Bed bug infestationBMJ 2013; 346 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f138 (Published 22 January 2013) Cite this as: BMJ 2013;346:f138
- Celine Bernardeschi, dermatologist1,
- Laurence Le Cleach, dermatologist1,
- Pascal Delaunay, parasitologist-entomologist2,
- Olivier Chosidow, professor of dermatology13
- 1AP-HP, Groupe Hospitalier Henri-Mondor, Department of Dermatology, Créteil, France
- 2Laboratoire de Parasitologie-Mycologie, Hôpital de l’Archet, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Nice-Université de Nice-Sophia Antipolis/Inserm U1065, Nice, France
- 3UPEC-Université Paris Est-Créteil Val-de-Marne, France
- Correspondence to: O Chosidow, Service de Dermatologie, Hôpital Henri-Mondor, 51, avenue du Maréchal-de-Lattre-de-Tassigny, 94010 Créteil Cedex, France
- Accepted 3 January 2013
Bed bug infestation seems to be re-emerging worldwide
The diagnosis of bed bug infestation starts with consultation for clinical reactions to bites but symptoms vary greatly
Suspect bed bug bites whenever a patient consults for papules positioned in groups of three or four bites forming a “breakfast-lunch-dinner” curve or line
Eradication requires patient education and the help of pest eradication professionals to identify pests and perform non-chemical and chemical interventions
Bed bugs are bloodfeeding insects that seem to be resurging in developed countries,1 possibly due to international travel and changes in pest control practices.2 Diagnosis of bed bug infestation relies on clinical manifestations of bites and direct observation of the arthropod, which is rarely recognised by those who are bitten.3 Evidence is lacking on the bed bug’s capacity to transmit disease, management of eradication, and the economic impact of infestations. This summary of the available evidence on the diagnosis and management of bed bug infestation aims to help general practitioners identify the clinical signs of bed bug bites and help patients identify and manage infestations.
Sources and selection criteria
We focused on articles published since October 2008 to update Goddard and colleagues’ systematic review.2 We searched PubMed and Embase databases until July 2012, using the search terms “bedbugs [Mesh] OR bed bugs OR bed bug OR Cimex”. We also manually searched textbooks, newspapers, and websites, mainly those listed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (www.cdc.gov/nceh/ehs/topics/bedbugs.htm). Our selection criteria were case reports on more than five patients, and results related to humans in the field of prevention and elimination of bed bugs or clinical manifestations of their bites.
What are bed bugs?
The two main species of bed bugs are Cimex lectularius and Cimex hemipterus, which are found in tropical zones and temperate areas, respectively. They are brown, wingless, flat, 2-5 mm long insects that resemble apple seeds. If in doubt, contact an entomologist for precise identification. The bugs have a multi-stage developmental life cycle and require a human blood meal every 3-5 days to progress from one stage to another (fig 1⇓).1 After contamination by a few bed bugs, their number increases exponentially. They can survive for one year without eating.
Where are bed bugs found?
Over the past 10 years, bed bugs—which had almost disappeared after the second world war—have increasingly been found in low budget and upmarket hotels, hostels, bed and breakfasts, private homes, night trains, cruise ships, and even nursing homes.1 4
Bed bugs are usually transported passively, mainly in clothing and luggage, but also on furniture (such as mattresses). Less commonly, they spread actively from room to room in communities, mostly through electric wiring or ventilation ducts. During the day they hide in dark places—such as spaces under baseboards, loose or peeling wallpaper, and crevices in furniture and mattresses—and they feed at night. They fear light and usually avoid smooth or glossy surfaces, such as tiles.2 Despite being easily visible, most people cannot recognise bed bugs—in a survey conducted in three counties in the United Kingdom, only 10% of 358 people identified them from pictures (fig 2⇓).3
How common are bed bug infestations?
The idea of a resurgence is based on Australian and European observational studies that have shown increases in pest manager interventions (700% increase between 1997-2000 and 2001-04 in Australia, 100% rise from 2002 (383 cases) to 2006 (770 cases) in Sweden). There were also increases in calls received about bed bugs in two London boroughs between 2000 (87 calls) and 2006 (334 calls), and more inquiries about species (nine samples of bed bugs submitted to the Department of Medical Entomology, Institute of Clinical Pathology and Westmead Hospital, Sydney, Australia in 1997 compared with 37 samples in 2000). The identification of bed bugs in Australian laboratories also increased between 2001 and 2004 as did the number of bed bugs intercepted by Australian customs officials between 1999 and 2003.5 6 7
The reasons for this resurgence are unknown. Contributing factors may include increased domestic and international travel.8 As a consequence, bed bugs, which were most common among the disadvantaged social classes in the first half of the last century, can now be encountered in all economic contexts. Other factors are enhanced resistance to pyrethroid insecticides,2 9 perhaps because of multiple mutations conferring metabolic resistance,10 and the fact that newer techniques for controlling cockroaches with bait do not kill bed bugs.11
What are the symptoms of bed bug infestation?
Because bed bugs feed at night and inject an anaesthetic when biting, the initial bite is not felt and most patients have no reaction; moreover, symptom onset, caused by allergic reactions to saliva, can be delayed.2 In 2009, an ethics committee approved experiment,12 conducted by laboratory scientists who volunteered to be bitten by bed bugs placed on their arms, confirmed that reactions to bites manifest up to 11 days later. In a recent questionnaire based study, only 30% of people living in bed bug infested households reported skin reactions.13
A 2009 systematic review of 18 articles on clinical reactions to bed bug bites reported the most common reactions to be 2-5 mm pruritic maculopapular lesions with a central haemorrhagic punctum, corresponding to the bite site, that are usually located on uncovered areas of the body.2 Skin lesions, such as three or four bites forming a curve or line (“breakfast-lunch-dinner alignment,” fig 3A⇓), are suggestive of but not specific to bed bugs. Other cutaneous symptoms include isolated pruritis, papules, nodules (fig 3B), and bullous eruptions (fig 3C).14
Some isolated case reports have reported systemic reactions, such as diffuse urticaria (fig 3D), asthma, and anaphylaxis.2 Bed bug infestation is usually looked for after a clinical diagnosis of bed bug bites. Similar symptoms in people sharing a bed, onset of the lesions after travelling or sleeping away from home, detection of bed bug faecal matter (small dark marks) in or around the bed, or disappearance of symptoms after changing sleeping place should trigger suspicion of infestation. However, the discovery of bed bugs on site confirms active infestation.
What are the differential diagnoses of bed bug bites?
The most common differential diagnoses are other arthropod bites,15 especially those of fleas, which form similar three or four bite lines or curves. Scabies can be confounding but differs from bed bug bites by the absence of visible puncta and the predominance of scratching in sites such as forearms, nipples, and genitals (table 1⇓).
In addition to arthropod bites, there are several dermatological differential diagnoses.16 These include erythema multiforme, which is characterised by target lesions on the extremities, and, sometimes, mucous membrane erosions; Sweet’s syndrome or acute febrile neutrophilic dermatosis, which includes papulonodular lesions on the extremities associated with general symptoms, such as arthralgias, fever, and leucocytosis; bullous dermatitis, which can affect the mucous cavities and unlike bed bug bites, can be seen on covered areas of the body; and vasculitis, which is characterised by polymorphous lesions, usually on the lower limbs, and sometimes affecting several organs. When such manifestations are seen, refer the patient to a dermatologist for further investigations, including a skin biopsy, if necessary.
What complications can arise from bed bug infestations?
Scratching can cause secondary infection—usually Staphylococcus aureus or Streptococcus spp—of skin lesions (usually impetigo).17
Evidence for disease transmission is less clear. Some pathogens have been detected in or on bed bugs. These include hepatitis B virus, Trypanosoma cruzi,1 hepatitis C virus,18 HIV,2 Aspergillus spp, and, more recently, meticillin resistant S aureus,19 but no study has yet demonstrated their vectorial role—their capacity to transmit diseases to humans.1
The psychological burden of bed bug infestation remains to be evaluated.
Although the economic impact is not known, bed bugs result in loss of productivity and costs include those of pest managers’ interventions and replacement of infested furniture.11
How are bed bug infestations managed?
Bed bug control is difficult, mainly because of the parasite’s hiding behaviour, and also because chemical and non-chemical technologies need to be combined for optimal effect.1 “Integrated pest management (IPM)” combines detection of the pest with non-chemical and chemical elimination strategies.
A randomised study conducted in 16 highly infested dwellings, divided into two groups, compared IPM using traps containing a killing agent and chemical treatment with diatomaceous earth dust (D-IPM) versus IPM in which bed bugs were sprayed with chlorfenapyr (S-IPM) but traps were not used.20 Both groups received patient targeted information provided by a brochure. They were also given advice on searching mattresses for hiding bugs; laundering bed linens weekly; and steaming floors, bed frames, sofas, and other infested furniture and sites. Insecticides were applied every two weeks over 10 weeks. Bed bug counts decreased by 97.6% and 89.7% after the intervention in the S-IPM and D-IPM groups, respectively.
Such eradication strategies were grouped together in documents called “Codes of practice” written by experts in Europe, the United States, and Australia,21 but their use, although recommended by some municipalities, is not mandatory.
How should bed bug bites be treated?
Guidelines based on expert opinions recommend treating the symptoms of bed bug bites with topical steroids (such as hydrocortisone 1%) once or twice a day for no longer than seven days.22 Prescribe systemic antihistamines only when pruritis is associated with sleeping difficulties.22 Antibiotics, either topical (such as mupirocin or fusidic acid three times a day for 7-10 days) or systemic, might be needed for secondary impetigo, depending on its severity.23
How can bed bugs be identified and eradicated?
Professionals need to educate patients on how to identify bed bugs and prevent spread (box). GPs can educate patients to use a “search and destroy” strategy by providing basic knowledge about the parasite. They should stress that each insect needs to bite a human every three to five days to grow and reproduce but can survive for one year without feeding, and how to detect and identify the arthropod (fig 4A⇓) or its faecal traces (fig 4B) in suspected areas, mostly mattresses and cracks and crevices in wooden furniture. This detection strategy should be applied whenever travelling.
Look for brown insects no bigger than apple seeds on the mattress, sofa, and curtains and in darker places in the room (especially cracks in the walls, crevices in box springs, and furniture)
Look for black spots on the mattress or blood traces on the sheets
Contact a pest management company
Wash clothes at 60°C or freeze delicate clothing, vacuum, and clean your home before the pest manager visits
Collaborate with professionals who are used to dealing with bed bug infestation to increase eradication efficacy
Carefully examine secondhand furniture to assure the absence of bed bugs before purchase so as not to contaminate your home
When sleeping in a hotel, even an upmarket establishment, lift mattresses to look for bed bugs or black spots
Do not leave luggage in dark places, near furniture, or close to your bed. Before going to bed, close suitcases and put them in the bathroom—in the bathtub or shower stall
Small case series suggest that washing at 60°C, tumble drying at 40°C, or dry cleaning is effective against all life stages.24 A recent trial also suggested that freezing can be used to decontaminate infested clothing.24 However, because bed bugs can survive for up to one year without feeding, keeping an infested room vacant is not an effective option.1 Disposal of highly infested items, together with physical removal of bed bugs and mattress covers and vacuuming, are recommended by pest managers’ codes of practice,21 even though scientific evidence of their efficacy is lacking.
The silicates (mostly diatomaceous earth dust) are somewhere between non-chemical and chemical treatments, and require further investigation before being used in pest management programmes.20
Although insecticides can be bought in supermarkets and on the internet, for efficacy and safety reasons they must be used only by professionals. Clinicians should be aware that misuse of insecticides may have clinical consequences. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recently identified 111 cases of illness attributed to insecticide misuse in an attempt to control bed bugs.25 Pyrethroids were implicated in 89% of those events and caused neurological, respiratory, and gastrointestinal symptoms.
The three main groups of currently used insecticides for bed bug infestations are pyrethroids (the most common),26 insect growth regulators, and carbamates. The organophosphates, like dichlorvos, are no longer used in Europe except in impregnated strips.27 Several large well conducted experimental studies have found high levels of bed bug resistance to all available products.9 28 Moreover, product formulation may influence their efficacy—a laboratory study showed that pyrethroid dusts kill bed bugs more effectively than sprays.29
Because of different resistance levels among bed bugs, a combination of insecticides should be applied to all harbourage areas: mattress seams; cracks in furniture, box springs, and bed frames; peeling wallpaper; and under carpets and floorboards.21
It is unclear how often these techniques should be applied, but because insecticides have a limited ovicidal effect, expert guidelines recommend a second look by the pest manager, with eventual retreatment 4-20 days after the first intervention. The length of this waiting time depends on the average temperature of the infested site.
How can infestation be prevented?
Evidence is lacking about the effectiveness of prevention procedures. Experts recommend washing mattress encasement and bed linens at temperatures above 60°C,21 and advise against purchasing second hand mattresses or furniture. However, it is not recommended that mattresses are pretreated with insecticides or preventive insecticide applications.
Early detection of the bed bugs may be an effective way to prevent their spread. Notably, experimental studies have shown the efficacy of bed bug traps in attracting the parasites, especially when combined with carbon dioxide and heat,30 but their ability to control infestation without the addition of chemical techniques has not been assessed. Results of a comparative study indicated that canine detection may be an option but is operator dependent,31 and further evaluation of this method is needed.
Tips for non-specialists
Inform patients who are about to travel of the resurgence of bed bugs and teach them how to recognise the arthropod
Suspect bed bug infestations in patients who consult for pruritic linear papules, especially when similar symptoms are found in people sharing a bed, and onset of the lesions after travelling or sleeping away from home Look for atypical skin reactions (blisters, crusts, necrosis) or general symptoms (fever) that may justify skin biopsy or further dermatological investigations
Encourage infested patients to call a pest manager as soon as the pest has been identified
Prescribe a mild potency topical steroid treatment once or twice a day for seven days to treat symptomatic bed bug bites
Additional educational resources
Resources for healthcare professionals
University of Kentucky (www.ca.uky.edu/entomology/entfacts/entfactpdf/ef636.pdf)—Comprehensive lesson on bed bugs
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (www.cdc.gov/nceh/ehs/topics/bedbugs.htm)—Link to various articles on bed bugs
NHS Choices (http://nhs.uk/conditions/bites-insect/pages/introduction.aspx)—Clinical knowledge summary about insect bites
Resources for patients
Easing bedbug anxiety: what you need to know about the recent bedbug resurgence. Harvard’s Women’s Health Watch 2011;18:7
Up to Date (www.uptodate.com/contents/bedbugs?source=search_result&search=bedbugs&selectedTitle=1~10)—Provides accurate general knowledge about bed bugs
Bed-Bugs.co.uk (http://bed-bugs.co.uk/)—Provides an interesting picture gallery of bed bugs and their bites, together with practical tips for eradication
Pest Control UK (www.pestcontrol-uk.org/pests/bed-bugs)—DIY control of bed bugs
Questions for future research
What are the risk factors for bed bug infestation?
What are the psychological complications of bed bug bites?
Can bed bugs transmit diseases to humans?
What is the best eradication strategy?
What are the mechanisms of pesticide resistance?
Are prevention approaches (sniffing dogs, resin strips, traps) effective?
Cite this as: BMJ 2013;346:f138
Acknowledgments: Thanks to Tu-Anh Duong, Arnaud Canet, Sebastien Larréché, and Pierre Wolkenstein for their collaboration and Janet Jacobson for editorial assistance.
Contributors: OC conceived the project, which was drafted by CB and revised by all authors. OC finally approved the article. All authors are guarantors.
Funding: No special funding received.
Competing interests: All authors have completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form at www.icmje.org/coi_disclosure.pdf (available on request from the corresponding author) and declare: no support from any organisation for the submitted work; no financial relationships with any organisations that might have an interest in the submitted work in the previous three years; no other relationships or activities that could appear to have influenced the submitted work.
Provenance and peer review: Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.