Neurotropic viruses and cerebral palsy: population based case-control studyBMJ 2006; 332 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.38668.616806.3A (Published 12 January 2006) Cite this as: BMJ 2006;332:76
- Catherine S Gibson, postdoctoral research fellow, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ()1,
- Alastair H MacLennan, professor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1,
- Paul N Goldwater, senior consultant clinical microbiologist, Department of Microbiology and Infectious Diseases1,
- Eric A Haan, clinical geneticist, Department of Genetic Medicine1,
- Kevin Priest, epidemiologist2,
- Gustaaf A Dekker, professor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1, South Australian Cerebral Palsy Research Group1
- 1 University of Adelaide, Women's and Children's Hospital, 1st Floor Queen Victoria Building, 72 King William Road, Adelaide, SA 5006, Australia
- 2 Epidemiology Branch, Department of Health, Adelaide, SA 5000, Australia
- Correspondence to: C S Gibson
- Accepted 8 October 2005
Objective To investigate the association between cerebral palsy and direct evidence for perinatal exposure to neurotropic viruses.
Design Population based case-control study.
Setting Adelaide Women's and Children's Hospital Research Laboratory.
Participants and main outcome measures Newborn screening cards of 443 white case patients with cerebral palsy and 883 white controls were tested for viral nucleic acids from enteroviruses and herpes viruses by using polymerase chain reaction. Herpes group A viruses included herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 (HSV-1 and HSV-2), Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), cytomegalovirus (CMV), and human herpes virus 8 (HHV-8), and herpes group B viruses included varicella zoster virus (VZV) and human herpes viruses 6 and 7 (HHV-6 and HHV-7).
Results The prevalence of viral nucleic acids in the control population was high: 39.8% of controls tested positive, and the prevalence was highest in preterm babies. The detection of herpes group B viral nucleic acids increased the risk of developing cerebral palsy (odds ratio 1.68, 95% confidence interval 1.09 to 2.59).
Conclusions Perinatal exposure to neurotropic viruses is associated with preterm delivery and cerebral palsy.
Intrauterine infection is postulated to be an important contributor to the development of cerebral palsy.1–3 Previous studies have investigated surrogate markers of infection, such as chorioamnionitis, funisitis, maternal pyrexia, raised values of C reactive protein, and raised interleukin-6 concentrations.4 This research used molecular techniques to show the presence of viral nucleic acids in the blood of newborn babies.
The herpes viruses (including cytomegalovirus (CMV), herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 (HSV-1 and HSV-2), varicella zoster virus (VZV), Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), and human herpes viruses 6, 7, and 8 (HHV-6, HHV-7, and HHV-8), and enteroviruses can all cross the placenta and infect the fetus.5–10 These viruses are potentially neurotropic and could contribute directly or indirectly to the causation of cerebral palsy. The likelihood of maternal infection resulting in infection of the fetus varies according to the specific virus, whether the infection is primary or recurrent, and the gestational age of the fetus at the time of infection. For cytomegalovirus, the risk of transmission to the fetus for mothers with primary infection is 50%, but only a minority (< 1%) of mothers with reactivation (or reinfection) transmit the virus in utero.11 Once the infection has crossed the placenta into the fetal circulation, the potential for neuronal damage is there, directly and also by the fetal inflammatory response in which pro-inflammatory cytokines may affect the developing brain adversely. This combination of factors may determine who develops cerebral palsy.
We investigated associations between potentially neurotropic viruses and cerebral palsy in a white Australian population. Our hypothesis was that evidence of perinatal viral infection may be associated with the development of cerebral palsy.
Selection of patients and controls
The study population comprised all children with cerebral palsy born in 1986-99 in South Australia to white mothers (n = 443), ascertained by South Australia's cerebral palsy register. The controls were 883 babies born to white mothers from 1986 to 1999.17 We identified newborn screening cards from South Australia's newborn screening programme for each case and control. We selected four potential controls from screening cards filed (by date of receipt) before (n = 2) and after (n = 2) the cards of cases. The date of birth of each control baby was within a few days of the case baby, the hospital from which we took the screening cards was of the same category (metropolitan teaching, metropolitan private, or country), and we took samples on roughly the same day of life as for the cases. The control population included a higher proportion of preterm infants than the general population, as many of the cases of cerebral palsy were born preterm and had been referred to metropolitan teaching hospitals. Linkage (with Automatch, version 4.3, Kennebunk, USA, 1998), using South Australia's perinatal database, was successful for all cases and 1691 controls. To ensure that they were not potentially cases of cerebral palsy we excluded 268/1691 (15.8%) controls because they were children of non-white mothers (n = 102), had a birth defect notified to the state's birth defects register (n = 161), or died in the first year of life (n = 37). We excluded some controls for more than one reason. Random numbers were used to select two controls from the remaining controls in each group of four, to form the control population of 886. As three controls had been selected more than once, the final number of controls was 883. These samples were not randomly selected from the entire newborn population; they were therefore representative of a white population without cerebral palsy, infant death, or notifiable birth defects. The data from all cases and controls were required to be de-identified before testing for polymorphisms and viral nucleic acids and statistical analysis. We undertook all testing with blinding to case or control status.
The viruses of interest were categorised into DNA and RNA viruses. The DNA viruses included HSV-1, HSV-2, VZV, EBV, CMV, HHV-6, HHV-7, and HHV-8. The RNA viruses included members of the Enterovirus family. We used two polymerase chain reactions to detect DNA viruses, using previously published primers.18 We assigned results to the respective test groups: the first detected nucleic acids of HSV-1, HSV-2, EBV, CMV, and HHV-8, hereafter designated herpes group A, and the second detected nucleic acids of VZV, HHV-6, and HHV-7, hereafter designated herpes group B. Within group A, differentiation between CMV and the remaining viruses (HSV-1, HSV-2, EBV, and HHV-8) was possible because of differences in band sizes of products from the polymerase chain reaction, which were visually determined by agarose gel electrophoresis.
We used NucleoSpin Tissue Extraction Kit (Macherey-Nagel, Germany) to extract punches of dried blood (1.2 mm) on newborn screening cards (collected by heel prick at 3-5 days of life) for DNA viruses. We chose a phenolic wash method to extract the newborn screening cards for RNA.19
We used reference RNA and DNA samples extracted from viral stocks to optimise all conditions for amplification. We included these reference samples as positive controls for all subsequent amplifications, using dried blood spots in addition to negative (no template) controls.
Sensitivity of virus detection
We determined the minimum number of detectable viral nucleic acid copies for each polymerase chain reaction and extrapolated back to a minimum number of detectable viral nucleic acid copies per millilitre of blood. The minimum number of detectable viral nucleic acid copies was 2.8/bloodspot (5.6×103/ml blood) for enterovirus, 1.6/bloodspot (3.2×103/ml blood) for herpes group A viruses, and 15/microlitre (3.2×103/ml blood) for herpes group B viruses.
We detected these viral nucleic acids by using newborn screening samples that had been stored for up to 18 years. We used PEPI, version 4.0 (Sagebrush Press, Salt Lake City, USA, 2001) to calculate prevalence proportions and exact 95% confidence intervals of the viruses in the newborn screening cards tested.
As cases and controls had not been matched for covariates such as gestational age, we used all controls in our analysis. Data analysis (GraphPad Instat, version 3.06, San Diego, USA) then considered cerebral palsy cases and controls by gestational age range (< 37 weeks, ≥ 37 weeks, and all gestational ages), type of cerebral palsy (diplegia, hemiplegia, quadriplegia, and all types) and virus. Results are expressed as odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals, comparing positive with negative virus detection. P values below 0.05 are marked in the tables.
Results were obtained from a total of 414/443 cerebral palsy samples (93.5%) and 856/883 control samples (96.9%), a difference that may cause an underestimation of the prevalence of viral exposure in the cerebral palsy cases (odds ratio 2.22, 95% confidence interval 1.26 to 3.93). Not all viruses gave a clear result for each card; the total number of results for each virus was therefore less than the maximum totals of 414 for cases or 856 for controls. The results are expressed as total readable results.
Prevalence of viruses in control population
We determined the prevalence of viral nucleic acids in the newborn white population of South Australia without cerebral palsy (table 1). CMV was the most prevalent virus, with 228 babies (26.7%) testing positive. In addition, 42 babies (4.9%) were positive for more than one virus. Of the babies positive for multiple viruses, the most common combination observed was herpes group B and CMV, with a prevalence of 3.1% (1.9 to 4.6), followed by CMV and herpes group A, with a prevalence of 1.1% (0.5 to 2.1). The remainder of the virus combinations contributed very small numbers, with prevalences of less than 1%.
We investigated the effect of gestational age on the prevalence of these viruses because of the high rate of prematurity in the control population. CMV was significantly (P < 0.01) more prevalent in preterm (82/247) than term (146/608) babies (33.2% and 24.0%, respectively; odds ratio 1.57, 95% confidence interval 1.14 to 2.17; table 2). Herpes group A viruses were also significantly (P < 0.05) more prevalent in preterm (89/247) than term (167/608) babies (36.0% and 27.5%, respectively; 1.49, 1.09 to 2.04). The same trend was observed for the presence of any herpes virus, with 44.3% (98/221) of preterm babies testing positive for any herpes virus, compared with 35.7% (188/526) of term babies (1.43, 1.04 to 1.97; table 2). No other virus was significantly different in relation to gestational age. The difference in the prevalences of any of the viruses between very preterm babies of less than 32 weeks' gestation and preterm babies of 32-36 weeks' gestation did not reach significance.
Viruses and cerebral palsy
We investigated associations between neurotropic viruses and cerebral palsy, taking into consideration gestational age and subtypes of cerebral palsy. Of the 414 cases of cerebral palsy, 131 were diagnosed with diplegia, 119 with hemiplegia, 112 with quadriplegia, and 52 with other or unspecified subtypes.
All gestational ages
The primary analyses showed a significant association between any viral exposure and cerebral palsy at all gestational ages (1.30, 1.00 to 1.67). The detection of herpes group B viral nucleic acids increased the risk of developing all types of cerebral palsy, with an odds ratio of 1.68 (1.09 to 2.59). This increased risk was also observed for the diplegic (1.93, 1.03 to 3.61) and hemiplegic (2.07, 1.10 to 3.88) subtypes of cerebral palsy and herpes group B viruses. Associations did not reach significance for any of the other viruses.
Gestational age ≥37 weeks
The risk of developing cerebral palsy for a gestational age of 37 weeks or more increased with the detection of any herpes virus, with an odds ratio of 1.52 (1.09 to 2.13), and also with the detection of any virus (1.64, 1.17 to 2.28). Herpes group B viruses were associated with the development of diplegia (2.45, 1.02 to 5.89) and hemiplegia (2.38, 1.15 to 4.92). The risk of developing cerebral palsy for gestational age of 37 weeks or more increased with the detection of any herpes virus (1.52, 1.09 to 2.13) and also with the detection of any virus (1.64, 1.17 to 2.28). Associations did not reach significance for any of the other viruses (table 3).
Gestational age <37 weeks
The detection of herpes group A viral nucleic acids decreased the risk of developing all types of cerebral palsy for gestational age < 37 weeks (0.65, 0.43 to 0.99; table 4). Detection of herpes group B increased the risk for quadriplegia for gestational age < 37 weeks (2.87, 1.09 to 7.59). We found no other significant associations for any of the other viruses (table 4).
Combination viruses at any gestational age
The presence of more than one virus was not associated with the risk of developing cerebral palsy at any gestational age (1.13, 0.65 to 1.98). Comparing term born babies with cerebral palsy with term born controls (1.29, 0.64 to 2.61), or preterm babies with cerebral palsy with preterm controls (0.98, 0.38 to 2.53), did not show any associations either.
Perinatal exposure to and infection with viruses are associated with cerebral palsy in the newborn. Our findings reinforce the possibility of a complex and heterogeneous relation between exposure to viral infections and subtypes of cerebral palsy at different gestational ages. Other cofactors may trigger neurotropic damage. We examined the association between cerebral palsy and perinatal exposure to neurotropic viruses. The findings were based on the detection of viral nucleic acids from newborn screening card blood spots collected within a few days of birth, and where detected, the findings indicate intrauterine or early neonatal viral exposure or infection.
Post hoc analyses were performed on the individual viruses and their combinations, increasing the likelihood of identifying chance statistical associations. Because of the small numbers in some of the subanalyses, other associations cannot be excluded with confidence. Where associations are seen in one gestational age range, similar trends are seen in the same subgroup of cerebral palsy with the same virus in other gestational age ranges. This implies that these may indicate true causal relations and may not be attributed to chance. These associations require further study.
Viral associations with preterm birth and cerebral palsy
We document the prevalence of certain viral nucleic acids in a white control population and have shown that stored neonatal blood spots can be used to investigate associations with cerebral palsy. Exposure to viral nucleic acids seems very common in our control population, with a prevalence of 39.8% for any of the viruses tested, and these were mostly herpes viruses. Nearly 5% of our control population tested positive for more than one virus. The prevalence of CMV was significantly higher in those controls born at less than 37 weeks' gestation than in controls born at term (33.2% v 24.0%), implying that the presence of viral infectious agents in the womb is also associated with subsequent preterm delivery.20–23
Using this large cohort of cases of cerebral palsy and controls we identified specific viral DNA and RNA nucleic acid sequences and showed that exposure to viral nucleic acids (and presumably infectious virus), in particular herpes group B, is associated with cerebral palsy. The results show a 1.5-2.5 times increased risk of developing cerebral palsy after perinatal exposure to herpes group B viruses. The prevalence of herpes group B viruses was 7.6% for controls and 12.1% for babies with cerebral palsy, giving a potential attributable risk of 4.5% of all cases of cerebral palsy if a causal relation exists. These results also show an increased risk of developing cerebral palsy in term babies after perinatal exposure to any virus. In contrast, the results from table 4 imply negative associations between perinatal exposure to viral nucleic acids and subsequent cerebral palsy for babies born before term. These conflicting results may be due to the higher prevalence of viral infection in control babies born before term, thus diluting any positive association between viral infection and cerebral palsy for preterm babies. Exposure late in gestation may not result in preterm birth, instead having direct effects on the brain, whereas exposure early in gestation may result in preterm birth but increase the risk of neuropathology associated with prematurity. In this manner, exposure to perinatal viral infection may be indirectly associated with cerebral palsy.
Although our study used non-quantitative methods of and well documented primers for polymerase chain reaction, viral loads may vary over a wide range. Low viral loads may not be sufficient to precipitate preterm birth, but continuing intrauterine development in the presence of infection may allow the infection to contribute to permanent neuropathology. On the other hand, high viral loads may initiate or result in preterm birth and increase the risk of neurological damage associated with prematurity or infection, or both. We plan prospective studies quantifying viral loads to test this theory. Prospective studies will allow access to a wider range of clinical data and correlation with clinical evidence of infection.
Our results do not necessarily indicate active congenital or neonatal infection. Detection of viral nucleic acids in the blood of neonates indicates only exposure to the respective virus or viruses, and not an inflammatory response. Given the small sample volume and the limit of detection of one to 10 viral nucleic acid copies, it could be inferred that true viraemic infection was occurring. It therefore also seems unlikely that presence of viral nucleic acid merely reflected transfer of maternal cells to the fetal circulation via the placenta. Prospective investigations are required to follow women through pregnancy, testing antenatal maternal blood samples for viral nucleic acids, and umbilical cord blood to determine if there is active infection in the fetus or neonate by examining leukocytes for the presence of viral antigens associated with active viral replication and the presence and severity of the inflammatory response of the fetus. The advent of widespread childhood vaccination against VZV, which has been available in South Australia for 10 years, will provide an opportunity to investigate the impact of maternal VZV infection and reactivation on the development of cerebral palsy. It will be interesting to observe if a decline occurs in the rates of cerebral palsy in the next generation, after the vaccination of their mothers, in a way similar to that of the rubellavirus vaccine in reducing the teratogenic effects of rubella during pregnancy.
It is unclear how perinatal exposure to viral infection causes subsequent brain damage and cerebral palsy. If the virus is able to cross the blood-brain barrier, it is capable of setting up infection in the brain and directly damaging vulnerable neuronal tissue. Herpesviruses are capable of establishing themselves within the brain, where they can remain latent indefinitely or reactivate and cause damage. Alternatively, products of infection can be released locally and into the circulation. These products can cross the blood-brain-barrier, as a result of either the barrier's immaturity24 or the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines that impair its integrity.25 26 Having penetrated the blood-brain-barrier, these pro-inflammatory cytokines—such as tumour necrosis factor α—can cause direct damage to developing white matter, resulting in periventricular leukomalacia, with possible stimulation of fetal microglia to produce more TNF-α27 and disruption of the endothelium and ependyma.26
The high prevalence of exposure to viral infection in our control population indicates that “triggers” or cofactors are needed before brain damage can occur. Such triggers may include genetic susceptibility to infections—for example, cytokine polymorphisms that increase or decrease the host immune response to the infection. Disruption of barriers such as the placenta and blood-brain barrier as a result of fetal infarctions secondary to inherited thrombophilia may also have a role in the transmission and establishment of infections. Infection triggering thrombosis in the fetus with thrombophilia could also be postulated. An association between fetal thrombophilia and cerebral palsy has also been found in our cohort.28
Our study has shown that exposure to viral infection is common in newborn babies in South Australia, especially in preterm babies. The risk of cerebral palsy is nearly doubled with exposure to herpes group B viruses but may require other factors, such as genetic susceptibility to infection and inherited thrombophilia or involvement of other clinical events—for example, growth restriction or prematurity—for brain damage and subsequent cerebral palsy to occur. Future studies are planned to investigate these factors.
What is already known on this topic
Preterm birth and choriamnionitis are associated with cerebral palsy and infection with neurotropic viruses in neonates and infants can lead to neurological disability, including cerebral palsy
What this study adds
Stored dried neonatal blood spots, from babies who were diagnosed subsequently to have cerebral palsy, and from control babies, often contain nucleic acids from neurotropic viruses
Herpes group A (including cytomegalovirus) nucleic acids were found more often in neonatal blood spots of preterm control babies than in control babies born at term
Herpes group B nucleic acids were found more often in neonatal blood spots of babies who were diagnosed subsequently to have cerebral palsy than in control babies
The presence of neurotropic viral nucleic acids in the blood of newborns and the subsequent diagnosis of cerebral palsy are significantly associated
A table showing prevalences of neurotropic viruses in a population of newborns diagnosed with cerebral palsy is on bmj.com
We thank Barry Slobedman (Westmead Millennium Institute, NSW, Australia) for providing us with positive control viral material.
Contributors CSG contributed to the collection, analysis and interpretation of data, writing of the manuscript, and is a study guarantor. AHM contributed to the design and interpretation of the data, writing of the manuscript, and is a study guarantor. PNG contributed to the design and interpretation of the data and writing of the manuscript. EAH contributed to the design, collection and interpretation of data, and writing of the manuscript. KP contributed to the collection and analysis of data, and writing of the manuscript. GAD contributed to the design and interpretation of data, and writing of the manuscript, and is a study guarantor. CSG, AHM, and GAD are guarantors. Other members of the South Australian Cerebral Palsy Research Group were involved in design of the study: Annabelle Chan, William M Hague, Zbigniew Rudzki, Phillipa Sharpe, T Yee Khong, Mark R Morton, Enzo Ranieri, Heather Scott, Heather Tapp, and Graeme Casey.
Funding Australian National Health and Medical Research Council, Channel 7 Children's Research Foundation, University of Adelaide, and South Australian Government Captive Insurance Corporation.
Competing interests None declared.
Ethical approval Research Ethics Committee of the Women's and Children's Hospital.