BMJ  2004;328:418-419 (21 February), doi:10.1136/bmj.328.7437.418

Editorial

No time to train the surgeons

More and more reforms result in less and less time for training

Surgical training in the United Kingdom is beset by fundamental problems raising what has been described as "considerable disquiet amongst trainees and trainers."¹ Basic and higher surgical trainees progress through a system comprehensively reformed five years ago to emphasise structured training, supervision, and regular assessment. So why are senior house officers' skill levels regarded by trainees and trainers as "very shallow"?² Why is there insufficient capacity in the system to train surgeons in the way that their trainers want?³ And why is it that, in a recent poll of consultant surgeons, two thirds would not wish to be operated on by a Calman trained consultant colleague?⁴

In 1993 Sir Kenneth Calman proposed reforms of the registrar grades to bring the United Kingdom into line with a European Union directive on medical training. It was hoped that encouraging structured learning and supervision would compensate for reducing training time. The European Working Time Directive became part of British law in 1998, and it means that soon no doctor may work more than 48 hours a week. The combined impact of these two reforms on surgical training is profound.

Before Calmanisation and the European Working Time Directive a trainee could expect to work over 30 000 hours between becoming a senior house officer and getting a consultant post. The Royal College of Surgeons calculates that this will now fall to 8000 hours.⁵ The chief medical officer proposes reforms that would further reduce this to 6000 hours.⁶ To become a competent surgeon in one fifth of the time once needed either requires genius, intensive practice, or lower standards. We are not geniuses. So has there been an increase in the intensity of teaching to compensate for the fivefold decrease in the length of surgical training?

Well no, not really. The largest ever survey of senior house officers in orthopaedic surgery showed that a third of these trainees were not taught in theatre or clinic.⁷ That many senior house officers arrive at posts halfway through their rotations without any real competence in operative skills as basic as suturing and tying knots is therefore unsurprising. This alone makes it difficult for them to progress to performing operations like appendicectomies, which most current registrars were doing as pre-registration house officers. The fact that house officers compete with registrars for training time makes this transition impossible for some.

Those surgeons who successfully negotiate the bottleneck between basic and higher surgical training posts find that their training needs are often incompatible with a system geared increasingly to provide service. When registrars need more time than consultants to perform procedures³; when consultants' results are audited irrespective of who performed the operation; when trusts' stars and status depend on output and outcome, where is the incentive to train? And where are the resources? One regional survey indicated that, even with trainees performing every operation, the total number of procedures available was a third less than the minimum recommended by their trainers.³ The increase in theatre time required for increased trainee operating in one specialty was estimated at 270 extra theatre days per year, at a cost to the region of £1.3m.³

Reform after reform of the NHS has been driven and informed by factors frequently very far away from the realities of providing surgical patients with continuity of care and of training the next generation of surgeons. Those of us lucky enough to be under way with our training on good teaching rotations can only feel relief that we are not in the cohort coming behind.

We cannot rely on highly able and motivated trainees and trainers to struggle on like this. Surgical training must be recognised as a priority, and it must be resourced with the time and funding, not only for skills courses and wet labs (where surgeons can practise techniques on appropriate models), but also for dedicated training lists and clinics, just as happened for waiting list initiatives.^{1 5 7} Not all consultants should be obliged to train all trainees^{1 8}; those consultants that do choose to undertake the additional responsibility and workload of training should be better supported.^{1 3 5 8} Why should they not also be rewarded? Senior trainees should benefit from a substantial period of supervised independent operating similar to the old senior registrar grade,¹ and assessment needs to be competency based, not dependent on a fixed time period in the grade.^{5 8}

Most current trainees are supposed to become the new "generalist" surgeons who will carry out common procedures, referring more complex patients on to "specialist" consultant colleagues.⁹ We are left in the worrying situation where 6000 hours of surgical training in its current state may not be enough to produce these new generalists, let alone provide consultants that can go on to become the kind of specialist consultant surgeon that we take for granted today.

(j.chikwe{at}medschl.cam.ac.uk), Cardiothoracic Surgery, Royal Brompton Hospital, London SW3 6NP

(t.desouza{at}rbh.nthames.nhs.uk), Cardiothoracic Surgery, Royal Brompton Hospital, London SW3 6NP

(m.shah{at}rbh.nthames.nhs.uk), Cardiothoracic Surgery, Royal Brompton Hospital, London SW3 6NP

---

Competing interests: None declared.

References

1. Murday A, Hamilton L, Magee P, Hyde J. The conflict between service and training in cardiothoracic surgery: a report of a short-life working group of the Society of Cardiothoracic Surgeons of Great Britain and Ireland. London: Society of Cardiothoracic Surgeons of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, 2000.
2. De Cossart L, Wiltshire C, Brown J. An audit of the operative skills of SHOs on BST programmes. Ann R Coll Surg Eng 2001;83(suppl): S326-7.
3. Crofts TJ, Griffiths JM, Sharma S, Wygrala J, Aitkin RJ. Surgical training: an objective assessment of recent changes for a single health board. BMJ 1997;314: 814.[Free Full Text]
4. Morris Stiff GJ, Clarke D, Torkington J, Bowrey DJ, Mansel RE. Taining in the Calman era: what consultants say. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 2002;84(suppl): 345-7.
5. Phillip H, Fleet Z, Bowman K. The European Working Time Directive—interim report and guidance from The Royal College of Surgeons of England Working Party. London: Royal College of Surgeons, January 2003.
6. Donaldson L. Unfinished business: proposals for reform of the senior house officer grade. NHS consultation paper. London: Department of Health, August 2002.
7. British Orthopaedic Association. Education and training for SHOs: a snapshot of the moment and recommendations for the future. London: British Orthopaedic Association, July 2002.
8. Liaison Group of the Specialist Training Authority, Joint Committee of Postgraduate Training for General Practice and the General Medical Council. Policy statement. Taking stock: the challenges facing medical training and education within a changing NHS. London: Specialist Training Authority, December 2002.
9. Department of Health. Modernising medical careers: the response of the four UK health ministers to the consultation on unfinished business. London: DoH, February 2003.

CiteULike    Complore    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    What's this?

Relevant Articles

No time to train the surgeons: Royal College of Surgeons of England responds

Peter J Morris
BMJ 2004 328: 1133. [Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]

No time to train the surgeons: Medical profession must re-establish its independence from government

Alan M Leaman
BMJ 2004 328: 1133. [Extract] [Full Text]

No time to train the surgeons: Only repeal of European Working Time Directive will help

Neville W Goodman
BMJ 2004 328: 1133. [Extract] [Full Text]

No time to train the surgeons: Golden age of surgical training didn't exist

David T Reilly
BMJ 2004 328: 1133-1134. [Extract] [Full Text]

No time to train the surgeons: The rot is deep

Aman S Coonar
BMJ 2004 328: 1134. [Extract] [Full Text]

No time to train the surgeons: Learning from the New Zealand experience

Lauren Ovens
BMJ 2004 328: 1134. [Extract] [Full Text]

No time to train the surgeons: Choosing trainees carefully may be the solution

Vipin Zamvar
BMJ 2004 328: 1134. [Extract] [Full Text]

No time to train the surgeons: Summary of rapid responses

Birte Twisselmann
BMJ 2004 328: 1134-1135. [Extract] [Full Text]

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Al-Ruzzeh, S., Karthik, S., O'Regan, D. (2007). Objective surgical skill assessment: the diagonal operating matrix. ICVTS 6: 188-191 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Lim, E., Tsui, S., on behalf of the Registrars and Consultant Cardiac, (2006). Impact of the European Working Time Directive on exposure to operative cardiac surgical training.. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg. 30: 574-577 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Yentis, S M (2005). The use of patients for learning and maintaining practical skills. JRSM 98: 299-302 [Full text]  
• Milton, R., White, R., Munsch, C. (2005). An introductory educational module for cardiothoracic trainees. ICVTS 4: 5-8 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Rathinam, S., Rajesh, P.B., Collins, F.J. (2005). Reply to Rocco. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg. 27: 175-176 [Full text]  
• Monro, J. L. (2004). The next challenge--adapting to change. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg. 26: 1063-1072 [Full text]  
• Fielder, A. R, Murray, P., Gibson, A., Watson, M., Moseley, M., Boulton, M. (2004). Ophthalmic surgical training. JRSM 97: 361-361 [Full text]  
• Morris, P. J (2004). No time to train the surgeons: Royal College of Surgeons of England responds. BMJ 328: 1133-1133 [Full text]  
• Coonar, A. S (2004). No time to train the surgeons: The rot is deep. BMJ 328: 1134-1134 [Full text]  
• Leaman, A. M (2004). No time to train the surgeons: Medical profession must re-establish its independence from government. BMJ 328: 1133-1133 [Full text]  
• Goodman, N. W (2004). No time to train the surgeons: Only repeal of European Working Time Directive will help. BMJ 328: 1133-1133 [Full text]  
• Reilly, D. T (2004). No time to train the surgeons: Golden age of surgical training didn't exist. BMJ 328: 1133-1134 [Full text]  
• Ovens, L. (2004). No time to train the surgeons: Learning from the New Zealand experience. BMJ 328: 1134-1134 [Full text]  
• Zamvar, V. (2004). No time to train the surgeons: Choosing trainees carefully may be the solution. BMJ 328: 1134-1134 [Full text]  

Rapid Responses:

Read all Rapid Responses

Wrong number of hours - which don't matter - quality does

W A Carrock Sewell
bmj.com, 20 Feb 2004 [Full text]

RCS response on training time for surgeons

Peter J Morris
bmj.com, 20 Feb 2004 [Full text]

And not just surgeons

Neville W Goodman
bmj.com, 20 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Practice makes perfect

Abdul Ghaaliq Lalkhen, et al.
bmj.com, 20 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Worse is yet to come

Norman P Briffa
bmj.com, 20 Feb 2004 [Full text]

ONUS IS ON THE TRAINERS AND FUTURE PATIENTS

Joseph I. Yikona
bmj.com, 20 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Re: Worse is yet to come

Thein H Oo, MD, MRCP(UK)
bmj.com, 21 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Revisiting the Lost Tribes

Paul L Thorpe
bmj.com, 21 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Hours spent do not equate to quality of training.

Saleem Althaf
bmj.com, 22 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Responsibility for progression to consultant status lies with trainees as well

Ketan Dhatariya
bmj.com, 22 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Re: No Time to Train Surgeons

Mano Sira
bmj.com, 22 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Re: Re: No Time to Train Surgeons

Thein H Oo
bmj.com, 23 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Untrained Junior Surgeons

Robert M Heddle
bmj.com, 23 Feb 2004 [Full text]

No time to train surgeons

Miles Fox
bmj.com, 23 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Re; No time to train the surgeons

James A McCaul, et al.
bmj.com, 23 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Speciality Competency Licence?

Jeffrey C McILwain
bmj.com, 23 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Safe in our dotage

Raymond W Clarke
bmj.com, 23 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Surgical training in the UK: A solution

Vipin Zamvar
bmj.com, 24 Feb 2004 [Full text]

The new consultant contract will not help

Christopher G Moran
bmj.com, 24 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Surgical Training in Crisis

Simon Cole
bmj.com, 24 Feb 2004 [Full text]

The rot goes deeper

Aman S Coonar
bmj.com, 24 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Time, efficiency, effectiveness and competence

Jeffrey C McILwain
bmj.com, 24 Feb 2004 [Full text]

No time to train the surgeons

Alan M Leaman
bmj.com, 24 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Give trainees a sporting chance

Andrew S Ramsay
bmj.com, 25 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Don't miss training opportunities

Michelle H Mullan
bmj.com, 27 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Re: Re: No time to train the surgeons.

Thomas J Edwards
bmj.com, 28 Feb 2004 [Full text]

Re: Re: Re: No time to train the surgeons.

David T Reilly
bmj.com, 1 Mar 2004 [Full text]

High Time for the Specialist Grade

Alfred P J Lake
bmj.com, 4 Mar 2004 [Full text]

The mindset has to change

Maya A. Harris
bmj.com, 5 Mar 2004 [Full text]

Room for improvement in the current system.

Babar B Chaudhri
bmj.com, 6 Mar 2004 [Full text]

No Time to Train the Surgeons

Ian D Fraser
bmj.com, 10 Mar 2004 [Full text]

No time to train the surgeons

JCH McDonald
bmj.com, 10 Mar 2004 [Full text]

The importance of preclinical training and personal contacts.

Richard G Fiddian-Geen
bmj.com, 11 Mar 2004 [Full text]

Maximising operating theatre training

Dr Seema Darshane
bmj.com, 15 Mar 2004 [Full text]

Learning from th New Zealand Experience

Lauren Ovens
bmj.com, 16 Mar 2004 [Full text]

More than time needed to train surgeons

Alistair R Fielder, et al.
bmj.com, 6 May 2004 [Full text]