Education And Debate

Commentary: Dangerous patients or dangerous diseases?

BMJ 1996; 312 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.312.7036.967 (Published 13 April 1996) Cite this as: BMJ 1996;312:967
  1. Pamela J Taylor, professor of special hospital psychiatrya,
  2. John Monahan, professor of psychology and legal medicineb
  1. a Institute of Psychiatry, London SE5 8AF
  2. b University of Virginia School of Law, Charlottesville, VA 22903-1789, USA
  1. Correspondence to: Professor Taylor.

    Given something of an international panic about people with a mental disorder, perhaps the most important contribution to rational practice is to emphasise that such disorders account for a minute proportion of society's violence. In countries with modest criminal homicide rates of, say, 2-6 per 100000 population, people with schizophrenia are overrepresented in criminal homicide statistics compared with their representation in the general population.1 In Denmark there is even some evidence of an increase, since 1959, in the number of men with schizophrenia who kill someone within their family.2 Criminal homicide, however, is a highly selected type of unnatural death even in peacetime.

    For non-fatal violence, in the only true community survey of violence and mental disorder,3 people with schizophrenia, major affective disorder, substance misuse, or a combination of disorders were overrepresented in the violence groups. Even so, less than 10% of the people with pure schizophrenia reported having been violent in the 12 months before the interview. Furthermore, they accounted for less than 3% of the total violence reported in the sample. There are no data to support the media caricature of people with a mental disorder, the shunning of former patients by employers or neighbours, or the laws increasing constraints proposed by politicians pandering to public fears. If most of society can remain untroubled by schizophrenia, however, the 1% or so of the population that suffer from it, their families, and the victims of those few schizophrenic people who become violent deserve more than reassurances about probabilities.

    Impact of psychotic illness

    An association between two conditions suggests but does not establish a causal link. Studies of comparative illness and violence careers are an important next step. Two Scandinavian birth cohort studies compared the criminal careers of people who had been admitted to hospital for major mental disorders with those …

    Sign in

    Log in through your institution

    Free trial

    Register for a free trial to thebmj.com to receive unlimited access to all content on thebmj.com for 14 days.
    Sign up for a free trial

    Subscribe