Teenagers need sex education, not just abstinence advice
BMJ 2005; 331 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.331.7509.129-c (Published 14 July 2005) Cite this as: BMJ 2005;331:129All rapid responses
Rapid responses are electronic comments to the editor. They enable our users to debate issues raised in articles published on bmj.com. A rapid response is first posted online. If you need the URL (web address) of an individual response, simply click on the response headline and copy the URL from the browser window. A proportion of responses will, after editing, be published online and in the print journal as letters, which are indexed in PubMed. Rapid responses are not indexed in PubMed and they are not journal articles. The BMJ reserves the right to remove responses which are being wilfully misrepresented as published articles or when it is brought to our attention that a response spreads misinformation.
From March 2022, the word limit for rapid responses will be 600 words not including references and author details. We will no longer post responses that exceed this limit.
The word limit for letters selected from posted responses remains 300 words.
The tradition in BMJ journalism of always putting a negative spin on
anything to do with abstinence education is powerfully illustrated by
Hopkins Tanne's news item.(1)
She states that 'the federal Department of Health and Human Services
in June showed that abstinence programmes...did not decrease teenagers'
sexual activity, pregnancy, or infection with sexually transmitted
diseases'. Of course it didn't; the report was an interim one about
younger children, some only in the 3rd grade.
In fact the report plainly states that it 'does not examine
behavioural outcomes due to the short duration of the follow-up period and
the young ages of the program participants.'(2) and that 'the success of
the programs in promoting abstinence, as well as in reducing risks of
pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases cannot be fully determined
without data that measures behaviours in the older teenage years'. (2)
This appropriate data is not even gathered, yet once again abstinence
is dismissed, not on the basis of any evidence, but by prejudiced and
innaccurate reporting. Such spin, even if subsequently corrected, has
already done the damage I can only assume Tanne intended. A correction
would none the less be a start towards a more balanced approach.
1. Teenagers need sex education, not just abstinence advice Janice
Hopkins Tanne BMJ 2005:129, doi:10.1136/bmj.331.7509.129-c
2. http://aspe.hhs.gov/hsp/05/abstinence/report.pdf. pages xx and
xxxiv
Competing interests:
Trevor Stammers is a trustee of Challenge Teams UK - a charity providing abstinence-based school sex education programmes
Competing interests: No competing interests
Sex education to children is one of the highly debated subjects with
regards to the content, means and its expected end. Opinions are varied on
the appropriate treatment warranted by this subject in terms of biomedical
or socio-cultural paradigm.
Being a health professional, I was frequently called upon to handle a
class on sex education. Very often such sex education is inappropriately
equated to educating children about human reproductive system. My personal
interest in the subject of Human sexuality began while dealing with the
issue with rehabilitated adolescent children. I discovered that they were
least interested in the anatomy of genital organs or details of the
reproductive system, or process of fertilization or menstruation. I
observed that the group I was handling was obsessed with the idea of sex.
They were obsessed with abstractness of sex. The mere utterance of the
world “sex” was scintillating to them. Hence innovation in the approach to
the subject was necessitated.
Undisputedly, the subject of ‘sexuality’ is one of the most
stigmatized and the most misunderstood topics of all the issues concerned
to the human behavior. Part of the reason being, absence of culture of
discourse on the issues related to sexuality in an open, frank and
informed discussion over the subject. Consequently subject of sexuality
is fret with myths and misconceptions. I decided to change my approach in
handling this very sensitive.
Would like to share a very process oriented methodology, which
generally I adopt to handle the subject while exploring this sensitive
issue with the children. The following step-by-step approach was found to
be very helpful to set the stage for discussing human sexuality with
adolescent children.
1. Funnel approach: This approach is generally adopted in behavioral
studies while handling sensitive issues. In this process discussion is
initiated from a larger and wider topic and gradually narrowed down to the
topic of interest. e.g., start with identifying different parts of motor
bike, Tree etc
2. Activity Based Learning: Sexuality being very sensitive issue it
is important that ice should be broken before taking up such issue.
Activity based discussed are often found to be useful in forging a rapport
within the group and also with the facilitator. So once the group is
gelling together in parts identification as above, the facilitator could
lead them to human body mapping. Very often there is hesitation in
indicating genital organs. At this stage discussion is on sexuality is
initiated by asking participants the reasons for hesitation or shyness in
when it comes to sexual parts or topic
3. Thinking Man’s TV. To begin the discussion on sexuality, the
facilitators writes the word SEX in large fonts on the board and ask the
participants to close eyes for two minutes and observe various visuals
that come to their mind and types feelings they experience.
4. Free listing : Facilitator requests the participants to spell out
the visuals and the they experienced and lists it on the board.
5. Simulation: In this stage a hypothetical real life conflict
situation is enacted through a role plays e.g., reaction of the family
members on learning of their child’s teenage pregnancy etc.
6. Discussion and Wrap up: The role play generally end with the
discussion. Care should be taken by the facilitator to not to be
judgmental, but rather help the participants go through the process of
critical thinking and informed decision making processes as illustrated in
‘Life Skills’ approach.
I have tried this step-by-step approach with at least three different
street children groups and two general groups. Would feel greatly
encouraged to receive your feedback after similar trial in your respective
setting.
regards,
Rajan R Patil : email <rajanpatil@yahoo.com>
Competing interests:
None declared
Competing interests: No competing interests
Teen sex-education no more a taboo
With the booming spread of HIV throughout the World, a sex education
program in high schools and colleges (adolescent children) is the urgent
need of this hour. Promoting abstinence among teenagers may be not as
simple as preaching1. American Academy of Pediatrics recommendation on
teenage children’s counseling on sexual behavior and postponing sexual
activity is definitely a positive move. The impact of counseling has to be
well studied and in the Western world it may definitely have a greater
positive impact. In the Asian region, sex still remains a taboo, open
discussion and sharing of information and knowledge regarded as an immoral
practice. Even though, every responsible adult citizens, including,
parents, teachers, policy makers and government think that, open
discussions are ethically and morally improper. Educated parents are still
resistant to impart healthy knowledge and practice of sex with their
adolescent children. Most of the teenagers sought their peer groups as the
sole responsible guides to inform them about their sexuality and most of
the time, may be driven to the wrong practices. As AIDS is spreading like
fire in every part of the World, educating teenagers is an urgent need
before HIV makes it way through among the innocent teen children.
References
1. Tanne JH. Teenagers need sex education, not just abstinence advice. BMJ
2005;331:129.
Competing interests:
None declared
Competing interests: No competing interests