Evidence does not support link

EDITOR—The summary points of Hemingway and Marmot's review of psychosocial risk factors for coronary heart disease may be misleading.1 The first of these states that “prospective cohort studies show a possible aetiological role for type A/hostility.” However, of the four prospective studies of hostility, only two show any significant association between hostility and coronary heart disease (one for women only). Six of the nine aetiological studies of type A behaviour also show no association with coronary heart disease. The other three studies give no information on completeness of follow up or whether outcomes such as angina were assessed in a blinded manner. One of these studies had minimal adjustment for confounding. No study showed any prognostic role for type A behaviour or hostility. Taken together, these studies do not represent robust evidence that these psychological variables have an important role in the development or prognosis of coronary …