Rapid Responses to:

OBSERVATIONS:
Petra Boynton
A remedy for lonely hearts?
BMJ 2007; 335: 1240 [Full text]
*Rapid Responses: Submit a response to this article

Rapid Responses published:

[Read Rapid Response] Trawling for patients
Joan McClusky   (14 December 2007)
[Read Rapid Response] Doctor's Widow, dating problem
Barbara Gardner   (20 December 2007)
[Read Rapid Response] I Remember You
Hugh Mann   (2 May 2008)

Trawling for patients 14 December 2007
 Next Rapid Response Top
Joan McClusky,
Medical writer
New York, NY 10003

Send response to journal:
Re: Trawling for patients

This article is an absolute, horrifyng delight.

Pick a common characteristic--being single! Invent an arbitrary, and necessarily short, worrisome interval--6 months! Extrapolate the results of a marketing survey to a large, unprovable, and scientific sounding odd number--5.6 million!

Use a scary medicalese term most people know--toxins!--to simultaneously characterize a problem as emanating from an outside source and requiring professional intervention.

Use basic. relatively unsophisticated but effective medical marketing techniques: " findings" that reveal the large "community of sufferers" --You are not alone!-- and ads featuring people the community of sufferers would like to identify with--in this attractive young people hugging each other.

And most important, don't ask people whether they're boring, unreliable, bad tempered, crude, selfish, bad in bed, stupid, lack basic good grooming/ hygiene or simply haven't met the right person.

Competing interests: None declared

Doctor's Widow, dating problem 20 December 2007
Previous Rapid Response Next Rapid Response Top
Barbara Gardner,
GP's Widow
Green View, Bainbridge, DL8 3EF

Send response to journal:
Re: Doctor's Widow, dating problem

On the 19th of December I received from NHS Pensions the information that I am not entitled to remarry, enter into another civil partnership, or cohabit with a partner and continue to receive the NHS widow's pension. You who are still married in 2008 will be paying more contributions so that your spouses may marry again after your death and they will then still receive the pension. As a result of this I place this advert with you:

Sixty year old widow with alopecia, wig and half of dead husband's NHS pension seeks sex and conversation, with no strings attached, for two days a week. Why for two days only? This is to avoid being told she is cohabiting and thus lose said pension. Only one retiring professional man need apply to make this woman happier.

I think you will agree, I don't need therapy, just a fairer playing field

Competing interests: None declared

I Remember You 2 May 2008
Previous Rapid Response  Top
Hugh Mann,
Physician
Eagle Rock, MO 65641 USA

Send response to journal:
Re: I Remember You

My eyes took a picture of you
And my brain laminated it

My mouth took a taste of you
And my tongue catalogued it

My body took a measurement of you
And my arms recorded it

My feet took a walk with you
And my legs longed for more

My heart took a chance with you
And my soul opened the door

Competing interests: None declared