BMJ  2006;332:571-574 (11 March), doi:10.1136/bmj.38753.375324.7C (published 2 March 2006)

Research

Effectiveness of hip protectors for preventing hip fractures in elderly people: systematic review

¹ Orthopaedic Department, Peterborough and Stamford Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Peterborough District Hospital, Peterborough PE3 6DA, ² Hull York Medical School, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7RX, ³ Department of Health Sciences, University of York, Heslington, York YO10 5DD

Abstract

Objectives To present the updated results of systematic review of the current evidence for the effectiveness of hip protectors from reports of completed randomised trials, and to explore the evolution of that evidence.

Design Systematic review with meta-analysis.

Data sources Cochrane Bone, Joint, and Muscle Trauma Group trials register (January 2005), Cochrane central register of controlled trials (Cochrane Library Issue 1, 2005), Medline (1966 to January 2005), Embase (1988 to January 2005), and CINAHL (1982 to December 2004). Other databases and reference lists of relevant articles were searched and some trialists were contacted.

Review methods Randomised or quasirandomised controlled trials reporting the incidence of hip fractures, pelvic fractures, and other fractures in elderly people offered hip protectors compared with a control group that was not.

Results Outcomes for fracture were available from 14 randomised and quasirandomised trials. Pooling of data from 11 trials carried out in nursing or residential care settings, including six cluster randomised studies, showed evidence of a marginally statistically significant reduction in incidence of hip fracture (relative risk 0.77, 95% confidence interval 0.62 to 0.97). Pooling of data from three individually randomised trials of 5135 community dwelling participants showed no reduction in hip fracture incidence with provision of hip protectors (1.16, 0.85 to 1.59). No evidence was found of any significant effect of hip protectors on incidence of pelvic or other fractures. No important adverse effects of hip protectors were reported, but compliance, particularly in the long term, was poor.

Conclusions On the basis of early reports of randomised trials, hip protectors were advocated. Accumulating evidence indicates that hip protectors are an ineffective intervention for those living at home and that their effectiveness in an institutional setting is uncertain.

CiteULike    Complore    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    What's this?

Relevant Articles

Shifting the focus in fracture prevention from osteoporosis to falls

Teppo L N Järvinen, Harri Sievänen, Karim M Khan, Ari Heinonen, and Pekka Kannus
BMJ 2008 336: 124-126. [Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]

Hip fracture

Martyn Parker and Antony Johansen
BMJ 2006 333: 27-30. [Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]

Effectiveness of hip protectors: Wider picture is important

Kenneth Nesbitt
BMJ 2006 332: 729. [Extract] [Full Text]

Effectiveness of hip protectors: It's more the effectiveness of compliance strategies

Peter D O'Halloran
BMJ 2006 332: 729. [Extract] [Full Text]

Hip protectors may not be effective
BMJ 2006 332: 0. [Full Text]

Hip protectors to prevent femoral fracture

Sophia E de Rooij
BMJ 2006 332: 559-560. [Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]

Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses

Julian P T Higgins, Simon G Thompson, Jonathan J Deeks, and Douglas G Altman
BMJ 2003 327: 557-560. [Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Cox, H., Puffer, S., Morton, V., Cooper, C., Hodson, J., Masud, T., Oliver, D., Preedy, D., Selby, P., Stone, M., Sutcliffe, A., Torgerson, D. (2008). Educating nursing home staff on fracture prevention: a cluster randomised trial. Age Ageing 37: 167-172 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Hayes, N., Close, J. C. T., Witchard, S., Awan-Bux, R., Anthony, L., Cawley, S., Jackson, S. H. D. (2008). What predicts compliance rates with hip protectors in older hospital in-patients?. Age Ageing 37: 225-228 [Full text]  
• MacLaughlin, E. J., Raehl, C. L. (2008). ASHP Therapeutic Position Statement on the Prevention and Treatment of Osteoporosis in Adults. Am J Health Syst Pharm 65: 343-357 [Full text]  
• Cryer, C, Knox, A, Stevenson, E (2008). Factors associated with hip protector adherence among older people in residential care. Inj. Prev. 14: 24-29 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Jarvinen, T. L N, Sievanen, H., Khan, K. M, Heinonen, A., Kannus, P. (2008). Shifting the focus in fracture prevention from osteoporosis to falls. BMJ 336: 124-126 [Full text]  
• Russell, J., Greenhalgh, T., Byrne, E., McDonnell, J. (2008). Recognizing rhetoric in health care policy analysis. J Health Serv Res Policy 13: 40-46 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Kiel, D. P., Magaziner, J., Zimmerman, S., Ball, L., Barton, B. A., Brown, K. M., Stone, J. P., Dewkett, D., Birge, S. J. (2007). Efficacy of a Hip Protector to Prevent Hip Fracture in Nursing Home Residents: The HIP PRO Randomized Controlled Trial. JAMA 298: 413-422 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Kannus, P., Parkkari, J. (2007). Hip Protectors for Preventing Hip Fracture. JAMA 298: 454-455 [Full text]  
• Finkelstein, E., Prabhu, M., Chen, H. (2007). Increased Prevalence of Falls Among Elderly Individuals With Mental Health and Substance Abuse Conditions. AJGP 15: 611-619 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Terzidis, A., Koutroumpa, A., Skalkidis, I., Matzavakis, I., Malliori, M., Frangakis, C. E, DiScala, C., Petridou, E. T. (2007). Water safety: age-specific changes in knowledge and attitudes following a school-based intervention. Inj. Prev. 13: 120-124 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Cole, P. A., Bhandari, M. (2006). What's New in Orthopaedic Trauma. JBJS 88: 2545-2561 [Full text]  
• (2006). Other articles noted. Evid. Based Med. 11: 127-128 [Full text]  
• Parker, M., Johansen, A. (2006). Hip fracture.. BMJ 333: 27-30 [Full text]  
• Kaye, P., Wyatt, J. (2006). Sophia. Emerg. Med. J. 23: 414-414 [Full text]  
• (2006). Hip Protectors Aren't All They're Cracked Up to Be. JWatch General 2006: 3-3 [Full text]  
• Nesbitt, K. (2006). Effectiveness of hip protectors: wider picture is important.. BMJ 332: 729-729 [Full text]  
• O'Halloran, P. D (2006). Effectiveness of hip protectors: it's more the effectiveness of compliance strategies.. BMJ 332: 729-729 [Full text]  
• de Rooij, S. E (2006). Hip protectors to prevent femoral fracture. BMJ 332: 559-560 [Full text]  

Rapid Responses:

Read all Rapid Responses

A chink in the armour?

Jonathan T McCrea
bmj.com, 10 Mar 2006 [Full text]

Ineffectiveness of hip protectors

David J Torgerson, et al.
bmj.com, 10 Mar 2006 [Full text]

Effectiveness of hip protectors or effectiveness of compliance strategies?

Nancy C. Edwards
bmj.com, 12 Mar 2006 [Full text]

hip fracture prevention

Kenneth Nesbitt
bmj.com, 13 Mar 2006 [Full text]

Hip Protectors in Care Homes Don't work in whole populations. The case in specific subgroups remains unproven. Critical Realism is required.

David Oliver, et al.
bmj.com, 14 Mar 2006 [Full text]

Re: Effectiveness of hip protectors or effectiveness of compliance strategies?

Peter D O'Halloran
bmj.com, 14 Mar 2006 [Full text]

Hip protectors may not be as ineffective as claimed

Pekka A Kannus
bmj.com, 15 Mar 2006 [Full text]

Hip protectors for prevention of hip fracture in the elderly: the importance of special attention to population subgroups

Anna M. Sawka, et al.
bmj.com, 21 Mar 2006 [Full text]

Hip protector effectiveness depends on biomechanical efficacy and user compliance

Stephen Robinovitch
bmj.com, 26 Mar 2006 [Full text]

New design – hip protectors on the road again

Gerold Holzer, et al.
bmj.com, 7 Apr 2006 [Full text]

Overcoming compliance issues with a "Stick-on" hip protector?

R Julian Minns, et al.
bmj.com, 8 Apr 2006 [Full text]

Re: Hip protectors may not be as ineffective as claimed

Peter D O'Halloran
bmj.com, 26 Apr 2006 [Full text]

Only biomechanically strong hip protectors have a chance to be clinically effective

Pekka A Kannus
bmj.com, 3 May 2006 [Full text]

Re: Only biomechanically strong hip protectors have a chance to be clinically effective

Peter D O'Halloran
bmj.com, 7 Jun 2006 [Full text]

Re: Re: Only biomechanically strong hip protectors have a chance to be clinically effective

Pekka A Kannus
bmj.com, 2 Sep 2006 [Full text]