International action needed to ensure the quality of medicines and tackle the fake drugs trade

Tuesday, November 13, 2012 - 12:01

Substandard and fake medicines harm and kill patients - urgent action needed to tackle this scandal, say experts

A global treaty is urgently needed to tackle the deadly trade of substandard and fake medicines, say leading experts in a paper published on bmj.com today.

Their call comes just days before 100 World Health Organisation member states hold their first meeting to discuss the problem, and the authors hope it will help to influence the debate and lead to some concrete actions.

The lethal meningitis outbreak in the US due to contaminated steroid injections has again highlighted the serious consequences of this global problem. Other recent examples include a heart medicine containing a toxic overdose of a malaria drug, which led to 125 deaths in Pakistan, and a fake cancer medicine containing starch and acetone trafficked to Canada and the US. The extent of harm to patients is still unknown.

Substandard and fake medicines harm and kill patients, write an international group of experts led by Amir Attaran from the University of Ottawa in Canada, with the help of the World Federation of Public Health Associations, International Pharmaceutical Federation and the International Council of Nurses.

In poor countries, the World Health Organisation estimates that over 10% of medicines may be “counterfeit” and, although medicine safety is better in rich countries, fake drugs still cause thousands of adverse reactions and some deaths. In the European Union medicines are now the leading illegitimate product seized at the border, increasing 700% from 2010 to 2011.

Yet despite years of debate, no agreement on how best to tackle this scandal has been reached, they argue.

They say that progress on the twin challenges of safeguarding the quality of genuine medicine and criminalising falsified ones “has been held back by controversy over intellectual property rights and confusion over terms.”

They believe that to move forward, several challenges must first be overcome.

For example, anti-counterfeiting laws must shift from protecting commercial interests to protecting public health interests; there must be clear, internationally agreed definitions for different types of illegitimate medicines; and more transparent surveillance and research is needed to measure the global scale of the problem.

“We argue that tackling the challenges of poor quality, unsafe medicines requires a comprehensive global strategy on which all stakeholders agree,” say the authors.

They point to other global treaties, for example on human trafficking or money laundering, that “have helped governments strengthen their laws and cooperate internationally to clamp down on the havens.”

They also point out that under today’s leading public health treaty – the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) - the law is now tougher on fake tobacco than on fake medicines.

They urge WHO to embark on a similar process to that used to create the FCTC, which they believe “avoids unnecessary controversy and can better enable governments, companies, advocates, and the health professions to protect the public’s health.”

Contact:

Amir Attaran, Canada Research Chair in law, population health, and global development policy, University of Ottawa, Canada
Mobile (please note, Ottawa is five hours behind UK time): +1 613 276 7687
Email: aattaran@uottawa.ca

THIS WEEK'S POLL