Editorials

Bupropion: a new treatment for smokers

BMJ 2000; 321 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.321.7253.65 (Published 08 July 2000) Cite this as: BMJ 2000;321:65

Nicotine replacement treatment should also be available on the NHS

  1. John Britton, professor of respiratory medicine (j.britton{at}virgin.net),
  2. Martin J Jarvis, professor of health psychology (martin.jarvis{at}ucl.ac.uk)
  1. Division of Respiratory Medicine, University of Nottingham, City Hospital, Nottingham NG5 1PB
  2. Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, ICRF Health Behaviour Unit, University College London, London WC1E 6BT

    Bupropion was licensed in June by the Medicines Control Agency for use in the United Kingdom to help patients stop smoking. Bupropion is the first new pharmacological treatment for smokers to be introduced since nicotine replacement therapy 20 years ago. Bupropion can potentially have a huge impact on public health not only through the efficacy of the drug itself but also by making smoking cessation services more widely available.

    There are about 13 million regular smokers in the United Kingdom.1 One in every two lifelong smokers will die prematurely from tobacco related causes.2 Interventions to help people stop smoking are cost effective in preventing that premature loss of life, and nicotine replacement products are the most effective treatment available.3 4 About 20% of those given nicotine replacement with support from specialist counsellors will remain non-smokers for one year and up to about 10% will remain non-smokers if given brief advice from a health professional in addition to nicotine replacement.3 This latter approach may potentially have a far greater impact on public health because wider coverage of the population can be achieved. It is also cost effective.5 However, nicotine replacement and counselling services have not been made generally available through the NHS, and nicotine replacement products have been removed from the list of prescribed drugs for which patients can be reimbursed. New services to help people stop smoking, which are being established in England as a result of the recent government white paper on smoking, aim to provide smokers with counselling support but still require smokers to pay for most or all of their nicotine replacement.1 One week of free nicotine replacement is available to those eligible for free prescriptions but the bureaucracy can be daunting. The potential impact of these specialist services at a population level is small, and their declared target is to reduce the number of smokers by only 20 000 each year—less than 0.2% of the current population of smokers.6

    Bupropion was originally developed as an antidepressant, but it is chemically unrelated to other antidepressant drugs. Its mechanism of action in smoking cessation is not understood but may be mediated by raising the concentration of dopamine in the nucleus accumbens, a process that is also involved in nicotine addiction.2 7 Two preliminary reports, 8 9 and now two clinical trials funded by the manufacturers, have shown its efficacy in smokers who were also given regular counselling support.10 11 The first of these studies compared placebo with three different doses of sustained release bupropion given for seven weeks in a parallel group study of 615 smokers: rates of quitting smoking after one year were 12.4% among those who took a placebo, 19.6% for those who took 100 mg bupropion daily, 22.9% for those who took 150 mg, and 23.1% for those who took 300 mg.10 This effect occurred independently of any evidence of current or previous depression.12 The second study of 893 smokers compared treatment with 150 mg sustained release bupropion twice daily (once daily for the first three days) either alone or in conjunction with transdermal nicotine, with nicotine alone or placebo.11 Cessation of smoking was sustained for one year of follow up in 5.6% of participants treated with placebo, 9.8% of those treated with transdermal nicotine, 18.4% of those treated with bupropion alone, and 22.5% of those treated with bupropion and nicotine.11 Bupropion alone was significantly more effective than placebo or transdermal nicotine and not significantly less effective than bupropion plus transdermal nicotine. Bupropion significantly reduced weight gain during the treatment period, although this effect was subsequently lost. The main adverse effects of bupropion were insomnia and dry mouth. Subsequent evidence has suggested that longer treatment with bupropion may reduce the likelihood of relapse and produce a more sustained reduction in weight gain (unpublished data).

    On the evidence of the only comparative study available bupropion seems to be more effective than transdermal nicotine.12 Although this finding needs to be confirmed and the combined effectiveness of bupropion and nicotine replacement needs to be established, the recent confirmation by the government that bupropion will be available on reimbursable prescriptions provides doctors in this country with a treatment to help patients stop smoking that is effective and, importantly, affordable for smokers. An eight week course of bupropion with support from a telephone helpline will cost the NHS about £86 ($129) (GlaxoWellcome, product information); this is less than the cost of a full course of most nicotine replacement formulations.4 To the smoker however, bupropion will be provided in four week treatment packs, so eight weeks will cost a maximum of two standard prescription charges (£12), which is less than the cost of one week's supply of transdermal nicotine. Given a choice between bupropion and nicotine replacement, a substantial proportion of smokers are likely to choose bupropion. This choice will be made easier by the fact that bupropion is available from general practitioners while nicotine replacement and counselling services are likely to involve referral elsewhere.

    The challenge to health service management is to reform and integrate nicotine replacement and counselling services into primary care to provide widespread accessibility to these and to bupropion. Since nicotine treatment may be preferred by some patients and bupropion may be contraindicated in others it is also essential to end the present irrational and unfair exclusion of nicotine replacement products from the list of reimbursable prescriptions. It is time that helping patients to quit smoking is taken seriously by the NHS, and if the arrival of bupropion is the catalyst that causes this to happen, then the drug might really achieve something.

    Footnotes

    • JB has been reimbursed by GlaxoWellcome, the manufacturer of bupropion, for attending international conferences in respiratory medicine and is participating in a clinical trial of transdermal nicotine funded by Pharmacia and Upjohn. MJJ has received honorariums from GlaxoWellcome for speaking and attending meetings of advisory panels.

    References

    1. 1.
    2. 2.
    3. 3.
    4. 4.
    5. 5.
    6. 6.
    7. 7.
    8. 8.
    9. 9.
    10. 10.
    11. 11.
    12. 12.