Includes two groups at particular risk: people of non-white ethnicity and children/teens
Rates of drowning deaths in US states that more comprehensively regulate open water swim sites are three to four times lower than in states without any such policies, reveals research published online in the journal Injury Prevention.
And that includes two groups at particular risk of open water drowning: people of non-white ethnicity and children/teens.
The data show that open water areas, such as lakes, rivers, and the ocean, are the most common sites for drowning for those over 5 years of age in the US.
To try and minimise the risks associated with open water swimming, various sites have been designated for recreational swimming. But it’s not clear what impact legislation, where it exists, might have on drowning death rates at these sites.
To explore this further, the researchers collected information on all unintentional drowning deaths occurring between 2008 and 2014 from the Center for Disease Control’s (CDC) Current Multiple Causes of Death database.
They focused on the 20 states with the highest rates, and the 10 with the lowest rates, of drowning deaths at open water sites.
They used CDC population data to calculate the annual drowning rates for everyone over the age of 5, as well as for people of non-white ethnicity and children and teens up to the age of 17.
They looked at the existence of regulations for open water safety and quality in each of these states to see if there were any discernible patterns.
They specifically looked at: water quality monitoring; availability of rescue and safety equipment; presence of lifeguards; signage; and the infrastructure for surveillance and planning as these five policy areas have been identified as critical.
Between 2012 and 2017, 10,839 people drowned at open water swim sites in the 30 states included in the analysis.
The highest open water drowning rates were primarily in north western and south eastern states, with the highest rates in Hawaii, Alaska, Idaho and Wyoming. The lowest rates were in Rhode Island, New York, and Delaware.
Less than half of the states studied (40%; 12) had regulations for open water swim sites. And only 4 states--Illinois, New York, West Virginia and New Jersey had four to five regulations in place.
But the total number of regulations was consistently associated with drowning rates at open water swim sites, with the lowest rates in states with more regulations, and the highest rates in states with the fewest regulations.
Regulations were also associated with lower open water drowning rates in two groups particularly at risk: those of non-white ethnicity and children/teens up to the age of 17.
Compared with states with all five policy area regulations in place, those with none had open water drowning rates that were three times higher among children and teens and rates that were more than four times higher among people of non-white ethnicity.
Signage and water quality were not associated with lower open water drowning rates, but after taking account of influential factors, such as total water area coverage and poverty, surveillance and planning were associated with a 45% reduction in drowning rates.
Lifeguard presence was also significantly associated with a 33% lower drowning rate.
This is an observational study, and as such, can’t establish cause, added to which the researchers looked only at rates in 30 states and didn’t consider non-fatal incidents associated with open water swimming.
Nevertheless, the findings prompt the researchers to conclude: “States interested in lowering their open water drowning rates, especially among high-risk populations, could evaluate their existing regulations and consider implementation of these regulations.”
Notes for editors
Research: Association of designated open water swim area regulations and open water drowning rates doi 10.1136/injuryprev-2019-043464
Journal: Injury Prevention
Funding: Seattle Children’s Research Institute
Link to Academy of Medical Sciences labelling system
Peer reviewed? Yes
Evidence type: Observational
Link to paper:
If you are a journalist needing to speak to an expert, please click here.Browse our Expert Media Panel
Latest coverage of BMJ in the national and international mediaSEE BMJ IN THE NEWS
If you are a journalist who would like to receive our press releases, please provide your details.GET THE LATEST PRESS RELEASES
Email the UK media relations team for more information.CONTACT US TODAY