Published 21 July 2009, doi:10.1136/bmj.b2680
Cite this as: BMJ 2009;339:b2680

Research

How citation distortions create unfounded authority: analysis of a citation network

¹ Children’s Hospital Informatics Program and Department of Neurology, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, 75 Francis Street, Boston, MA 02115, USA

Objective To understand belief in a specific scientific claim by studying the pattern of citations among papers stating it.

Design A complete citation network was constructed from all PubMed indexed English literature papers addressing the belief that β amyloid, a protein accumulated in the brain in Alzheimer’s disease, is produced by and injures skeletal muscle of patients with inclusion body myositis. Social network theory and graph theory were used to analyse this network.

Main outcome measures Citation bias, amplification, and invention, and their effects on determining authority.

Results The network contained 242 papers and 675 citations addressing the belief, with 220 553 citation paths supporting it. Unfounded authority was established by citation bias against papers that refuted or weakened the belief; amplification, the marked expansion of the belief system by papers presenting no data addressing it; and forms of invention such as the conversion of hypothesis into fact through citation alone. Extension of this network into text within grants funded by the National Institutes of Health and obtained through the Freedom of Information Act showed the same phenomena present and sometimes used to justify requests for funding.

Conclusion Citation is both an impartial scholarly method and a powerful form of social communication. Through distortions in its social use that include bias, amplification, and invention, citation can be used to generate information cascades resulting in unfounded authority of claims. Construction and analysis of a claim specific citation network may clarify the nature of a published belief system and expose distorted methods of social citation.

© Greenberg 2009
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

CiteULike    Complore    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    StumbleUpon    Technorati    What's this?

Relevant Articles

Inappropriate referencing in research

Dean Fergusson
BMJ 2009 339: b2049. [Extract] [Full Text]

Polymyositis, invasion of non-necrotic muscle fibres, and the art of repetition

Gerald J D Hengstman and Baziel G M van Engelen
BMJ 2004 329: 1464-1467. [Full Text] [PDF]

Related external webpages:

Listen to an interview with Steven Greenberg in the BMJ podcast

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Will, E. J. (2009). Caveats for Scientific Publication in the Modern Marketplace. CJASN 4: 1693-1695 [Full text]  

Rapid Responses:

Read all Rapid Responses

Unfortunately results applicable to virtually all fields

Terence Oliva
bmj.com, 31 Jul 2009 [Full text]

The consequences of inadequate literature investigation.

Les O. Simpson
bmj.com, 2 Aug 2009 [Full text]

Breastfeeding physiology: another casualty of inappropriate citation.

Carol Anne Walshaw
bmj.com, 3 Aug 2009 [Full text]

What I tell you three times is true

Neville W Goodman
bmj.com, 6 Aug 2009 [Full text]

Sophisticated Methods of Knowledge Construction in Medicine

Carmel M Martin
bmj.com, 7 Aug 2009 [Full text]

Reduction of bias begins with search strategy

Amanda R. Ross-White
bmj.com, 10 Aug 2009 [Full text]

But everybody knows....

Roger K.A. Allen
bmj.com, 11 Aug 2009 [Full text]

Chinese Whispers and there is a crack in everything. It's how the light gets in.

Roger K.A. Allen
bmj.com, 14 Aug 2009 [Full text]

Less Distortion in Meta-Analyses than in Narrative Reviews?

Will G Hopkins
bmj.com, 17 Aug 2009 [Full text]

Time to Wake Up

Arif S Hashmi
bmj.com, 20 Aug 2009 [Full text]

referencing systems contribute to the problem

Melissa Raven
bmj.com, 27 Aug 2009 [Full text]

Don't Miss the Mark

Gary T. Buckholz
bmj.com, 3 Sep 2009 [Full text]

Online poll

Find out more on doc2doc >>