BMJ
Home Help Search/Archive Feedback Table of Contents

This week in the BMJ

Volume 316, Number 7143, Issue of 16 May 1998
©1999 by The British Medical Journal


[Down]Some small for gestational age fetuses have higher risk of late fetal death than others
[Down]Case upheld for four layer bandaging for leg ulcers
[Down]Women may not be receiving most effective pacemakers
[Down]Rates of depression among men in Scotland have risen since 1980
[Down]Danish out of hours service is working well
[Down]More diabetics are being reviewed in general practice but without a proportionate decline in secondary care

Some small for gestational age fetuses have higher risk of late fetal death than others

In small for gestational age fetuses, without congenital malformations, constitutionally small fetuses---for example twins or the fetuses of short mothers---have been assumed to at lower risk of late fetal death than fetuses affected by conditions such as pre-eclampsia or cigarette consumption. Cnattingius et al (p 1483) tested that assumption in over 1 million births in the Swedish birth register. Overall, late fetal mortality was increased in women who were over 35, nulliparous, smoked, or were =<155 cm tall and greatly increased in those with pre-eclampsia, essential hypertension, and twin pregnancies. But in very small for gestational age fetuses death rates were lower in women aged under 35, =<155 cm tall, with twins, or with severe eclampsia or hypertension.    

[To top]

Case upheld for four layer bandaging for leg ulcers

Compression treatment is recommended to promote healing of venous leg ulcers, and early work in Charing Cross showed that a four layer compression bandage achieved a high rate of healing (74%) in 2 weeks. The cost of effective bandages, however, has meant that this has not been a viable option in the home. On p 1487 Morrell et al evaluate the cost effectiveness of four layer compression bandaging in community based clinics in a randomised controlled trial in Trent. The healing rates in the clinics were greater than in the control group, who received standard treatment at home, and no significant difference was found in mean total NHS costs. The authors suggest that for patients who are willing to travel, an effective leg ulcer service could be provided in community clinics at a reduced cost.    

[To top]

Women may not be receiving most effective pacemakers

The sex of patients has been shown to influence the management of cardiovascular disorders. Schüppel et al evaluated the effect of sex on doctors' choice of pacemaker in a large German database (p 1492). Women were more likely to receive single chamber pacemakers and less likely to receive dual chamber or rate responsive systems than men. This remained true even after demographic and clinical variables were controlled for. The reason for the apparent discrimination could not be determined from the study.

[To top]

Rates of depression among men in Scotland have risen since 1980

With an increase in the number of suicides among men, Shajahan and Cavanagh hypothesised that there would be a fall in the ratio of the number of women to men admitted to Scottish hospitals for depression from 1980 to 1995---a period of socioeconomic change. On p 1496 they show that the rate of admission for depression fell among women from 6.1/10 000 in 1980 to 5.3 in 1995 and rose among men from 3.1 to 3.5. This finding confirms other studies, and the authors conclude that the rise in prevalence is genuine and not just a result of changes in diagnostic practice.

[To top]

Danish out of hours service is working well

The out of hours service in Denmark (population 5.2m) was reformed at the beginning of 1992. All 15 counties now have a coordination centre where all patients' calls are triaged by general practitioners, who decide whether the patient needs a home visit, a consultation in an out of hours consultation room, or telephone advice. One of the main reasons for the reform was the huge out of hours workload for general practitioners, and this has decreased considerably since 1992. On p 1502 Christensen and Olesen outline the main points of the reform and describe its effects on number of out of hours services, workload of general practitioners, cost of the service, and patient satisfaction.

[To top]

More diabetics are being reviewed in general practice but without a proportionate decline in secondary care

Various measures have encouraged the provision of diabetes care in general practice in Britain. On p 1505 Goyder et al examined data on patients with diabetes in five general practices in Leicester in 1990-5 to see if the proportion reviewed in general practice had risen. Overall the proportion having their annual review in general practice rose from 17% (of 282) in 1990 to 35% (of 514) in 1995 while the proportion seen in outpatient clinics fell only from 35% to 30%; the proportion reviewed in neither setting fell from 54% to 37%. The authors conclude that previously unmet needs are being met rather than care shifted from primary care.

[To top]


Home Help Search/Archive Feedback Table of Contents

Copyright © 1999 by the British Medical Journal.