Question

Parthasarathy Ramesh,
Consultant Physician
Solihull Hospital, B912JL
12 December 2003

What options are available to relieve ear blockage due to flight descents, apart from chewing gums, sudafed tablets if you have a cold, or yawning?

 

Competing interests: None declared

Answer this question

Answers

[Read Question and Answer]Open your Eustachian Tube
Sebastian Hendricks   (8 April 2004)
[Read Question and Answer]do not use pseudoephedrine (Sudafed)
alain martinole   (22 March 2004)
[Read Question and Answer]An earful of pain
Dr. Herbert H. Nehrlich   (21 March 2004)
[Read Question and Answer]Blocked ears and flying
Rosemary A Allan   (20 March 2004)
[Read Question and Answer]Mimic swallowing
Biji T Kurien   (20 March 2004)
[Read Question and Answer]Frenzel and going up and down!
Steven M Rudolphy   (20 March 2004)
[Read Question and Answer]Unblocking ears
Darryl M Hoffman   (19 March 2004)
[Read Question and Answer]Pinch and blow
Theo Fenton   (23 December 2003)
[Read Question and Answer]Drink Water
Aaron J Baxter   (23 December 2003)
[Read Question and Answer]Blowing up a balloon
john McCormack   (14 December 2003)

Open your Eustachian Tube 8 April 2004
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Sebastian Hendricks,
Specialist Registar in Audiological Medicine
Department of Neuro-otology, National Hospital for Neurology & Neurosurgery, London WC1N 3BG

In people without upper respiratory tract infections, allergic rhinitis or cranio-facial malformations the eustachian tube between the nose and the middle ear should open with swallowing. This equalises the pressure in the middle ear compared to the outer ear canal and the sensation of pressure disappears. That is why drinking, chewing gum, blowing your nose etc can be helpful.

The treatment differs according to each patients, e.g. feeding a baby during as- or descendent, chewing gum, taking decongesting nose drops etc. In some cases, eg. see the above, this might not help.

A device called "Otovent" can be purchased from Pharmacists. This is a balloon fixed to a connector that is placed in front of the nostril to blow up the balloon. This device has been found helpful in patients with chronic eustachian tube dysfunction and can be helpful in the described problem.

Competing interests: None declared

do not use pseudoephedrine (Sudafed) 22 March 2004
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
alain martinole,
general practitionner
France

Myocardial infarction has been reported in a 28 year old man following pseudoephedrine intake. It also has other cardiac,neurological,and neuropsychiatric adverse reactions (see Revue Prescrire and Prescrire international )

Competing interests: Association Mieux Prescrire. No free lunch. Healthy Skepticism.

An earful of pain 21 March 2004
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Dr. Herbert H. Nehrlich,
Private Practice
Bribie Island, Australia 4507

Both my wife's uncle and her father were pilots in WW II. They did not much like the Frenzell manoeuvre because "Jerry" had devised it. Yet it was very effective, and alternatives such as blowing up a balloon or chewing gum while grinning were less effective. The uncle is now convinced that no better trick than the Jerry manoeuvre ever was invented.

Competing interests: None declared

Blocked ears and flying 20 March 2004
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Rosemary A Allan,
Consultant Radiologist
St Georges Healthcare NHS Trust, London, SW18 5PD

The best solution I've found to avoid the pain and discomfort during flight descent are some special earplugs which have a valve system that minimizes the pressure gradient across the eardrum. These are easily available in most larger Boots (especially the ones at major airports) for about a fiver. This isn't a commercial plug as I can't remember their exact name (something like 'ear-planes', but they are usually located in the travel section along with the motion sickness remedies; drugstores in the US stock a similar brand. You insert them about an hour before landing and take them out once off the plane and I think they do smaller ones for the under 5's. One pair is good for both outgoing and return journeys of one trip, provided they don't get dust/sand in them.

These earplugs are very simple to use and really do make a huge difference - I don't fly without them now.

Competing interests: None declared

Mimic swallowing 20 March 2004
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Biji T Kurien,
Senior Research Scientist
Oklahoma City, OK 73104

Just swallow saliva one or more times as necessary until one feels the ears pop open.

Competing interests: None declared

Frenzel and going up and down! 20 March 2004
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Steven M Rudolphy,
Principal
Mt Sheridan Medical Practice, Cairns, Qld 4868

Apparently the Frenzel manoevre (Frenzel was a Luftwaffe commander)- trapping air between your tongue and palate and raising your tongue while closing the nose and glottis - is an efficient way to equalise the middle ear.

Going up I suggest patients do this every 30 seconds for the first 10 minutes - planes go up fast and every 5 minutes on the way down about 40 minutes - when the announcement of starting the descent is made - descent is slow.

No evidence though.

Competing interests: None declared

Unblocking ears 19 March 2004
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Darryl M Hoffman,
attending cardiac surgeon
Beth Israel Medical center New York NY USA 10003

To complete the advice based on the scuba diving experience: equalise EARLY and OFTEN! (also GENTLY)

Competing interests: None declared

Pinch and blow 23 December 2003
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Theo Fenton,
Consultant Paediatrician
Mayday Hospital, Croydon

The "pinch and blow" method is used by descending SCUBA divers, and is just as effective for descending airline passengers. Occlude both nostrils by squeezing the end of your nose, then blow hard through your nose (no air or, er, mucus will escape from your nose if you're squeezing hard enough). You'll feel one ear pop, then the other - and great relief.

Competing interests: None declared

Drink Water 23 December 2003
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
Aaron J Baxter,
2nd year medical student
Saba University, Dutch Antilles

Nothing scientific here - drink water. I find that if I drink water as I ascend or descend on my flights, it helps dramatically. In addition to relieving that dreaded pain, it also keeps you hydrated. Eureka!

Competing interests: None declared

Blowing up a balloon 14 December 2003
Next Question and Answer Previous Question and Answer Top
john McCormack,
gp
connemara, ireland

Blowing up a balloon is great for co-operative kids.

Competing interests: None declared




Access jobs at BMJ Careers
Whats new online at Student 

BMJ