Jump to: Page Content, Site Navigation, Site Search,
You are seeing this message because your web browser does not support basic web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing and what you can do to make your experience on this site better.
Jean Paul Galmiche a Department of Gastroenterology and
Hepatology, Hotel-Dieu University Hospital, 44035 Nantes Cedex 01, France, b Gastrosurgical Unit, College of Medicine,
University of Nantes, France, c Institute of
Pharmacology, School of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Parma,
Italy
Correspondence to: Professor Galmiche Galmiche{at}easynet.fr
Gastro-oesophageal reflux disease is caused by retrograde
flow of gastric contents through an incompetent gastro-oesophageal
junction. The disease encompasses a broad spectrum of clinical
disorders from heartburn without oesophagitis to severe complications
such as strictures, deep ulcers, and intestinal metaplasia (Barrett's
oesophagus).1 The prevalence of heartburn, the most
typical symptom of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, is extremely
high,2 but most people with reflux do not seek medical
help for this condition and treat themselves with over the counter
preparations. Oesophagitis (defined by mucosal breaks) is less
frequent, occurring in less than half of patients undergoing endoscopy
for reflux symptoms. Symptoms and severity of oesophagitis are poorly
correlated. Although reflux may remain silent in patients with
Barrett's oesophagus, heartburn can severely affect the quality of
life of patients with negative endoscopy results. The natural course of
the disease also varies considerably.2 Patients with
gastro-oesophageal reflux disease seen by gastroenterologists usually
have a chronic condition with frequent relapses, whereas those who rely
on general practitioners' help usually have less severe disease,
consisting of intermittent attacks with prolonged periods of
remission.
Summary points
Most patients with dominant heartburn have no signs of
oesophagitis at endoscopy. However, chronic relapsing
gastro-oesophageal reflux disease can severely affect quality of life
In primary care many patients can be successfully treated by
intermittent courses of drugs on demand
Alginate-antacids and H2 receptor antagonists are useful in
patients with mild disease
Cisapride is as effective as H2 receptor antagonists in
short term treatment and can prevent relapse in mild oesophagitis
Proton pump inhibitors relieve symptoms and heal oesophagitis more
completely and faster than other drugs. They are effective throughout
the disease spectrum, and maintenance therapy prevents recurrences
The principles of laparoscopic and open antireflux surgery are the
same. In skilled hands, similarly good results have been reported up to
two years after both approaches
In young fit patients laparoscopic surgery may be a cost effective
alternative to a lifetime of drug treatment
Relief of symptoms and prevention of relapses are the primary aims of treatment for most patients. However, healing is also an important objective for those with moderate to severe oesophagitis or complications, or both. These goals can now be achieved, at least in part, for nearly all patients thanks to the recent development of effective drugs, especially proton pump inhibitors. The last decade has also seen the rapid development of laparoscopic surgery.
| |
Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Several reviews on the treatment of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease have been published recently,3-6 and this information has been supplemented by a Medline search covering 1995-7. We also used a database created during a recent workshop (Genval, Belgium, October 1997). From the 429 references available in this database we selected those reporting trials comparing proton pump inhibitors with other drugs, treatment of patients with negative endoscopy results, meta-analysis of trials, evaluation of laparoscopic surgery, and cost-utility analysis.
| |
Medical treatment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Lifestyle and dietary recommendations
Lifestyle and dietary recommendations, together with antacids,
have long been the mainstay of treatment. The recommendations were
based on physiological studies showing reduced acid exposure, at least
in some instances.7 In fact, the effectiveness of these
measures has not been established by well controlled trials. The role
of obesity in the pathogenesis of the disease, as well as the benefit
of weight loss, has not been proved. No benefit has been shown from
giving up smoking or discontinuing the use of drugs such as
bronchodilators in asthmatic subjects.8 Although it is
wise to stop smoking or reduce the consumption of fatty foods for other
reasons, not much benefit can be expected in gastro-oesophageal reflux
disease. Raising the head of the bed9 and avoiding lying
down within three hours after dinner may be useful, especially for
patients with severe regurgitation or nocturnal symptoms. When specific
foods or drugs are poorly tolerated by a patient it is logical to avoid
or withdraw them.
Antacids and alginate-antacids
Though several placebo controlled trials have failed to establish
their efficacy,10 epidemiological studies have shown that
antacids and alginate-antacids are often used successfully as self
treatment by people with reflux who do not seek medical
help.11 The combination of antacids with alginate is more
effective than antacids alone. In a large open trial of
alginate-antacid taken on demand, most patients with mild oesophagitis
remained in good clinical remission during the six months of the
study.12
Prokinetics
Since gastro-oesophageal reflux disease is primarily a motility
disorder the use of prokinetics has an excellent rationale. Bethanechol
and the anti-dopaminergics metoclopramide and domperidone have proved
slightly effective. However, their marginal benefit is often offset by
poor tolerance. They have now been superseded by cisapride, a
5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT4) receptor agonist which enhances
oesophageal peristaltic waves, increases oesophageal sphincter tone,
and accelerates gastric emptying.13
Sucralfate
Sucralfate is a polysulphate sucrose salt which is supposed to
protect oesophageal mucosa. Conflicting results have been reported in
trials in patients with gastro-oesophageal reflux disease. It has
little, if any, role in modern antireflux therapy.
Acid suppression
H2 receptor antagonists
H2 receptor antagonists (cimetidine, ranitidine,
famotidine, and nizatidine) were the first acid suppressors shown to be
effective in short term treatment of gastro-oesophageal reflux
disease.15 However, the benefit was less than initially
expected, especially in severe oesophagitis, for which the average gain
in healing has not exceeded 10%. Moreover, maintenance therapy with
standard doses of H2 blockers (for example, 150 mg
ranitidine twice daily) does not prevent relapses.16 There
are many reasons for the limited efficacy of these drugs, including
tolerance (reduced efficacy over time17) and incomplete
inhibition of postprandial gastric acid secretion.
15 16
Increasing the dose18 and dosing frequency improves the
efficacy, although it probably reduces compliance and increases cost.
Combined treatment with prokinetics is less effective and more
expensive and inconvenient than monotherapy with proton pump
inhibitors.19
Nevertheless, because of their excellent safety profile, H2 blockers are useful in some patients with mild gastro-oesophageal reflux disease when they can be taken as needed. Their availability as over the counter drugs is currently being evaluated,20 and they may eventually partly replace antacids. Special formulations (such as a wafer or effervescent tablets) may be more appropriate for this use. 21 22
Proton pump inhibitors
Proton pump inhibitors act at the final step in acid secretion by
blocking H+/K+ ATPase
irreversibly in gastric parietal cells. Omeprazole (20 and 40 mg
daily) was the first proton pump inhibitor extensively evaluated in
reflux oesophagitis, and lansoprazole (30 mg daily) and pantoprazole
(40 mg daily) have also been used. A recent meta-analysis of 43 therapeutic trials conducted in patients with moderate or severe
oesophagitis confirmed the advantage of proton pump inhibitors over
H2 blockers.23 The proportion of patients
successfully treated was nearly doubled with proton pump inhibitors,
and the rapidity of healing and symptom relief were about twice that
with H2 blockers. Their superiority is also clear in mild
oesophagitis and patients with negative endoscopy
results.24 Omeprazole (20 mg or 10 mg daily) has also
been shown to be better than cisapride.25 Quality of life
is restored to normal with omeprazole.25
The efficacy of proton pump inhibitors is maintained with time,19 and a meta-analysis of long term trials26 has confirmed that continuous maintenance therapy with omeprazole (20 mg or 10 mg daily) achieves significantly better results than maintenance with 150 mg ranitidine twice daily (figure). Interestingly, the relief of heartburn during omeprazole treatment is highly predictive of healing.26 Therefore, no further endoscopic investigation is required in asymptomatic patients taking proton pump inhibitors (unless initial endoscopy shows severe oesophagitis or complications). Many patients with mild disease do not require continuous maintenance therapy. Recent studies have shown excellent results for symptom relief and quality of life with omeprazole on demand (20 or 10 mg daily).27
|
The main issue concerning prolonged use of proton pump inhibitors in gastro-oesophageal reflux disease is safety. Although proton pump inhibitors are well tolerated, some concern exists about the risk of malignancy after 10 or 20 years of potent acid suppression. Proliferation of endocrine cells has been reported in relation to hypergastrinaemia as a result of hypochlorhydria, which is non-specific for proton pump inhibitors. In fact, the risk of endocrine neoplasia seems extremely low and of no clinical relevance for most patients, whereas that of developing atrophic gastritis (a premalignant condition for adenocarcinoma) is more important and deserves more complete evaluation.28 Since the risk of atrophic gastritis seems related to Helicobacter pylori infection some authors recommend eradication of this bacterium before embarking on long term acid suppression. However, the benefit of this strategy is not yet adequately demonstrated.
| |
Antireflux surgery |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The principle of every surgical procedure, whether open surgery or laparoscopic repair, is to restore an anti-reflux barrier by recreating a sufficient pressure gradient in the distal oesophagus and to close the hiatal hernia.
Open surgery
Excellent results can be obtained with different procedures such
as total fundic wrap (Nissen operation) or partial fundoplications
(such as Toupet's procedure). The preferred and probably most
efficient anti-reflux procedure is the "floppy" Nissen
fundoplication, which has been developed to avoid the side effects of
the original fundic wrap (dysphagia, gas bloat syndrome, and inability
to burp). Success rates of up to 90% can be achieved, with almost no
mortality and morbidity. After 10 to 20 years some deterioration can
occur, usually associated with wrap disruption.29
Laparoscopy
The technical aspects of laparoscopic fundoplication have been
extensively described. Routine use of a postoperative nasogastric tube
is unnecessary, and a soft diet is introduced on the first
postoperative day. Patients are generally discharged by the first or
second postoperative day and are usually able to return to work within
two weeks after their operation. However, laparoscopic Nissen
fundoplication is a demanding technique and requires different skills
from other procedures such as cholecystectomy. The learning curve is a
determining factor in the rate of the postoperative
complications.30 Severe complications are noted in 0.5-2%
of cases.31 Oesophageal perforation, a potentially lethal
complication, occurs in 0.5-1.5% of all cases and is related to the
surgeon's expertise.
| |
How to manage gastro-oesophageal reflux disease |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Management of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease depends mainly on age (and concomitant illness), severity of symptoms and oesophagitis, and outcome of initial treatment.
Initial treatment
In patients with mild or moderate heartburn the first approach is
usually to combine lifestyle modifications with alginate-antacids. This
is adequate to relieve symptoms in a large proportion of patients
presenting to general practice. However, in young adults presenting
with no alarming symptoms (such as dysphagia, anaemia, or weight loss)
there is now good consensus on use of acid suppressors without
endoscopic assessment. Short courses of H2 blockers or
proton pump inhibitors can be given without risk of missing a life
threatening condition. In patients over 45 years of age and those with
alarming symptoms, endoscopy is mandatory to exclude malignancy and
assess the severity of oesophagitis, which is an important predictor of
therapeutic response. When endoscopy gives normal results in a patient
with atypical symptoms the diagnosis of gastro-oesophageal reflux
disease should be established before any treatment is recommended.
Twenty four hour pH monitoring with symptom analysis may be useful,
although a trial of proton pump inhibitors may be a more attractive and
cheaper option. Rapid relief of symptoms seems to have good sensitivity
for diagnosis of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, but the results
need to be confirmed in further prospective studies.35
Long term management
In most cases relief of symptoms and healing of oesophagitis
can be achieved after adequate initial treatment. The key issue is long
term control of the disease. Intermittent, on demand drug treatment is
suitable for patients with mild or moderate symptoms and infrequent
relapses. However, if symptoms recur shortly after treatment has been
stopped, maintenance treatment (usually with proton pump inhibitors) is
highly effective and certainly the best option for older patients or
those at risk from surgery. Surgery may be preferable to a lifetime of
drug treatment for a young fit patient with frequent
relapses.41 Laparoscopic surgery is now the preferred
approach for many patients and surgeons. However, even the economic
benefit of this strategy over proton pump inhibitors remains to be
established and will probably require more than 10 years of follow up
evaluation.42 Therefore, caution is required before the
indications for laparoscopic surgery are extended. Ideally, this
procedure should be performed only in specialist centres with expertise
in managing gastro-oesophageal reflux disease.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
a prospective study of alginate as self-care treatment for 6 months.
Aliment Pharmacol Ther
1993;
7:
385-392[Medline].
a comparison of their pharmacokinetics and pharmacology.
Aliment Pharmacol Ther
1996;
10:
913-918[Medline].
cancer risk, biology and therapeutic management.
Aliment Pharmacol Ther
1993;
7:
339-345[Medline].
Read all Rapid Responses