Table 1 Baseline characteristics of patients and clinical details at trial entry. Values are numbers of patients unless otherwise indicated
|
Characteristic
|
Surgery (n=176)
|
Rehabilitation (n=173)
|
Male
|
79 (44.9)
|
93 (53.8)
|
Female
|
97 (55.1)
|
80 (46.2)
|
Age:
|
|
|
<30 years
|
24 (13.6)
|
20 (11.6)
|
30-39 years
|
63 (35.8)
|
67 (38.7)
|
40-49 years
|
56 (31.8)
|
66 (38.1)
|
50 years
|
33(18.8)
|
20 (11.6)
|
Centre:*
|
|
|
A
|
55 (31.3)
|
54 (31.2)
|
B
|
28 (15.9)
|
27 (15.6)
|
C
|
45 (25.6)
|
43 (24.9)
|
D
|
48 (27.3)
|
49 (28.3)
|
Mean duration of back pain years (range) in years
|
8 (1-35)
|
8 (1-35)
|
Current smokers
|
76 (43.2)
|
74 (42.8)
|
Litigation
|
25 (14.2)
|
21 (12.1)
|
Currently in paid employment
|
88 (50.0)
|
94 (54.3)
|
Back pain interfered patient's ability to work:
|
149 (84.7)
|
149 (86.1)
|
Had to give up job
|
65 (43.6)
|
67 (45.0)
|
Had to change job
|
19 (12.7)
|
10 (6.7)
|
Had to reduce hours
|
17 (11.4)
|
12 (8.0)
|
Had to take sick leave
|
59 (39.6)
|
69 (46.3)
|
Clinical details
|
|
|
Clinical classification:
|
|
|
Spondylolisthesis
|
20 (11.4)
|
18 (10.4)
|
Post-laminectomy
|
14 (8.0)
|
14 (8.1)
|
Chronic low back pain
|
142 (80.6)
|
141 (81.5)
|
Planned surgery type:
|
|
|
Graf
|
27 (15.3)
|
28 (16.2)
|
Fusion
|
149 (84.7)
|
144 (83.2)
|
Missing
|
0
|
1 (0.6)
|
Planned fused level:
|
|
|
Single level
|
100 (56.8)
|
109 (63.0)
|
>1 level
|
70 (39.8)
|
62 (35.8)
|
Missing
|
6 (3.4)
|
2 (1.2)
|
Mean score (SD)
|
|
|
Oswestry disability index
|
46.5 (14.6)
|
44.8 (14.8)
|
Shuttle walking test in metres
|
254 (209)
|
247 (185)
|
SF-36 physical component score
|
19.4 (8.8)
|
20 (9.7)
|
SF-36 mental component score
|
43.2 (10.9)
|
44.2 (12.6)
|
Modified somatic perception questionnaire
|
9.0 (6.4)
|
7.7 (5.7)
|
Zung self rating depression scale
|
31.8 (10.4)
|
31.2 (11.8)
|
Distress and risk assessment method:
|
|
|
Normal
|
14 (8.0)
|
14 (8.1)
|
At risk
|
65 (36.9)
|
85 (49.1)
|
Distressed depressive
|
87 (49.4)
|
69 (39.9)
|
Distressed somatic
|
9 (5.1)
|
2 (1.2)
|
Missing
|
1 (0.6)
|
3 (1.7)
|
|
* Refers to the three largest recruiting centres and a pool of the remaining centres.