Letter

Ethical market in organs

BMJ 2002; 325 doi: 10.1136/bmj.325.7368.835 (Published 12 October 2002)
Cite this as: BMJ 2002;325:835

Access to the full text of this article requires a subscription or payment. Please log in or subscribe below.

Market of organs is unethical under any circumstances

  1. Ignazio R Marino, professor of surgery (marinoir@msx.upmc.edu),
  2. Claudia Cirillo, administrative coordinator for international relations,
  3. Alessandra Cattoi, chief, news bureau, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center in Italy
  1. University of Pittsburgh, Thomas E Starzl Transplantation Institute
  2. University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Suite 10097, Forbes Tower, 200 Lothrop Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA
  3. Sheffield North Primary Care Trust, Sheffield S5 6NU
  4. Transplant Unit, Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH3 9YW

    EDITOR—Although we admire Harris and Erin's commitment to solve the dilemmas posed by a shortage of organs, we strongly disagree not only with their conclusions but also with their assumption—namely, that the selling and buying of human organs can be made ethical. 1

    Harris and Erin harness their theory to the laudable commitment to raise donation rates but arrive at the definition of an ethical market by promoting a system that seems to depend only on a restricted group of citizens—those who find the monetary incentives proposed appealing.

    Firstly, the integrity of the human body should never be subject to trade. Can we truly define this system as ethical because the selling and buying of organs is administered by the state?

    Secondly, how can a system be called ethical when it implicitly penalises the weakest people and exacerbates discrimination based on census? Will a healthy well-off citizen ever decide to give away part of his or her body for monetary gain? Donation rates might be boosted, but, although both the rich and the poor will continue benefiting from transplantation indiscriminately, organ procurement will be increased only by contributions from poor people.

    Any commitment towards raising donation rates can …

    Access to the full text of this article requires a subscription or payment

    Subscribe

    Article access

    Article access for 1 day

    Purchase this article for £20 $30 €32*

    The PDF version can be downloaded as your personal record

    * Prices do not include VAT

    Rapid responses

    THIS WEEK'S POLL

    BMJ most popular