Serum cholesterol concentraions in parasuicide

BMJ 1995; 310 doi: 10.1136/bmj.310.6995.1632 (Published 24 June 1995)
Cite this as: BMJ 1995;310:1632
  1. Massimo Gallerani,
  2. Roberto Manfredini,
  3. Stefano Caaracciolo,
  4. Chiara Scapoli,
  5. Sergio Molinari,
  6. Carmelo Fersini
  • Accepted 12 April 1995

Abstract

OBJECTIVE —To evaluate whether people who have committed parasuicide have low serum cholesterol concentrations.

DESIGN —Results of blood tests in subjects admitted to hospital for parasuicide compared with those of a control group of non-suicidal subjects; comparison in subgroup of parasuicide subjects of two sets of blood test results (one set from admission for parasuicide and the other from admission for some other illness).

SETTING —General hospital, Ferrara, Italy.

SUBJECTS —331parasuicide subjects aged 44 (SD 21) years (109 with two sets of blood test results) and 331 controls.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES —Serum cholesterol concentrations and possible association with parasuicide, considering sex, violence of method of parasuicide, and underlying psychiatric disorder.

RESULTS —Lower serum cholesterol concentrations (4.96 (SD 1.16) mmol/l) were found in the parasuicide subjects than in the controls (5.43 (1.30); P < 0.001), regardless of sex and degree of violence of parasuicide method. Both men and women with two sets of blood test results had lower cholesterol concentrations after parasuicide. Linear regression analysis showed that the difference in cholesterol concentrations was significantly related to the length of time between the taking of the two sets of blood samples.

CONCLUSION —The study showed low cholesterol concentrations after parasuicide. This finding agrees with previous studies, which suggest an association between low cholesterol concentration and suicide.

  • Trials of cholesterol lowering have shown an increased mortality from violent deaths and suicide

  • No studies of cholesterol concentrations in parasuicide subjects are available

  • This study shows lower cholesterol concentrations in parasuicide subjects than in controls

  • The association between low cholesterol concentration and parasuicide, however, does not allow definite conclusions to be drawn

  • Further prospective trials are needed to focus on the possible effects of abrupt variation in cholesterol concentration on behaviour

Footnotes

  • The study was supported by grants from the Italian ministry.

    We thank Mrs Eileen Cartoon for her collaboration in preparing the final version of the manuscript.

  • Accepted 12 April 1995

THIS WEEK'S POLL