Preventing neural tube defects in Europe: population based studyBMJ 2005; 330 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.330.7491.574 (Published 10 March 2005) Cite this as: BMJ 2005;330:574
- Araceli Busby, lecturer in environmental epidemiology ()1,
- Lenore Abramsky, registry leader2,
- Helen Dolk, professor of epidemiology3,
- Ben Armstrong, reader in statistics1 a Eurocat Folic Acid Working Group
- 1 London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1E 7HT
- 2 North Thames (West) Congenital Malformations Register, Northwick Park Hospital, Harrow, Middlesex HA1 3UJ
- 3 EUROCAT Central Registry, University of Ulster, Newtownabbey, Co Antrim, Northern Ireland BT37 OQB
- Corresponding author: A Busby
- Accepted 27 January 2005
Each year, more than 4500 pregnancies in the European Union are affected by neural tube defects. Unambiguous evidence of the effectiveness of periconceptional folic acid in preventing neural tube defects has been available since 1991,1 and improving folate status sufficiently could result in the prevention of more than two thirds of all neural tube defects. We report on trends in the prevalence of neural tube defects up to 2001, in the context of a survey in 16 European countries of periconceptional folic acid policies and their implementation.2 3
Participants, methods, and results
Eurocat is a network of population based congenital anomaly registries in Europe (http://www.eurocat.ulster.ac.uk/). A total of 9 273 212 births were surveyed by 31 registries in 16 countries 1980-2001,3 including 8913 babies or fetuses with neural tube defects (anencephaly, spina bifida, or encephalocele): 3298 live births, 844 stillbirths, and 4771 terminations of pregnancy after prenatal diagnosis. In the United Kingdom and Ireland, yearly prevalence of neural tube defects declined, predating any periconceptional folic acid supplementation policy initiatives, from 45 per 10 000 births in 1980 to 10 to 15 per 10 000 in the 1990s (%figure). In contrast, in the rest of Europe the prevalence during the 1980s and thereafter was close to 10 per 10 000 births (%figure).
The first governments to formulate a periconceptional folic acid supplementation policy were the United Kingdom (1992), Ireland (1993), and the Netherlands (1993); six more (Switzerland 1996, Denmark 1997, Norway 1998, Portugal 1998, France 2000, and Spain 2001) followed. Malta (1994) and Finland (1995) recommended raising folate status by dietary means only. Austria, Belgium, Croatia, Germany, and Italy had no government policy, although in all these countries professional bodies have issued guidelines or recommendations.2
For 23 of the registers with data going back to at least 1990, we compared changes in prevalence over time according to policy type by estimating, for each registry, the ratio of prevalence in 1999-2001 to 1989-91 and calculating the mean of such ratios (on a log scale) for all registries in countries with similar policy types (as introduced by 1999), using standard random effects meta-analysis techniques.3 In the United Kingdom and Ireland we found a significant overall mean reduction in the prevalence of neural tube defects in 1999-2001 compared with 1989-1991 (32% (17% to 44%)), continuing a trend that preceded policies of folic acid supplementation. Registries in other countries with a policy of raising periconceptional folate status (by supplementation or dietary means) introduced by 1999 had a mean reduction in prevalence of 17% (44% reduction to 4% increase), whereas registries from countries with no policy by 1999 showed a mean reduction of 9% (26% reduction to 12% increase).3
The prevalence of neural tube defects in Europe has not declined substantially in the past decade despite national policies of folic acid supplementation in half the countries. The prevalence in the United Kingdom and Ireland fell by 32% continuing a stronger pre-existing trend and remains slightly higher than overall European levels. These data suggest that policies simply recommending periconceptional supplementation of folic acid in planned pregnancies are not effective enough. Many women may not receive or respond to health promotion messages stressing the need to commence supplementation preconceptionally, or may remain unaware that dietary modifications are unlikely to achieve sufficient folate intake,w1 and a large proportion of pregnancies in most countries are unplanned.2 Folate status of most women of childbearing age could be raised by fortifying a staple food with folic acid,4–5 which would also help to reduce socioeconomic inequalities in the prevalence of neural tube defects. Health effects of supplementation and fortification should be monitored, and policies should be reviewed periodically in light of the findings. The potential for preventing neural tube defects in Europe by raising folate status is still far from being fulfilled,1 and it is unacceptable to continue to rely mainly on prenatal screening and termination to reduce the number of babies born with neural tube defects.2 w2
What is already known on this topic
Periconceptional folic acid supplementation can prevent most neural tube defects if widely used
Supplementation must begin before conception for it to be effective
What this study adds
Lack of a substantial decline in neural tube defect prevalence in Europe since 1991 shows that the potential for preventing neural tube defects is still far from being fulfilled
Periconceptional supplementation and fortification of staple foods is needed to reach all women before conception and to prevent widening of socioeconomic inequalities
Information about the figure and references w1 and w2 are on bmj.com
Contributors AB designed, did, and interpreted the statistical analysis and drafted the paper. LA designed the survey, gathered information, provided neural tube defect data, interpreted the results, and drafted the paper. HD designed the survey and statistical analysis, interpreted the results and drafted the paper. BA designed and interpreted the statistical analysis and drafted the paper. All the above authors are guarantors. Members of the Eurocat Folic Acid Working Group, who were involved in design, completion and interpretation of survey, development of Eurocat recommendations, contributed neural tube defect data to the Eurocat central database and commented on drafts of the paper: Marie-Claude Addor, Nicola Armstrong, Ingeborg Barisic, Andrea Berghold, Paula Braz, Elisa Calzolari, Marianne Christiansen, Guido Cocchi, Anne Kjersti Daltveit, Hermien De Walle, Grace Edwards, Miriam Gatt, Blanca Gener, Yves Gillerot, Romana Gjergia, Janine Goujard, Martin Haeusler, Anna LatosBielenska, Robert McDonnell, Amanda Neville, Annukka Ritvanen, Christine Rösch, and Volker Steinbicker. Maria Loane extracted the data from the Eurocat central registry database. The following Eurocat registry leaders contributed data to the Eurocat central database: Sebastiano Bianca, Fabrizio Bianchi, Patricia Boyd, Catherine de Vigan, Maria Feijoo, Ester Garne, Lorentz Irgens, David Lillis, Maria Luisa Martinez-Frias, Carmen Mosquera Tenreiro, Vera Nelen, Annette Queisser-Luft, Elisabeth Robert, Gioacchino Scarano, Claude Stoll, David Stone, Romano Tenconi, and David Tucker.
Funding Eurocat is supported by the EU Commission Public Health Directorate Public Health Programme.
Competing interests None declared.
Ethical approval All registries have the ethics approval appropriate to their national and local ethics guidelines.