Jump to: Page Content, Site Navigation, Site Search,
You are seeing this message because your web browser does not support basic web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing and what you can do to make your experience on this site better.
Judith A Stewart a Department of Public Health Sciences, Guy's,
King's College, and St Thomas's School of Medicine, 5th Floor,
Capital House, London SE1 3QD, b Department of Neurology, St
Thomas's Hospital, London SE1 5EH, c Stroke Unit, St
Thomas's Hospital, London SE1 5EH
Correspondence to: Dr
Wolfe c.wolfe{at}umds.ac.uk
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective:
To identify ethnic differences in the
incidence of first ever stroke.
Design:
A prospective community stroke register
(1995-6) with multiple notification sources. Pathological
classification of stroke in all cases was based on brain imaging or
necropsy data. Rates were standardised to European and world
populations and adjusted for age, sex, and social class in multivariate analysis.
Setting:
A multi-ethnic population of 234 533 in
south London, of whom 21% are black.
Results:
612 strokes were registered. The crude annual incidence rate was 1.3 strokes per 1000 population per year (95% confidence interval 1.20 to 1.41) and 1.25 per 1000 population per year
(1.15 to 1.35) age adjusted to the standard European population.
Incidence rates adjusted for age and sex were significantly higher in
black compared with white people (P<0.0001), with an incidence rate
ratio of 2.21 (1.77 to 2.76). In multivariable analysis increasing age
(P<0.0001), male sex (P<0.003), black ethnic group (P<0.0001), and
lower social class (P<0.0001) in people aged 35-64 were independently
associated with an increased incidence of stroke.
Conclusions:
Incidence rates of stroke are higher in
the black population; this is not explained by confounders such as social class, age, and sex. Ethnic differences in genetic,
physiological, and behavioural risk factors for stroke require further
elucidation to aid development of effective strategies for stroke
prevention in multi-ethnic communities.
|
Key messages
|
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Incidence rates of first stroke in different white populations worldwide have been determined.1-3 A study in the United States showed a twofold increase in the incidence in one black population,4 but no data are available on black populations in Europe. Mortality from stroke, however, is higher among black people than white people in the United Kingdom and the United States. 5 6 In Britain, Caribbean immigrants have the highest mortality from stroke, with some evidence that this is due to increased incidence rather than case fatality. 7 8 Previous studies in black populations are difficult to interpret because of methodological inconsistencies. 7 9
In the United Kingdom there are targets to reduce mortality from
stroke.10 These are difficult to attain without accurate incidence data. In 1989-90 a community stroke register in south London
identified that ethnicity was associated with incidence of stroke in
residents aged under 75 years.11 The south London stroke
register was established to investigate ethnic differences in the
natural history of stroke. We present incidence data for the first 2 years (1 January 1995 to 31 December 1996).
| |
Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Details of register
A population based stroke register that recorded first stroke in
patients of all age groups was set up with standard criteria.12 Data were collected prospectively by the
registry team, comprising a neurologist and two nurses. By using 12 referral sources cases of stroke were identified in a defined area
corresponding to 22 wards of Lambeth, Southwark, and Lewisham Health
Commission. The total population (234 533) is 72% white, 21% black
(11% Afro-Caribbean, 7.5% West African, and 2.5% black mixed), and
3% Asian, Bangladeshi, and Pakistani.13 Hospital
surveillance of admissions for stroke included two teaching hospitals
within and three outside the study area. Community surveillance of
stroke included patients under the care of all general practitioners
within and on the borders of the study area (n=147).
|
Analysis
The denominators for the calculations of incidence rate were
the 1996 adjusted estimates of the 1991 census data from the Office for
National Statistics for the study area with 10 year age groups (0-14;
15-24 to 75-84; >85). Incidence rates specific for sex and ethnic
group were adjusted for age to standard European and world populations.
To enable comparisons with the MONICA (monitoring trends and
determinants in cardiovascular disease) populations, rates adjusted for
age were also calculated for ages 35-64 only. Confidence intervals for
the age specific rates and age adjusted rates were calculated by using
the Poisson distribution. Incidence rate ratios for black to white were
calculated by using Poisson regression with adjustment for age and sex.
Incidence rate ratios were also calculated to examine ethnic
differences in incidence for each pathological type of stroke with
adjustment for age and sex. As social class data are ill defined in
those aged under 35 or over 64, a further Poisson regression, adjusted for age, sex, and social class, was performed on cases in patients aged
35-64. Case fatality rates were calculated at 7, 28, 90, and 180 days
after stroke. Logistic regression with adjustment for age and sex was
used to compare ethnic groups.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The south London stroke register registered 612 patients with first stroke. Patients were identified by between one and five notification sources, with a median of three. The most common referral sources were hospital wards, death certificates, and hospital medical staff. One hundred patients (16.3%) were not admitted to hospital. Nine of these were identified after death.
Of the 612 patients registered, 289 were men; 489 were white, 102 were black, and 21 were classified "other." The mean (range; SD) age of all first strokes was 71.3 (12 to 99; 14.4) years; 73.6 (12 to 99; 13.2) years for white people, 61.4 (17 to 94;16.2) years for black people, and 66.9 (49 to 87; 12.6) years for "other" (P<0.0001). There were 136 non-manual, 368 manual, and 108 inactive patients.
Pathological diagnosis of stroke subtype was confirmed in 536 cases. The distribution of each subtype was cerebral infarction in 419; primary intracerebral haemorrhage in 79; and subarachnoid haemorrhage in 43; 71 were unclassified. Of the unclassified cases, 19 (27%) were community patients and 20 patients (one community, 19 hospital) died within 48 hours of onset of stroke.
The crude total incidence rate per 1000 population was 1.31 (95% confidence interval 1.20 to 1.41); 1.25 (1.15 to 1.35) standardised to the European and 0.82 (0.75 to 0.89) standardised to the world populations. Incidence rates (age adjusted to the standard European population) were higher in men than in women (table 1). The incidence rate ratio for men compared with women showed a higher rate in men (1.3; 1.1 to 1.5; P<0.003). Across all age groups incidence rates were higher in black compared with white populations except in those aged 45-54 years (table 2). The incidence rate ratio adjusted for age and sex in black compared with white patients was 2.21 (1.77 to 2.76; P<0.0001). The incidence rates increased with age in all ethnic groups, and age was a significant independent factor (P<0.0001) (tables 1 and 2).
|
Social class for those aged between 35 and 64 was a significant independent factor. The incidence rate ratio between patients in manual (99 cases) and non-manual classes (31 cases) was 2.11 (1.37 to 3.25; P<0.0001). Thirteen patients (9%) were classified as economically inactive. Within the 35-64 age group the incidence rate ratios between black and white groups before and after adjustment for social class were 1.71 (1.17 to 2.49; P=0.005) and 1.53 (1.04 to 2.23; P=0.029), respectively. In this age range ethnicity was significantly associated with incidence of stroke after adjustment for age, sex, and social class. Irrespective of ethnicity, age specific incidence rates for all subtypes of stroke increased with age. The incidence rates adjusted for age and sex for each subtype of stroke were higher in black people than white people (table 3). The incidence rate ratios for black:white people were 1.99 (1.50 to 2.63; P<0.001) for cerebral infarction; 3.28 (1.83 to 5.77, P<0.001) for primary intracerebral haemorrhage; and 2.36 (1.2 to 4.63, P=0.013) for subarachnoid haemorrhage. The age and sex adjusted case fatality rates at 7, 28, 90 and 180 days showed no significant difference between ethnic groups (table 4).
|
|
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Case ascertainment
The validity of any incidence study depends on complete and
accurate ascertainment of cases. Core criteria for stroke incidence
studies12 were incorporated by using standard definitions,
a prospective study design, an adequate and defined population, and
notification by multiple overlapping sources.
Population denominator data
The 1991 census data on the population denominator may not be
accurate; no data were obtained for 2.2% of the population and
underenumeration was highest in men aged 20-29 years.14 As
incidence rates for stroke in all ethnic groups are low in this age
group denominator underenumeration would probably not influence the
ethnic differences found. Population growth, mobility, and cross
boundary effects are difficult to estimate and may differ between
ethnic groups. These factors, for which we have not been able to
control, may influence observed incidence rates.
Stroke incidence
The total stroke incidence rate of 1.25 per 1000 population, age adjusted to the standard European population, was
lower than that reported over 10 years ago in the Oxfordshire community
stroke project (1981-6) (1.6 per 1000 white population).3 The estimates from the south London register are within the range of
rates reported in registers in Europe and New
Zealand.
1 15-17
Pathological stroke type
We have shown increased incidence rates for all pathological
subtypes of stroke in black people, with primary intracerebral
haemorrhage having the highest black:white incidence rate ratio.
Higher rates of haemorrhagic stroke in black people but of embolic
strokes and extracranial occlusive vascular disease in white people
have been reported in a number of hospital stroke series.19 In some hospital series ease of access to
healthcare facilities and use of diagnostic tests differ between black
and white patients, thereby introducing selection
bias.
6 19
In the register there was no significant
difference in incidence rates of unclassified stroke between ethnic groups.
Social class
Ethnic differences in social class have been suggested as
contributory to the excess mortality from stroke in black people
compared with white people in the United States.20 Adjustment for social class has not been performed in any published study on stroke incidence including black subjects. In the register adjustment of incidence rates for social class was possible only within the limited age range (35-64) for which census data on social
class were available. There are problems with registrar general's
coding of social class, particularly in the exclusion of housewives,
carers, students, and the unemployed, but it was the only measure
available. Although the reduced sample size of cases of stroke in those
aged 35-64 meant that the confidence intervals of black:white incidence
rate ratios after adjustment for social class were wide, ethnicity was
still significantly associated with stroke incidence.
Risk factors
The excess incidence of stroke among black people compared with
white people was not explained by social class, age, or sex.
Differences in genetic, physiological, and behavioural risk factors
that may account for ethnic differences in stroke incidence require
further elucidation. A higher prevalence of hypertension and diabetes
among black people compared with white people has been
reported,23 and a recent study suggests ethnic differences
in genetic predisposition to hypertension.24 Ethnic
differences in these risk factors alone, however, do not account for
the increased risk of stroke among black people.
5 7
Case fatality
Case fatality at 28 days was 26%, which is comparable with
rates reported of 18% and 33% in two Italian centres.1 The 28 day case fatality rates for patients aged 35-64 years reported in MONICA were 15% to 49% in men and 18% to 57% in women; our rate
of 17% (for the same age group) is towards the lower end of the ranges
and comparable with rates reported in Nordic populations.1 Some studies have suggested ethnic differences in survival from stroke.4 In the register there were no significant
differences in case fatality between black and white people up to 6 months after stroke.
Conclusion
We have shown important ethnic differences in the incidence of
stroke. Investigation of ethnic differences in risk factors for stroke
is needed to account for the excess incidence among black people to
plan effective prevention and management of stroke in multi-ethnic
communities.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank fieldworkers Elizabeth Richardson, Tania Collela, and Francis Bunn for their help with data collection and all general practitioners and general practice and hospital staff in the area who have supported the study.
Contributors: JS initiated and coordinated the formulation of the primary hypothesis, discussed core ideas, designed the protocol, particularly the documentation of clinical data, and participated in data collection, analysis, and writing of the paper. RD participated in the documentation, analysis, and interpretation of the data, quality control, and writing of the paper. RH initiated research, discussed core ideas, participated in protocol design, data documentation, and analysis, and contributed to the paper. AR initiated research, discussed core ideas, participated in protocol design, collection, documentation, and analysis of data, and contributed to the paper. CW, the principal instigator of the south London stroke register research project, initiated research, participated in the design and execution of the study, discussed core ideas, participated in the documentation, analysis, and interpretation of the data, and edited the paper. CW is the guarantor.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Funding: Northern and Yorkshire Region Research and Development Programme. Glaxo Wellcome plc contributed a research and development grant.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
(Accepted 10 February 1999)
Read all Rapid Responses
Israeli students are refusing to perform intimate examinations on anaesthetised women without their informed consent.