Jump to: Page Content, Site Navigation, Site Search,
You are seeing this message because your web browser does not support basic web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing and what you can do to make your experience on this site better.
John Danesh Clinical Trial
Service Unit and Epidemiological Studies Unit, Nuffield Department of
Clinical Medicine, University of Oxford, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford
OX2 6HE
Correspondence to: J Danesh
john.danesh{at}balliol.ox.ac.uk
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objectives:
To examine the association between
coronary heart disease and chronic Helicobacter pylori infection.
Design:
Case-control study of myocardial infarction at
young ages and study of sibling pairs with one member affected and the
other not.
Setting:
United Kingdom.
Participants:
1122 survivors of suspected acute
myocardial infarction at ages 30-49 (mean age 44 years) and 1122 age
and sex matched controls with no history of coronary heart disease; 510 age and sex matched pairs of siblings (mean age 59 years) in which one
sibling had survived myocardial infarction and one had no history of
coronary heart disease.
Main outcome measures:
Serological evidence of chronic
infection with H pylori.
Results:
472 (42%) of the 1122 cases with early onset myocardial infarction were seropositive for H pylori
antibodies compared with 272 (24%) of the 1122 age and sex matched
controls, giving an odds ratio of 2.28 (99% confidence interval 1.80 to 2.90). This odds ratio fell to 1.87 (1.42 to 2.47; P<0.0001) after smoking and indicators of socioeconomic status were adjusted for and to
1.75 (1.29 to 2.36) after additional adjustment for blood lipid
concentrations and obesity. Only 158 of the 510 pairs of siblings were
discordant for H pylori status; among these, 91 cases and 67 controls were seropositive (odds ratio 1.33 (0.86 to 2.05)). No strong
correlations were observed between H pylori seropositivity
and measurements of other risk factors for coronary heart disease
(plasma lipids, fibrinogen, C reactive protein, albumin, etc).
Conclusion:
In the context of results from other
relevant studies, these two studies suggest a moderate association
between coronary heart disease and H pylori
seropositivity that cannot be fully accounted for by other risk
factors. But even if this association is causal and largely reversible
by eradication of chronic infection, very large randomised trials would
be needed to show this.
|
Key messages
|
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
By 1998, more than 25 epidemiological studies had reported on the
association between Helicobacter pylori seropositivity and vascular disease, including nine studies that reported on a total of
about 2000 cases of non-fatal myocardial infarction or death from
coronary heart disease.
1 2
In aggregate, these published reports indicated a weakly positive association, leading to suggestions that H pylori infection might be an avoidable cause of
coronary heart disease. But there is substantial heterogeneity among
the findings of these nine studies of coronary heart disease
(
28=53; P<0.0001), with reports of
strong associations with coronary heart disease in smaller studies
generally not confirmed by larger and better designed studies (odds
ratio 2.28 in studies of <200 cases v 1.07 in studies of
200 cases;
21=5.5; P<0.05). Four
of the nine studies were prospective, with a weighted mean age at
coronary heart disease event of 66 years. These prospective studies
should be more reliable than the retrospective studies since, in
addition to their general advantages (such as minimisation of bias in
case-control studies), they included larger numbers of cases (total of
1441) and better adjustment for standard risk factors and markers of
socioeconomic status. There was no evidence of heterogeneity among them
(
23=2.4; P>0.1), and a combined
analysis yielded a risk ratio of 1.15 (99% confidence interval 0.91 to
1.45).2
Although this meta-analysis of prospective studies argues against a
strong association between H pylori infection and coronary heart disease, it cannot reliably confirm or exclude a moderate association. Studies of patients with early onset coronary heart disease may help to determine whether such an association exists since
vascular risk factors (such as smoking, blood cholesterol, and blood
pressure
3 4
) are often more strongly related to disease
at younger ages. We report two complementary studies, one comparing
young patients with acute myocardial infarction with young controls
(which should maximise the strength of any association) and one
comparing people with myocardial infarction at any age with an
unaffected sibling (which should minimise any artefactual association
due to confounding factors).
| |
Participants and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cases and controls
Patients with suspected acute myocardial infarction were
randomised within 24 hours of the onset of symptoms in the third
international study of infarct survival (ISIS-3)5 trial of
fibrinolytic and antithrombotic treatments; in the United Kingdom, an
epidemiological questionnaire was sent to them a few months later.3 Respondents were asked to provide contact details
for their siblings and children aged over 30 living in the United Kingdom so that similar questionnaires could be sent to them, with an
additional copy for their spouses; 21 703 (47%) of 46 441 such
relatives and 13 577 of their spouses completed the questionnaire, with 30 126 respondents denying any history of coronary heart disease.
Patients with a history of stroke, gastrointestinal bleeding, or peptic
ulceration tended not to be recruited into the ISIS-3 trial because of
the treatments being evaluated, so people who reported such conditions
were not eligible for the present studies: this excluded 1900 (6%)
relatives or spouses without a history of coronary heart disease. A
further 13 were excluded because they provided insufficient
information, leaving 28 213 potential controls.
Questionnaires
Controls were asked about their current body size, education,
medical history, and consumption of cigarettes and alcohol, whereas
cases were asked about their habits and history just before their index
myocardial infarction (because having a heart attack may alter
behaviour).3 Reported indicators of socioeconomic status
included smoking, age ended full time education, number of live
siblings, and height (with the last two regarded as markers of
childhood crowding and nutritional deprivation6 respectively). Household income was estimated from the current postcode
by using computer software that has been found to produce reasonably
high correlations (R=0.40; P<0.0001) with self reported income.7 The birth rank of participants was estimated from the ages of their living siblings, since it has been suggested that
having older siblings predisposes to earlier acquisition of H
pylori.8
Blood samples
Blood was collected into 10 ml vacutainers containing 0.12 ml
preservative (15% potassium EDTA with 0.34 mmol/l aprotinin). Samples
were obtained from cases immediately after randomisation (within 24 hours of symptoms) but before the ISIS-3 trial treatments began. After
returning the study questionnaire, potential controls were sent
identical vacutainers for blood collection by their general
practitioner. Whole blood samples were received by post in the central
laboratory after a mean of two days and centrifuged, with plasma and
buffy coat aliquots stored at
40oC.
Laboratory methods
We measured H pylori specific IgG titres in previously
unthawed plasma samples, blind to case-control status, by enzyme linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA; Orion, Espoo, Finland) using the
manufacturer's pre-specified cut off for seropositivity (titre
300). The intra-assay and interassay coefficients of variation for
manufacturer's standards were 2% and 3% respectively. The reproducibility of H pylori serology within individuals was
determined (in order to assess regression dilution9) in
blood samples taken three years apart from 1065 controls (of whom 115 were in the study of early onset myocardial infarction). We used
Beckman CX-4 and CX-5 autoanalysers to measure cholesterol and albumin concentrations (both with Beckman reagents) and apolipoprotein A1 and B concentrations (Immuno reagents).
Fibrinogen was measured with a Nephelometer Analyzer II (Behring
reagents). The intra-assay and interassay coefficients of variation
were 2% and 3% for both cholesterol and albumin and 2% and 6% for
both apolipoproteins and fibrinogen.
Statistical methods
We analysed the case-control study of early onset myocardial
infarction using unmatched stratified logistic regression fitted by
unconditional maximum likelihood and the sibling pair study using
matched analyses and conditional maximum likelihood. Explanatory
variables in the main adjusted analyses included age, sex, current
cigarette smoking habit, age ended full time education, estimated
household income, reported height, and geographical region of
residence. (Subsidiary analyses included adjustment for blood lipid
concentrations and obesity, but these factors were not strongly
associated with H pylori serology in this study or in a
synthesis of previous studies.11) Controls who were
brothers or sisters of cases had, on average, more siblings than the
cases, and so the analyses were standardised for the number of living
siblings.10 Non-fasting blood total cholesterol, apolipoprotein A1 and B, albumin, fibrinogen, and
C reactive protein concentrations were also investigated as possible
correlates of H pylori seropositivity. Odds ratios are given
with 99% confidence intervals to allow for their exploratory nature,
and two sided probability values are used.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Case-control study of suspected myocardial infarction at ages
30-49
Table 1 shows the characteristics of cases and their age and sex
matched controls. As expected, known vascular risk factors (such as
smoking and blood lipids) differed significantly between cases and
controls. In all, 472 (42%) of the cases were seropositive for H
pylori antibodies compared with 272 (24%) of the controls (table
2). This difference yielded an odds ratio of 2.28 (99% confidence
interval 1.80 to 2.90), which fell to 1.87 (1.42 to 2.47) after smoking
and indicators of socioeconomic status were adjusted for and to 1.75 (1.29 to 2.36) after additional adjustment for blood lipids and
obesity. Varying the cut off titre for seropositivity did not
materially alter the estimate, and the association did not seem to
differ with age (table 2) or birth order (data not
shown).
|
|
Sibling pair study of suspected myocardial infarction at ages
30-79
Matching cases of suspected myocardial infarction (mean age 59)
with siblings of the same sex and similar age resulted in less extreme
differences between cases and controls in various markers of
socioeconomic status (table 3). The differences in some vascular
risk factors (for example, current smoking, blood cholesterol
concentration) also seemed smaller, perhaps because of the older
average age of the sibling pairs as well as the matching. But
discordance in H pylori seropositivity among the 510 sibling pairs was uncommon; only 91 seropositive cases had seronegative control
siblings and 67 seronegative cases had seropositive controls (table 4).
The ratio of these numbers of discordant pairs gave an odds ratio of
1.33 (99% confidence interval 0.86 to 2.05), which was not much
altered by adjustment for smoking and indicators of socioeconomic
status (1.37; 0.87 to 2.15) or by additional adjustment for blood
lipids and obesity (1.29; 0.78 to 2.13). When attention was restricted
to the 420 pairs in which neither was included as a case or a control
in the study of early onset myocardial infarction, 75 seropositive
cases had seronegative control siblings and 54 seronegative cases had
seropositive controls, again giving an odds ratio of 1.30 (0.81 to
2.11) that was largely unchanged by adjustments for smoking and
indicators of socioeconomic status (1.34; 0.81 to 2.20).
Persistence of H pylori seropositivity and correlations
with other characteristics
Of 430 participants who were H pylori seropositive at
first testing, 411 (96%) remained so three years later, and 628 (99%)
of 635 participants remained seronegative. There were no clearly
significant differences between the mean concentrations of blood total
cholesterol, apolipoproteins, fibrinogen, C reactive protein, or
albumin or of alcohol consumption among H pylori
seropositive and seronegative individuals in the two studies (table 5).
This is consistent with the results of a meta-analysis of 18 studies with information on 10 000 people.11 Consequently,
adjustment for these factors would not be expected to alter materially
any association between H pylori and myocardial infarction,
and it did not do so.
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Previous studies have not provided convincing epidemiological evidence for or against a causal association between H pylori infection and coronary heart disease, largely because they were limited by small sample sizes and incomplete adjustment for potential confounders. 1 2 Our studies are comparatively large, adding more than 1600 cases of myocardial infarction to the aggregate of 2000 cases of non-fatal myocardial infarction or death from coronary heart disease available previously. Moreover, they involve many cases at young ages (when associations with other risk factors are generally stronger) and include adjustment for several potential confounding factors. The results of both our studies are consistent with a moderate association between H pylori seropositivity and coronary heart disease, particularly at younger ages.
|
|
|
Strengths and limitations of case-control study
Some factors in our case-control study of early myocardial
infarction could have led to underestimation of the role of H
pylori. Firstly, almost half of the controls were siblings or
children of someone who had survived a myocardial infarction (although
they were not necessarily relatives of the cases in the study). As
H pylori is often spread within families during
childhood,12 if infection has a role in coronary heart disease relatives of survivors of myocardial infarction would have
greater risks of carrying the infection than would the general population. The effects of any such "overmatching" would not be large, however, and the 24% H pylori seroprevalence in
the controls is about that expected in the British population aged
30-49.13
for example,
overrepresentation of higher social classes13
this might
have produced exaggerated results. For the study results to be
explained entirely by differences in social class, however, all cases
would have to have come from the lowest two social classes and all
controls from the top two (assuming seroprevalences based on other
studies13 of 40% and 20% at these two extremes). Such
gross selection bias is implausible, and, moreover, the estimated mean
household incomes of potentially eligible controls who provided blood
samples and of those who did not were similar (£19 600 v
£18 800). Nevertheless, some residual confounding is suggested by the
reduction in the odds ratio from 2.28 (
21=79) to
1.87 (
21=35)
after smoking and some imperfect indicators of socioeconomic status
were adjusted for. The fact that such crude adjustment reduced the odds
ratio so substantially suggests that exact adjustment for all
confounders would have produced an even greater reduction, but such
considerations are difficult to quantify.
Strengths and limitations of sibling pair study
Studying sibling pairs should provide better matching for
socioeconomic status and should also help avoid selection biases. But,
as 69% of the pairs had the same H pylori status (which is
similar to the 60% concordance rate reported among several hundred
non-identical Swedish twins18), only 158 pairs were discordant and hence informative about any association with myocardial infarction. The odds ratio of seropositivity for myocardial infarction was 1.33 (99% confidence interval 0.86 to 2.05) and was largely unchanged after adjustment. This suggests that exact adjustment for the
truly relevant factors would have little effect. Although this odds
ratio is not significant, it is compatible with the results of our
study of early onset myocardial infarction and published prospective
studies (figure).
|
Conclusions
Ever since the early claims of strong associations, the evidence
for an association between H pylori and coronary heart
disease has steadily weakened. Our findings
together with a
meta-analysis of previous reports
renew the possibility of a moderate
association, particularly in early middle age, but exclude the
existence of a strong one. Hence, unless epidemiological studies of
H pylori subtypes (or of other infective agents) give more extreme relative risks, randomised trials of anti-infective
interventions may be needed to help determine causality. Even if a
causal link exists, any effect of infection on risk of coronary heart
disease might not be rapidly and fully reversible (as is the case with other risk factor interventions19). Hence, trials of
interventions against infection might need to randomise large numbers
of participants and to observe them for several years to assess
reliably any effects on coronary heart disease.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank the patients and their relatives who participated in the ISIS studies, their general practitioners, and the medical and nursing staff from the participating hospitals in the United Kingdom; Peter Froggatt, Cheryl Swann, and Robert Waller of the Independent Scientific Committee on Smoking and Health, Department of Health; and Stewart Cederholm-Williams and Julian Marshall of Oxford Bio-Research Laboratory.
Contributors: RC, RP, SP, and LY established the ISIS epidemiological database. JD helped with H pylori serum antibody measurements, analysed the data, and drafted the manuscript. SC performed laboratory measurements. All authors edited the manuscript. Jill Barton and Kathy Jayne coordinated questionnaire data collection. Deanne Lloyd, Buki Chukwurah, Janet Taylor, and Joy Hill helped with laboratory measurements. Alison Palmer and Paul Appleby helped with data analysis and computing. JD is the study guarantor.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Funding: JD is supported by Merton College and a Frohlich award, and RC holds a British Heart Foundation professorship. The ISIS trials and epidemiological studies were supported by the manufacturers of the study drugs5 and by the British Heart Foundation, Medical Research Council, Imperial Cancer Research Fund, and Tobacco Products Research Trust of the Independent Scientific Committee on Smoking and Health, Department of Health.
Competing interests: None declared.
website extra: Collaborators and participating centres are listed on the BMJ's website www.bmj.com
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| 1. | Danesh J, Collins R, Peto R. Chronic infections and coronary heart disease: is there a link? Lancet 1997; 350: 430-436[Medline]. |
| 2. | Danesh J, Appleby P. Persistent infection and vascular disease: a systematic review. Expert Opin Invest Drugs 1998; 7: 691-713. |
| 3. |
Parish S, Collins R, Peto R, Youngman L, Barton J, Jayne K, et al.
Cigarette smoking tar yields, and non-fatal myocardial infarction: 14 000 cases and 32 000 controls in the United Kingdom.
BMJ
1995;
311:
471-477 |
| 4. | Prospective Studies Collaboration. Cholesterol, diastolic blood pressure, and stroke: 13 000 strokes in 450 000 people in 45 prospective cohorts. Lancet 1995; 346: 1647-1653[Medline]. |
| 5. | ISIS-3 (Third International Study of Infarct Survival) Collaborative Group. ISIS-3: a randomised comparison of streptokinase vs tissue plasminogen activator vs anistreplase and of aspirin plus heparin vs aspirin alone among 41 229 cases of suspected acute myocardial infarction. Lancet 1992; 339: 753-770[Medline]. |
| 6. |
Yarnell JWG, Limb ES, Layzell JM, Baker IA.
Height: a risk marker for ischaemic heart disease.
Eur Heart J
1992;
13:
1602-1605 |
| 7. |
Danesh J, Semmence J, Gault S, Appleby P, Peto R.
Postcodes as useful markers of social class: population-based study in 26 000 British households.
BMJ
1999;
318:
843-845 |
| 8. |
Blaser MJ, Chyou PH, Nomura A.
Age at establishment of Helicobacter pylori infection and gastric carcinoma, gastric ulcer, and duodenal ulcer risk.
Cancer Res
1995;
55:
562-565 |
| 9. |
MacMahon S, Peto R, Cutler J, Collins R, Sorlie P, Neaton J, et al.
Blood pressure, stroke, and coronary heart disease part 1. Prolonged differences in blood pressure: prospective observational studies corrected for the regression dilution bias.
Lancet
1990;
335:
765-774[Medline].
|
| 10. | Mendall MA, Goggin PM, Molineaux N, Levy J, Toosy T, Strachan D, et al. Childhood living conditions and Helicobacter pylori seropositivity in adult life. Lancet 1992; 339: 896-897[Medline]. |
| 11. |
Danesh J, Peto R.
Risk factors for coronary heart disease and infection with Helicobacter pylori: meta-analysis of 18 studies.
BMJ
1998;
316:
1130-1132 |
| 12. |
Goodman KJ, Correa P.
The transmission of Helicobacter pylori. A critical review of the evidence.
Int J Epidemiol
1995;
24:
875-887 |
| 13. |
Sitas F, Forman D, Yarnell JWG, Burr ML, Elwood PC, Pedley S, et al.
Helicobacter pylori infection rates in relation to age and social class in a population of Welsh men.
Gut
1991;
32:
25-28 |
| 14. | Feldman RA, Evans SJW. Accuracy of diagnostic methods used for epidemiological studies of Helicobacter pylori. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 1995; 9(suppl 2): 21-31. |
| 15. |
Sonke GS, Beaglehole R, Stewart AW, Jackson R, Stewart FM.
Sex differences in case fatality before and after admission to hospital after acute cardiac events: analysis of community based coronary heart disease register.
BMJ
1996;
313:
853-855 |
| 16. | Crabtree JE, Taylor JD, Wyatt JI, Heatley RV, Shallcross TM, Tompkins DS, et al. Mucosal IgA recognition of Helicobacter pylori 120KDa protein, peptic ulceration, and gastric pathology. Lancet 1991; 338: 332-335[Medline]. |
| 17. |
Pasceri V, Cammarota G, Patti G, Cucoc L, Gasbarrini A, Grillo RL, et al.
Association of virulent Helicobacter pylori strains with ischemic heart disease.
Circulation
1998;
97:
1675-1679 |
| 18. |
Malaty HM, Engstrand L, Pedersen NL, Graham DY.
Helicobacter pylori: genetic and environmental influences. A study of twins.
Ann Intern Med
1994;
120:
982-986 |
| 19. | Collins R, Peto R, Gray R, Parish S. Large-scale randomized evidence: trials and overviews. In: Weatherall D, Ledingham JGG, Warrell DA, eds. Oxford textbook of medicine. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996:21-32. |
(Accepted 29 July 1999)
Read all Rapid Responses