Gender related disordersBMJ 2004; 329 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.329.7466.615 (Published 09 September 2004) Cite this as: BMJ 2004;329:615
- Kevan Wylie
Gender identity disorder is being given greater attention and importance by the medical profession. Although its aetiology is unclear, some evidence suggests that it has a neurobiological basis. The condition is no longer confused with sexual orientation preference and other gender related disorders. Social stigma remains, and patients need multidisciplinary assessment and care.
The designation of sex has always been established by looking at the anatomical sex, and the term gender identity describes whether a person senses himself or herself to be masculine or feminine. Gender role describes how people publicly express themselves in their clothing, use of cosmetics, hairstyle, conversation, body language, appearance, and behaviour. Usually, gender identity and gender role are congruous, but in people with gender identity disorder, severe incongruity exists between anatomical sex and gender identity, and the person has persistent discomfort with his or her anatomical sex, usually from childhood. A sense of inappropriateness is felt in the gender role of that sex, and such people have a strong, ongoing, crossgender identification, with a desire to live and be accepted as a member of the opposite sex. Usually they have a desire for hormonal therapy and surgery to make their body as congruent as possible with the desired gender identity.
It is essential to recognise that sexual orientation—the sex someone finds erotically attractive—is distinct from gender identity and role, and it may be heterosexual, homosexual, or bisexual. The proportion of heterosexual, bisexual, and gay people is no different in transgendered people than in non-transgendered people, and most studies suggest that heterosexuality occurs after surgical reassignment.
The aetiology of gender dysphoria is controversial. Some believe it reflects the physical and mental health of the mother during pregnancy, while others believe that a disturbed interaction occurs between parts of the brain and sex hormones during development of the fetus because by the sixth week of gestation, brain sex is a reality, and gender programming may have started. Other theorists have described the condition to reflect developmental problems during early life. There is an emphasis on the nurturing aspects of gender reinforcements and programming. Children may have to suppress their natural behaviours and tendencies to conform and fit in, which can cause undue distress.
Some evidence supports the idea that transsexualism is a neurodevelopmental condition during fetal growth. Several sexually dimorphic nuclei have been found in the hypothalamic area of the brain, particularly the sexually dimorphic limbic nucleus (the central subdivision of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis) that becomes fully matured in the human brain by early adulthood.
Zhou et al found that the biological structure in the brains of male to female transsexual people had a totally female pattern that was not attributable to sex hormone therapy. Kruijver et al later found that regardless of sexual orientation, men had almost twice as many somatostatin neurones as women. These inhibit thyroid stimulating hormone and growth hormones in the hypothalamus. The number of neurones in male to female transsexual people was similar to that in women, whereas the number of neurones in female to male transsexual people was similar to that in men. This seems to support a neurobiological basis for gender identity disorder.
This article is adapted from the second edition of the ABC of Sexual Health, which will be published later this year. A list of support networks for patients is on bmj.com
People who identify themselves with transsexualism are known as transpeople. Those who are assigned as female at birth but who sense their body sexual function as, and identify themselves as, male are known as transmen, and vice versa. Once treatment through hormonal and surgical intervention is complete, many people no longer identify themselves as trans but simply as men or women
When a predisposition for transsexualism exists, various factors, including psychosexual matters, may subsequently have a role in outcome
Hormones may influence considerably the dimorphic development at several critical times: initially during the fetal period, around the time of birth, and, most likely, after birth.
In cross dressing transvestism, men find intense relief in dressing in women's clothing. In these circumstances, progression to sexual arousal and activity or an intense desire to seek sexual reassignment surgery is rare. In transvestite fetishism, the person, who is almost invariably a man, obtains sexual arousal as a consequence of dressing in women's clothing. Masturbation or other sexual activity associated with the cross dressing is not unusual, with the man later discarding the clothing, often with a degree of repulsion.
In the United Kingdom in 1970, a legal judgment removed the right to correct birth certificates. This meant that transpeople lost their rights to marry, foster, adopt, and receive support for domestic violence. Custodial sentencing placements also were affected.
A legal judgment from the European Court of Justice in 1998 meant that discrimination on the grounds of a person's transsexualism became illegal, and rights were put in effect by the Sex Discrimination (Gender Reassignment) Regulations that year.
The Gender Recognition Act 2004 makes provision for a person of either gender, aged at least 18, to make an application for a gender recognition certificate on the basis of living in the gender other than identified on the original birth certificate. A diagnosis of gender dysphoria and evidence of having lived in the acquired gender for at least two years will be necessary. It will not be necessary for full gender reassignment surgery to have taken place. A short certificate of birth can then be issued.
Standards of care
The Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association laid out internationally agreed standards of care for transgendered patients who want to change to their chosen gender. These standards outline the pathways of treatment that should be available to patients seeking help. They include the role of mental health professionals in diagnosing accurately any comorbid psychiatric conditions, confirming the gender disorder, and ensuring that patients are offered appropriate treatment. Up to 1 in 10 transpeople have problems with mental illness, genital mutilation, or suicide attempts.
Transpeople should be counselled about the range of treatment options and implications and, if necessary, should be encouraged to have psychotherapy. The professional should ascertain eligibility and readiness for progression to hormone and surgical therapy. Whenever possible, this should be done within the context of a multidisciplinary team and should take into account the needs of the individual patient rather than enforcing a rigid package of care.
The real life experience can happen at a predetermined time or before starting hormonal therapy; the decision usually depends on local policy. The person must aim to maintain full time or part time employment or function as a student or in a community based volunteer activity.
He or she must provide written documentation to prove that people other than the therapists acknowledge that the patient successfully passes and functions in the chosen gender role. People who are retired may have some problems in providing such documentation.
Clear guidelines about haematological, biochemical, and endocrinological monitoring should be given before and during treatment with hormones. When starting hormonal therapy, the desired effects and the positive and negative side effects must be outlined to the patient and appropriate consent should be obtained. It is good practice to ensure that any partner of the patient is aware of the effects of prescribed medications. Reproductive options with gamete storage should be taken into account and explicit consent obtained. Speech and language therapy and hair removal techniques should be offered at this stage.
Gender reassignment surgery
After a minimum of 12 months' supervision within the real life experience, the opportunity for surgery can be considered. As with entering hormonal therapy, criteria of eligibility and readiness need to be met. When the supervising team is convinced that these have been satisfied, a second psychiatric or medical opinion should be sought, preferably from an experienced clinician from another service. If this opinion is supportive, the patients should be referred to a specialist surgeon. Surgical options include breast surgery and genital reassignment surgery. The patient must be fully counselled about the limitations of surgery and the potential complications.
Transmen may be offered bilateral mastectomy, hysterectomy, oophorectomy, and fashioning of a penis and scrotum. Possible operations for transwomen are removal of the penis and testes and fashioning a new vagina and clitoris, as well as techniques such as breast augmentation, reshaping of the nose and the cricothyroid cartilages, facial remodelling, and hair transplants. Adequate postoperative care from the surgical, hormonal, and therapeutic points of view must be provided.
Studies that have reported the outcome of sex reassignment surgery have found varied results. One report suggests satisfaction with the surgical results in 87% of male to female patients and 97% of female to male patients. Young age, good family and social support, and success of the surgical procedures all correlate with patients' long term satisfaction.
Kevan Wylie is consultant in sexual medicine, Porterbrook Clinic, Sheffield
The ABC of Sexual Health is edited by John Tomlinson, specialist in sexual health, Winchester,