BMJ editor urges Roche to fulfil promise to release Tamiflu trial data

Tuesday, October 30, 2012 - 12:19

Journal launches open data campaign to compel greater accountability in healthcare

BMJ Editor-in-chief, Dr Fiona Godlee, has urged pharmaceutical giant Roche to honour the promise it made almost three years ago and release key Tamiflu trial data for independent scrutiny.

In an open letter to company director, Professor Sir John Bell, she says: “Billions of pounds of public money have been spent on [Tamiflu] and yet the evidence on its effectiveness and safety remains hidden from appropriate and necessary independent scrutiny.”

The letter is published on the BMJ’s website (bmj.com/tamiflu) alongside correspondence by the Cochrane team with Roche, the US Centres for Disease Control (CDC) and the World Health Organisation (WHO), as part of an open data campaign aimed at persuading Roche to give doctors and patients access to the full data on Tamiflu.

Dr Godlee's letter follows recent reports that the European Medicines Agency (EMA) has initiated infringement proceedings against Roche to investigate deficiencies in safety reporting, including the processing of around 80,000 reports on suspected adverse drug reactions.

Dr Godlee is also one of 28 signaturies to a letter published in The Times today (thetimes.co.uk/letters) calling on drug companies to “come clean” and make clinical trial data for all drugs in current use available to healthcare professionals.

Pressure from politicians is also mounting. Last week, Sarah Wollaston, a GP and Conservative MP, raised the issue of missing data in Parliament, while Health Minister Norman Lamb has agreed to meet experts to discuss the issue of access to clinical trial data.

In December 2009, Roche made a public promise to release full clinical trial reports of its antiviral drug oseltamivir (Tamiflu) in response to a major investigation by the BMJ and researchers Peter Doshi and Tom Jefferson from the Cochrane Collaboration.

The investigation found no clear evidence that Tamiflu prevents complications like pneumonia in healthy people. It also raised serious concerns about access to drug data, the use of ghost writers in drug trials, and the drug approval process.

Since the investigation, some further data have been released to the Cochrane reviewers, but the full data set has still not been provided.

The Cochrane reviewers now know that there are at least 123 trials of Tamiflu and that the majority (60%) of patient data from Roche Phase 3 completed treatment trials remain unpublished. Their main concerns relate to “the likely overstating of effectiveness and the apparent under-reporting of potentially serious adverse effects.”

Meanwhile, Tamiflu has been a great commercial success for Roche and has been added to the World Health Organisation’s list of essential medicines.

In her letter, Dr Godlee appeals to Professor Bell “to bring your influence to bear on your colleagues on Roche’s board.” She adds: “In refusing to release these data of enormous public interest, you put Roche outside the circle of responsible pharmaceutical companies. Releasing the data would do a great deal to restore confidence in your company and its board of directors.”

In a response not for publication, Professor Bell said he has referred the matter to Roche and is awaiting a response.

“The open correspondence on bmj.com aims to hold specific individuals and organisations to account,” writes Dr Godlee in an accompanying editorial. “Their actions are preventing independent scrutiny of the results of clinical trials and putting patients’ lives at risk. We also hope it will contribute to a sea change in the public mood.”

A poll on bmj.com last week asked: "Who is mainly at fault for denying access to negative clinical trial results?" Of the 569 votes, 69% said pharma, 13.5% said regulators, and 9% said legislators.

The BMJ plans to launch other campaigns linked to its investigations in the future.

Contacts:

Fiona Godlee, Editor-in-Chief, BMJ, London, UK
Tel (via BMJ Group Press Office): +44 (0)20 7383 6920
Email: sburns@bmjgroup.com

Tom Jefferson, Coordinator, Cochrane Acute Respiratory Infections Group, Rome, Italy
Tel (mobile): +39 329 202 5051
Email: jefferson.tom@gmail.com

Peter Doshi, Postdoctoral Fellow, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Tel (mobile): +1 617 407 3019
Email: pnd@jhu.edu

Click here to see all the open correspondence: bmj.com/tamiflu

THIS WEEK'S POLL