Education And Debate

Controversies in Management: Dietary treatments for obesity are ineffective

BMJ 1994; 309 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.309.6955.655 (Published 10 September 1994) Cite this as: BMJ 1994;309:655
  1. C S Wooley,
  2. D M Garner
  1. University of Cincinnati, College of Medicine, Cincinnati, Ohio 45267, USA Beck Institute for Cognitive Therapy and Research, Bala Cynwood, Pennsylvania 19001, USA
  1. Correspondence to: Dr Wooley.

    It is surprising that debate continues about the effectiveness of dietary treatments for obesity. Perhaps this is partly related to ambiguity in the term effectiveness. It is well known that most treatments produce temporary weight loss. But it is equally well known that 90% to 95% of those who lose weight regain it within several years.1 This poor outcome has led to charges that traditional treatments for obesity should be abandoned and countercharges that it is irresponsible to withhold treatment for such a serious problem. The failure of reducing diets to produce lasting improvement was recently reiterated at a National Institutes of Health consensus conference, which also warned about the adverse effects of treatment.2

    The failure of fat people to achieve a goal they seem to want - and to want almost above all else - must now be admitted for what it is: a failure not of those people but of the methods of treatment that are used. It is no longer a mystery why diets have such a poor long term record of success. Indeed the failure of obese people to become or remain thin by “normalising” their food intake follows logically from studies on the heritability of obesity,3 the biology of weight regulation,4 and the physiology of energy metabolism.5

    Demand for treatment is not a justification

    Yet many remain enthusiastic about treatment. It could be said that the main evidence for the value of dieting is that health professionals continue to prescribe it. Inertia feeds on itself, failure to change …

    View Full Text

    Sign in

    Log in through your institution

    Subscribe