Jump to: Page Content, Site Navigation, Site Search,
You are seeing this message because your web browser does not support basic web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing and what you can do to make your experience on this site better.
Nadia Badawi a TVW Telethon Institute for Child Health Research, PO
Box 855, West Perth, Western Australia 6872, Australia, b Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Hornsby Ku-ring-Gai
Hospital, Hornsby, New South Wales 2077, Australia, c Department of Paediatrics,
University of Western Australia, Western Australia 6907, Australia, d Princess Margaret Hospital for Children, Subiaco, WA 6008, Australia
Correspondence to: Dr N
Badawi, Department of Neonatology, New Children's Hospital, Royal
Alexandra Hospital for Children, PO Box 3515, Parramatta, New South
Wales, New South Wales 2124, Australia nadiaB{at}nch.edu.au
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective:
To ascertain antepartum predictors of
newborn encephalopathy in term infants.
Design:
Population based, unmatched case-control
study.
Setting:
Metropolitan area of Western Australia, June 1993 to September 1995.
Subjects:
All 164 term infants with moderate or severe newborn encephalopathy; 400 randomly selected controls.
Main outcome measures:
Adjusted odds ratio estimates.
Results:
The birth prevalence of moderate or severe newborn encephalopathy was 3.8/1000 term live births. The neonatal fatality was 9.1%. The risk of newborn encephalopathy increased with
increasing maternal age and decreased with increasing parity. There was
an increased risk associated with having a mother who was unemployed
(odds ratio 3.60), an unskilled manual worker (3.84), or a housewife
(2.48). Other risk factors from before conception were not having
private health insurance (3.46), a family history of seizures (2.55), a
family history of neurological disease (2.73), and infertility
treatment (4.43). Risk factors during pregnancy were maternal thyroid
disease (9.7), severe pre-eclampsia (6.30), moderate or severe bleeding
(3.57), a clinically diagnosed viral illness (2.97), not having drunk
alcohol (2.91); and placenta described at delivery as abnormal (2.07).
Factors related to the baby were birth weight adjusted for gestational
age between the third and ninth centile (4.37) or below the third
centile (38.23). The risk relation with gestational age was J shaped
with 38 and 39 weeks having the lowest risk.
Conclusions:
The causes of newborn encephalopathy are
heterogeneous and many of the causal pathways start before birth.
|
Key messages
|
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Newborn encephalopathy is an important clinical problem associated with considerable morbidity and mortality and is central in the assignment of blame in obstetric litigation. Birth prevalence ranges from 1.8 to 7.7 per 1000 term live births.1-7 Few studies have been population based, most have focused largely on the intrapartum period, most have been small, and many lacked adequate controls.2-6
Our pilot study identified new possible associations
such as, a family
history of seizures, vaginal bleeding in pregnancy, maternal thyroxine
treatment, and maternal pyrexia during labour.7 The aim of
this study was to investigate the role of characteristics before
conception and antepartum and intrapartum factors in the aetiology of
encephalopathy in the newborn and specifically the hypotheses from the
pilot study. We report here on characteristics before conception and
antepartum.
| |
Subjects and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Between June 1993 and September 1995 we conducted a case-control
study of term infants with newborn encephalopathy born in metropolitan
Perth, Western Australia (population 1.2 million). All cases of
moderate and severe newborn encephalopathy are referred to one of the
two tertiary neonatal units in Perth.7 Cases included in
this study were those term babies (
37 weeks) who, during the first
week of life, fulfilled the criteria shown in the box. Infants with
Down's syndrome or open neural tube defects were excluded. This
definition of newborn encephalopathy differs from that used by many
others in that it is broader and does not assume an intrapartum
aetiology.2-6 Deaths in the first week of life were
reviewed to ensure that no baby who fulfilled the entrance criteria
died before transfer.
|
Inclusion criteria for cases with moderate or severe newborn
encephalopathy
|
The severity of newborn encephalopathy was graded as moderate or severe according to criteria modified from Sarnat and Sarnat.8 Infants with severe encephalopathy were those who fulfilled one or more of the criteria listed in the box; the remainder were defined as moderate.
|
Criteria for severe encephalopathy
|
Controls were randomly selected from the population of term births
delivered in metropolitan Perth during the same period; 412 were
selected. With 150 to 180 cases the study had
90% power to detect a
relative risk of 2.5 or more for exposures with a prevalence of between
10% and 85% in the controls.
A questionnaire completed by the mothers collected sociodemographic and lifestyle information together with a medical and family history. Medical details were extracted from medical records. The infants with encephalopathy were examined daily (by NB) and the first 200 control infants were examined at recruitment (by NB).
Statistical analysis
Analyses were carried out with unconditional logistic regression.
A model containing
variables from before conception and the antepartum period was
constructed as follows. Explanatory variables were included if there
was strong pre-existing evidence that they were causally related to
newborn encephalopathy or cerebral palsy or if their inclusion covered
a principal hypothesis. Other potential confounding variables were then
entered altogether as additional terms in the core model. The
additional terms were removed in ascending order of the likelihood
ratio test (twice the change in the log likelihood) and all terms which
did not represent a significant (P<0.05) component of the model were
removed. Non-linearity in the continuous variables and interactions
were tested for.
Intrapartum
The aetiology of newborn encephalopathy
probably involves numerous determinants acting along complex causal
sequences. If one is interested in whether factor C causes disease D
and, in truth, A causes B causes C causes D, an apparently
"complete" logistic regression analysis which mutually adjusts for
the effects of A, B, and C by including all three as covariates may be
seriously misleading. The strength of the true association between C
and D is likely to be underestimated, and if C is "measured" with more error or with greater misclassification than either A or B,
disease D may appear independent of C. We therefore adopted a cautious
approach to analysis. We estimated bivariate associations between
intrapartum variables and the binary variable of newborn encephalopathy
(yes/no) with unconditional logistic regression. Each model was
restricted to the covariate of interest. This analysis was extended by
creating a core model containing all antepartum variables of importance
(see table 2). The intrapartum exposures of interest were added to (and
removed from) this core model one at a time. An association which is
present in both the unadjusted and adjusted analyses
will be misleading only if it has been confounded by antepartum
variables not included in the core model or by intrapartum determinants
arising spontaneously or as a direct consequence of unmodelled
antepartum exposures. For unmodelled antepartum or intrapartum
determinants to distort our inferences seriously their effect would not
only have to be substantial but their distribution at a population
level would have to be correlated with a covariate of interest. We
would therefore argue that any covariate which exhibits an association
in both the adjusted and unadjusted analyses is worth considering as a
putative cause of newborn encephalopathy. Furthermore, an intrapartum
exposure which exhibits an important association with newborn
encephalopathy in either the adjusted or
the unadjusted analysis is worthy of further investigation with
independent data. The findings of the intrapartum analysis are reported
in the accompanying paper.9
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In total we enrolled 164 infants with encephalopathy as cases and 400 infants as controls, a response of 100% and 97%, respectively. The birth prevalence of moderate or severe newborn encephalopathy was 3.80 per 1000 term live births (95% confidence interval 3.24 to 4.43). Fifteen case infants and no control infants died in the neonatal period, giving a neonatal case fatality of 9.1% (5.2% to 14.6%). Table 1 gives the observed distribution of the entry criteria for the affected infants, two thirds of whom had moderate encephalopathy and a third had severe encephalopathy.
|
Factors before conception
Risk factors from before conception and antepartum risk factors
for newborn encephalopathy are shown in table
2.
|
The adjusted relative risk of
newborn encephalopathy increased significantly with increasing maternal
age. Rather than risk increasing with parity, there was a
non-significant decrease in risk of 17% for each delivery after the
first (odds ratio 0.83; 95% confidence interval 0.64 to 1.06). Infants
born to professional women, trades persons, or clerks were at least
risk with other forms of employment and unemployment being associated
with an increased relative risk. Interestingly, paternal employment
status had no additional effect. Women without private health insurance were at a greater risk than those with such insurance.
Medical conditions
A family history of recurrent
non-febrile seizures or other neurological disorders, defined as any
mention of these conditions in up to second degree relatives of the
child, were associated with over a 2.5-fold increase in relative risk. Infertility treatment was associated with over a fourfold increased risk. Essential hypertension was associated with a non-significant increased risk.
Antepartum factors
Maternal conditions
Women with thyroid disease were over
nine times more likely to have a baby with newborn encephalopathy than those without. Severe pre-eclampsia, moderate or severe vaginal bleeding in pregnancy, and a documented medical attendance for a
presumed viral infection were all associated with an increased risk.
While nearly all women reported drinking very little or no alcohol
during pregnancy consumption of some alcohol was apparently protective.
Cigarette smoking showed no effect.
The relative risk in relation to
gestational age showed a clear J shaped curve ranging from 2.35 at 37 weeks' to 13.2 at 42 weeks' gestation. Growth
restriction11 was also strongly associated with the risk
of newborn encephalopathy. Boys were at a 50% increased risk compared
with girls, which was almost significant. The presence of a placenta
reported as abnormal at birth was associated with a doubling in risk.
Six affected infants and one control infant had late or no antenatal
care. There was a non-significant increase in risk for births at a
private hospital. There were too few twins to draw conclusions. Several
variables were not included as they were possibly along a causal
pathway or were outcome variables associated with newborn
encephalopathy. Inclusion of these variables in the adjusted analysis
would have potentially masked the effects of other variables that were
working in combination with them. These variables included birth
defects (found in 23.2% affected infants and 2.3% control infants)
and a reported abnormal antepartum cardiotocogram (found in 8.5% and 2.0%, respectively).
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Many previous studies of newborn encephalopathy have been restricted to babies who showed so called signs of hypoxia and ischaemia during labour. As the present study aimed to investigate a wider range of potential causes we chose a broader though widely accepted definition of newborn encephalopathy and investigated factors from before conception to postnatal events.
Intrauterine growth restriction, pre-eclampsia, and gestational
age
The association of newborn encephalopathy with restriction of
intrauterine growth was the strongest found in this analysis. Similar
associations have been described for cerebral palsy,
12 13
seizures in the newborn, and encephalopathy.
7 14
This
association shows the importance of the selection of our study
population by gestational age rather than birth weight. If "term"
had been defined by birth weight (for example,
2500 g) the
significance of growth restriction to encephalopathy may have been
underestimated.
Sociodemographic factors
We found a range of social and demographic factors that have not
previously been described as risk factors for newborn encephalopathy.
Contrary to expectations the risk with increasing maternal age does not
seem to be mediated through increasing parity. The strong
correlation between maternal age and parity, however, makes it
difficult to disentangle their individual effects, and these results
should therefore be interpreted with caution.
Other antepartum factors
A family history of seizures and of other neurological disorders
were confirmed as risk factors and have been described in studies of
cerebral palsy and neonatal seizures.20 These results
suggest that genetic or early developmental factors may influence the
risk of newborn encephalopathy.
such as hyperthermia,26 inflammatory mediators, or other pathophysiological
responses.27 Evidence from this and other studies suggests
that the placenta may be an important but currently ignored (and
commonly discarded) source of information.
Data from infants with birth defects and abnormal antepartum
cardiotocograms were deliberately excluded from the multiple logistic
regression analysis. While numbers were small the excess of abnormal
antepartum cardiotocograms in case infants suggests the presence of
antepartum compromise. Case infants had excess malformations and most
were not defects of the central nervous system, findings consistent
with results of other studies.
3 7 28
Birth defects occur
early in intrauterine life and may be markers of factors in early
pregnancy, which may also cause the encephalopathy. Alternatively a
birth defect may make the fetal brain vulnerable to other damaging
factors.
Our definition of encephalopathy was broad, the study was population
based, control data were collected, and the results suggest that the
causes of newborn encephalopathy are heterogeneous and that many of the
causal pathways resulting in newborn encephalopathy start before
birth.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank the babies and parents who participated in this study and the staff of the TVW Telethon Institute for Child Health Research, Princess Margaret Hospital for Children, King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women, and all the other maternity hospitals in Perth. We are also grateful to the panel of local obstetricians who developed the consensus criteria for elective caesarean section.
Contributors: NB designed the study, obtained a research training fellowship which funded the start of the project, was chief investigator on the subsequent research grant which funded its continuation, enrolled cases and half the controls and collected the data relating to these, coded the data, entered data into the file for analysis, carried out the analysis, and wrote the first draft of the paper. JJK assisted with the design of the study, particularly the control selection method, assisted with data coding and computerisation, and supervised the analysis and writing of the paper. JMK assisted with the obstetric elements of the design of the study, facilitated data collection, provided expert obstetric interpretation of the data, and contributed to the paper writing. LMA assisted with the supervision of the pilot study and the design of this study, contributed to the day to day running of the study, and assisted with data handling and interpretation. Sadly, her untimely death precluded her from contributing to the writing of the paper. FO enrolled and collected original data from half the controls and collected data from cases and controls for the data validation, and also edited the paper. PRB provided advice at every stage of the study, oversaw the analytical strategy, and provided editorial direction during writing. PJP assisted with the study design, helped enrol cases, and edited the paper. FJS had the original idea for the present study, assisted with the design, and contributed to the writing and editing of the paper. NB and JK are the guarantors.
Dr Alessandri died in August 1997
Funding: The Public Health Research and Development Committee of the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia (94/3368) and the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia (96/0560; 96/3209; 98/7062).
Competing interests: None declared.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
incidence and prediction of outcome in the Stockholm area.
Acta Paediatr
1983;
72:
321-325.(Accepted 28 August 1998)
Read all Rapid Responses