Published 11 June 2009, doi:10.1136/bmj.b2060
Cite this as: BMJ 2009;338:b2060

Research

Outcomes for births booked under an independent midwife and births in NHS maternity units: matched comparison study

¹ School of Nursing and Midwifery, University of Dundee, Dundee DD1 4HJ, ² Community Health Sciences, University of Dundee, Dundee DD2 4BF

Objective To compare clinical outcomes between women employing an independent midwife and comparable pregnant women using NHS services.

Design Anonymised matched cohort analysis. Cases from the database of the Independent Midwives’ Association (IMA) matched up to 1:5 with Scottish National Health Service (NHS) records for age, parity, year of birth, and socioeconomic status. Multivariable logistic regression models used to explore the relation between explanatory variables and outcomes; analyses controlled for potential confounding factors and adjusted for stratification.

Setting UK databases 2002-5.

Participants Anonymised records for 8676 women (7214 NHS; 1462 IMA).

Main outcome measures Unassisted vertex delivery, live birth, perinatal death, onset of labour, gestation, use of analgesia, duration of labour, perineal trauma, Apgar scores, admission to neonatal intensive care, infant feeding.

Results IMA cohort mothers were significantly more likely to achieve an unassisted vertex delivery than NHS cohort mothers (77.9% (1139) v 54.3% (3918); odds ratio 3.49, 95% confidence interval 2.99 to 4.07) but also significantly more likely to experience a stillbirth or a neonatal death (1.7% (25) v 0.6% (46); 5.91, 3.27 to 10.7). All odds ratios are adjusted for confounding factors. Exclusion of "high risk" cases from both cohorts showed a non-significant difference (0.5% (5) v 0.3% (18); 2.73, 0.87 to 8.55); the "low risk" IMA perinatal mortality rate is comparable with other studies of low risk births. Women in the IMA cohort had a higher incidence of pre-existing medical conditions (1.5% (22) v 1.0% (72) in the NHS cohort) and previous obstetric complications (21.0% (307) v 17.8% (1284)). The incidence of twin pregnancy was also higher (3.4% (50) v 3.1% (224)). In the IMA cohort, 66.0% of mothers (965/1462) had home births, compared with only 0.4% of NHS cohort mothers (27/7214). Spontaneous onset of labour was more common in the IMA group (96.6% (1405) v 74.5% (5365); 10.43, 7.74 to 14.0), and fewer mothers used pharmacological analgesia (40.2% (588) v 60.6% (4370); 0.42, 0.38 to 0.47). Mothers in the IMA cohort were much more likely to breast feed (88.0% (1286) v 64.0% (2759); 3.46, 2.84 to 4.20). Prematurity (4.3% (63) v 6.9% (498); 0.49, 0.35 to 0.69), low birth weight (4.0% (60) v 7.1%) (523); 0.93, 0.62 to 1.38), and rate of admission to neonatal intensive care (4.4% (65) v 9.3% (667); 0.43, 0.32 to 0.59) were all higher in the NHS dataset.

Conclusions Healthcare policy tries to direct patient choice towards clinically appropriate and practicable options; nevertheless, pregnant women are free to make decisions about birth preferences, including place of delivery and staff in attendance. While clinical outcomes across a range of variables were significantly better for women accessing an independent midwife, the significantly higher perinatal mortality rates for high risk cases in this group indicate an urgent need for a review of these cases. The significantly higher prematurity and admission rates to intensive care in the NHS cohort also indicate an urgent need for review.

© Symon et al 2009
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

CiteULike    Complore    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    StumbleUpon    Technorati    What's this?

Relevant Articles

Independent midwifery care versus NHS care in the UK

Allison Shorten and Brett Shorten
BMJ 2009 338: b2210. [Extract] [Full Text]

Outcomes of planned home births with certified professional midwives: large prospective study in North America

Kenneth C Johnson and Betty-Anne Daviss
BMJ 2005 330: 1416. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

The future of clinical negligence litigation?

Brian Capstick
BMJ 2004 328: 457-459. [Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]

Commons committee calls for more choice over home births

Upasana Tayal
BMJ 2003 327: 249. [Extract] [Full Text]

Rates for obstetric intervention among private and public patients in Australia: population based descriptive study

Christine L Roberts, Sally Tracy, and Brian Peat
BMJ 2000 321: 137-141. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

ABC of labour care: Place of birth

Luke Zander and Geoffrey Chamberlain
BMJ 1999 318: 721-723. [Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]

Perinatal death associated with planned home birth in Australia: population based study

Hilda Bastian, Marc J N C Keirse, and Paul A L Lancaster
BMJ 1998 317: 384-388. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

Compensation for medical accidents.

B Capstick, P Edwards, and D Mason
BMJ 1991 302: 230-232. [PDF]

Home births in England and Wales, 1979: perinatal mortality according to intended place of delivery.

R Campbell, I M Davies, A Macfarlane, and V Beral
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 1984 289: 721-724. [Abstract] [PDF]

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Shorten, A., Shorten, B. (2009). Independent midwifery care versus NHS care in the UK. BMJ 338: b2210-b2210 [Full text]  

Rapid Responses:

Read all Rapid Responses

Independent Midwives UK Response

Brenda van der Kooy
bmj.com, 11 Jun 2009 [Full text]

small things

helene a brandon
bmj.com, 20 Jun 2009 [Full text]

Birth Outcomes and Task Shifting in Low-Income Countries: A Call for Evidence?

Fekadu Aga
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2009 [Full text]

Why do women book with independent midwives?

Gill Gyte, et al.
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2009 [Full text]

Independent midwife births promotes exclusive breastfeeding

NorahM. Nyanga
bmj.com, 28 Jun 2009 [Full text]

Perinatal Death or Perineal Trauma?

Selin Hassan, et al.
bmj.com, 24 Jul 2009 [Full text]

Re: Editorial; and Perinatal Death or Perineal Trauma?

Andrew G Symon, et al.
bmj.com, 30 Jul 2009 [Full text]

Re: Perinatal Death or Perineal Trauma?

sarah golden
bmj.com, 10 Oct 2009 [Full text]

Online poll

Find out more on doc2doc >>