Purchasing for all: an alternative to fundholding
BMJ 1994; 308 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.308.6925.391 (Published 05 February 1994) Cite this as: BMJ 1994;308:391
- J P Graffy,
- J Williams
- Academic Department of General Practice and Primary Care, Medical Colleges of St Bartholomew's and the Royal London Hospitals, London Hackney General Practitioners' Forum, London E3 2AN
- Correspondence to: Dr Jonathan P Graffy, Statham Grove Surgery, Statham Grove, London N16 9DP.
- Accepted 16 December 1993
Abstract
Objective: To evaluate general practitioner participation in a district health authority's purchasing work.
Design: Questionnaire study of 131 Hackney general practitioners and 33 senior health service managers; review of the minutes of 28 meetings of the Hackney General Practitioners' Forum and the contract between City and Hackney Health Authority and the St Bartholomew's NHS Trust.
Setting: Hackney General Practitioners' Forum.
Main outcome measures: General practitioners' and managers' perceptions of how representative and effective the general practitioners' forum is; proportion of new quality targets and service developments contributed by general practitioners; main issues discussed by the forum and impact on district health authority policy.
Results: 99 (76%) general practitioners and 27 (82%) managers responded. Both groups perceived the forum as representative. 92% (24/26) of the managers thought the forum was effective but only 74% (70/95) of general practitioners did so, largely because some doubted that the forum was listened to. 75% (103/138) if quality targets and 55% (16/29) of service developments planned in the 1993-4 contract were contributed by general practitioners. They also lobbied successfully for more resources for urology and community mental health services.
Conclusions: Input into commissioning via a general practitioners' forum can be both representative and effective. General practitioners need to work closely to achieve a consensus and those involved need administrative support. The relation between general practice and public health medicine needs to be strengthened.
Footnotes
- Accepted 16 December 1993