Rapid Responses to:

LETTERS: Phil Johnson "Black boxing:" response by editor of Hospital Doctor BMJ 1999; 319: 520 [Full text]

Rapid Responses: Submit a response to this article

Rapid Responses published:

And I thought doctors were catty

Ed Walker   (24 August 1999)

Response

Margaret M Sealey   (24 September 1999)

And I thought doctors were catty 24 August 1999
Ed Walker Send response to journal: Re: And I thought doctors were catty	The Independent's 'Pandora' is offering a prize for the person most deserving a human-scaled saucer of milk. I suggest it should be divided between Philip and Richard. Competing interests: I have a foot in both camps
Response 24 September 1999
Margaret M Sealey Send response to journal: Re: Response	Editor- You may think that 'Hospital Doctor' is a 'throwaway newspaper', (you are quoted as saying such in their letter page of the 12th August), but at least it provides a very valuable outlet for the feelings and concerns of ordinary doctors like myself. This is much more than can be said of the British Medical Association, its multiple committees, its Journal and its Editor. Dr Margaret M Sealey Consultant Anaesthetist Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Birmingham