Essential protections will be lost if government plans go ahead
Brexit’s Great Repeal Bill will axe the right to health, warn experts in The BMJ today.
Peter Roderick and Allyson Pollock from the Institute of Health and Society at Newcastle University, argue that “the fundamental right to health in the UK will be lost if the government proceeds with its plan not to convert the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights into UK law, as announced in the white paper on the Great Repeal Bill.”
They explain how the value of this charter was shown last year, in both EU and UK courts, when the tobacco industry unsuccessfully challenged the new rules on plain packaging of cigarettes.
One of the industry’s arguments was that the rules violated its rights. But both the EU Court of Justice and the High Court in London used the right to health in article 35 of the charter as a counter weight to that argument.
“The government’s proposal not to maintain the fundamental rights charter means that after Brexit it will not be possible for a UK judge to use article 35 or other charter rights when interpreting UK laws that have derived from the EU,” they write.
“These include laws to protect public health such as on pesticide residues in food, health and safety at work, management and disposal of hazardous substances, regulation of medicinal products, and air and water quality.”
They argue that the change “will considerably weaken the ability of judges in future to uphold the law if it is challenged by industry in the courts” and they raise concerns about the arguments put forward by the government to support its intention to dispense with the charter.
“The real protections for public health and inequalities that the charter represents will be set aside if the present government is re-elected in June and its plan to ditch the charter goes ahead,” they warn.
And they urge all those concerned about public health and social solidarity “to ask their parliamentary candidates to oppose the government’s plan and to amend the Great Repeal Bill after the election in order to keep the charter’s protections.”
Note to Editors
Editorial: Brexit’s Great Repeal Bill will axe the right to health https://www.bmj.com/content/
If you are a journalist needing to speak to an expert, please click here.Browse our Expert Media Panel
Latest coverage of BMJ in the national and international mediaSEE BMJ IN THE NEWS
If you are a journalist who would like to receive our press releases, please provide your details.GET THE LATEST PRESS RELEASES
Email the UK media relations team for more information.CONTACT US TODAY