Education And Debate

Children as consumers

BMJ 1998; 316 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.316.7144.1600 (Published 23 May 1998) Cite this as: BMJ 1998;316:1600
  1. Cleone Hart, senior registrara,
  2. Rosemary Chesson, reader in health services research.b
  1. a Department of Child and Family Psychiatry, Royal Aberdeen Children's Hospital, Aberdeen AB9 2ZG
  2. b Faculty of Health and Food, Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen AB25 1LD
  1. Correspondence to: Dr Chesson

    Children are important users of health services, accounting for up to a quarter of general practitioner consultations1 and 30% of the workload in accident and emergency departments.2 However, their needs are given insufficient priority by policy makers and health service professionals. Last year a report of the British government's health committee stressed that a change in attitude was needed and that it was important to listen to children and to take their views into account.3

    Although consumers have an important role in reforming health care,4 the paternalistic attitude still prevailing among health professionals when it comes to consumer involvement in health care and research can make this difficult.5 Patient passivity begins early in life6 so we should not be surprised that adult users acquiesce. In this article we discuss why children should be consulted directly, how this is to be achieved, and finally what may be required to bring about change.

    Summary points

    Children are major users of health services but are rarely consulted as healthcare consumers

    Although parents are extensively used as proxies for children, their accounts may not always accurately reflect children's perceptions

    Large numbers of children are cared for and treated by staff who have no paediatric training and abilities to communicate cannot be assumed

    Children's concepts of hospital care and illness differ greatly from those of adults

    Children may be able to express their opinions if they are sought using appropriate methods

    Staff need to be trained to enable the child's voice to be heard and may need to consult colleagues in departments of child and family psychiatry and clinical psychology and develop closer contacts with teachers and social workers

    Current situation

    Parent as proxy

    In Britain, although there has been an increasing emphasis on obtaining the views of health service users, children are rarely included. This …

    View Full Text

    Sign in

    Log in through your institution

    Subscribe