative interviews
- Doctor-Patient Communication: A Review
- What Are Terminally Ill Cancer Patients Told About Their Expected Deaths? A Study of Cancer Physicians' Self-Reports of Prognosis Disclosure
- Values Parents Apply to Decision-Making Regarding Delivery Room Resuscitation for High-Risk Newborns
- Management of hope
- Decision-making in patients with advanced cancer compared with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
- Hope and Prognostic Disclosure
- Communication About Prognosis Between Parents and Physicians of Children With Cancer: Parent Preferences and the Impact of Prognostic Information
- Practice of expert critical care nurses in situations of prognostic conflict at the end of life.
- Discussing Prognosis: "How Much Do You Want to Know?" Talking to Patients Who Are Prepared for Explicit Information
- Defining Cancer Patients As Being in the Terminal Phase: Who Receives a Formal Diagnosis, and What Are the Effects?
- Necessary Collusion: Prognostic Communication With Advanced Cancer Patients
- Patient-physician communication about end-of-life care for patients with severe COPD
- Dying of lung cancer or cardiac failure: prospective qualitative interview study of patients and their carers in the community
- Role of Health-Related Quality of Life in Palliative Chemotherapy Treatment Decisions
- Enhancing Physician-Patient Communication
- Other Articles Noted
- Collusion in doctor-patient communication