A lot
- Richard Smith, editor (rsmith@bmj.com)
- BMJ
Doctors and managers have different cultures, which opens up possibilities not only of fruitless fighting but also of rich learning. I've belonged to both cultures. In 1989 I went to the Stanford Business School in California with a typical doctor's view of management: boring, uncreative, and best left to those incapable of doing anything better. I came back thinking the opposite. To be able to mix together ideas, people, and resources to makes things happen is creative, difficult, and a privilege. Generally, there is even more uncertainty in management than medicine. Having now inhabited both cultures it's clear that they have much to learn from each other—and where better to do that than within healthcare systems, where they work alongside each other?
Not everything is different between the two cultures. Both professions are full of highly committed people who work extremely hard—often to the point of damaging themselves and their families. The training of both is long, hard, and never ends. Contrary to what doctors may believe, managers think about ethics. Shocked by the scandals of the 1980s, business schools have been teaching ethics for as long as medical schools. This is not to say that all managers behave ethically any more than all doctors do.
Both professions respond to financial incentives. Doctors like to fool themselves that they don't, but there is overwhelming evidence that they do—just like everybody …
Sign in
Personal subscribers, sign in here:
Article access
Article access for 1 day
Purchase this article for £20 $30 €32*
The PDF version can be downloaded as your personal record
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us
Digg
Facebook
Reddit
Technorati
Twitter
Stumbleupon
Rapid responses
Latest Responses
The decline in the breast cancer incidence is 1.2% and it is not significant.
Published 10 February 2012
'twas ever thus
Published 10 February 2012
The value of historic human remains
Published 10 February 2012
In Praise of British Literature
Published 10 February 2012
Is real shared decision making possible?
Published 10 February 2012
Most responses
Does anyone understand the government’s plan for the NHS? (17 responses)
Published 17 Jan 2012
Bad medicine: medical nutrition (15 responses)
Published 18 Jan 2012
Shared decision making: really putting patients at the centre of healthcare (7 responses)
Published 27 Jan 2012
Why legislation is necessary for my health reforms (7 responses)
Published 1 Feb 2012
Search for evidence goes on (5 responses)
Published 17 Jan 2012