BMJ 2002;325:870 ( 19 October )

Primary care

Screening and brief intervention for excessive alcohol use: qualitative interview study of the experiences of general practitioners

Anders Beich, research fellow, ^a Dorte Gannik, associate professor, ^a Kirsti Malterud, professor. ^b

^a Central Research Unit and Department of General Practice, University of Copenhagen, Panum Institute, DK-2200 Copenhagen, Denmark, ^b Section for General Practice, Department of Public Health and Primary Health Care, University of Bergen, Ulriksdal 8c, N-5009 Bergen, Norway

Correspondence to: Anders Beich a.beich{at}gpract.ku.dk

Objective: To explore the suitability of a screening based intervention for excessive alcohol use by describing the experiences of general practitioners who tried such an intervention in their everyday practice.
Design: Qualitative interviews with general practitioners who had participated in a pragmatic study of a combined programme of screening and a brief intervention for excessive alcohol use. Doctors were interviewed either individually or in focus groups. A computer based, descriptive, phenomenological method was used to directly analyse the digitally recorded interviews.
Setting and participants: 24 of 39 general practitioners in four Danish counties who volunteered to take part in the pragmatic study were interviewed.
Results: The doctors were surprised at how difficult it was to establish rapport with the patients who had a positive result on the screening and to ensure compliance with the intervention. Although the doctors considered the doctor-patient relationship robust enough to sustain targeting of alcohol use, they often failed to follow up on initial interventions, and some expressed a lack of confidence in their ability to counsel patients effectively on lifestyle issues. The doctors questioned the rationale of screening in young drinkers who may grow out of excessive drinking behaviour. The programme needed considerable resources, and it interrupted the natural course of consultations and was inflexible. The doctors could not recommend the screening and brief intervention programme, although they thought it important to counsel their patients on drinking.
Conclusions: Screening for excessive alcohol use created more problems than it solved for the participating doctors. The results underline the value of carrying out pragmatic studies on the suitability of seemingly efficacious healthcare programmes.

What is already known on this topic Efficacy studies have shown that in ideal conditions a brief intervention in primary care can lower alcohol consumption Health authorities recommend the implementation of screening for excessive alcohol use and a brief intervention to modify drinking behaviour, but such screening and brief intervention programmes have not yet proved to be successful What this study adds General practitioners who have tried a screening and brief intervention programme in their practice find the extra workload onerous and have problems in establishing rapport with excessive drinkers located by screening The programme disrupts normal patterns of work and cooperation in the general practice setting while failing to detect and deal with some problem drinkers

---

© BMJ 2002
CiteULike    Complore    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    StumbleUpon    Technorati    What's this?

Relevant Articles

Some screening is necessary to identify excessive drinkers early in primary care

Nick Heather, Peter Anderson, Antoni Gual, and Kaija Seppä
BMJ 2003 326: 550. [Extract] [Full Text]

General practitioner screening for excessive alcohol use

Stephen Rollnick, Jim McCambridge, Francis Keaney, John Strang, Stephen Rollnick, Robert Patton, and Robin Touquet
BMJ 2003 326: 336. [Extract] [Full Text]

GPs do not recommend screening for excessive alcohol use
BMJ 2002 325: 0. [Full Text]

Website of the week: Alcohol screening

Christopher Martyn
BMJ 2002 325: 910. [Full Text]

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Ruf, D., Berner, M., Kriston, L., Lohmann, M., Mundle, G., Lorenz, G., Niebling, W., Harter, M. (2009). Cluster-randomized Controlled Trial of Dissemination Strategies of an Online Quality Improvement Programme for Alcohol-related Disorders. Alcohol Alcohol 0: agp079v1-agp079 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Kool, B, Ameratunga, S, Jackson, R (2009). The role of alcohol in unintentional falls among young and middle-aged adults: a systematic review of epidemiological studies. Inj. Prev. 15: 341-347 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Broder, K. R., Cohn, A. C., Schwartz, B., Klein, J. D., Fisher, M. M., Fishbein, D. B., Mijalski, C., Burstein, G. R., Vernon-Smiley, M. E., McCauley, M. M., Wibbelsman, C. J., for the Working Group on Adolescent Prevention Pri, (2008). Adolescent Immunizations and Other Clinical Preventive Services: A Needle and a Hook?. Pediatrics 121: S25-S34 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Beich, A., Gannik, D., Saelan, H., Thorsen, T. (2007). Screening and brief intervention targeting risky drinkers in danish general practice A pragmatic controlled trial. Alcohol Alcohol 42: 593-603 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Berner, M. M., Harter, M., Kriston, L., Lohmann, M., Ruf, D., Lorenz, G., Mundle, G. (2007). Detection and management of alcohol use disorders in German primary care influenced by non-clinical factors. Alcohol Alcohol 42: 308-316 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Williams, E. C., Kivlahan, D. R., Saitz, R., Merrill, J. O., Achtmeyer, C. E., McCormick, K. A., Bradley, K. A. (2006). Readiness to Change in Primary Care Patients Who Screened Positive for Alcohol Misuse. Ann Fam Med 4: 213-220 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• VASILAKI, E. I., HOSIER, S. G., COX, W. M. (2006). THE EFFICACY OF MOTIVATIONAL INTERVIEWING AS A BRIEF INTERVENTION FOR EXCESSIVE DRINKING: A META-ANALYTIC REVIEW. Alcohol Alcohol 41: 328-335 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Johansson, K., Bendtsen, P., Akerlind, I. (2005). Advice to patients in Swedish primary care regarding alcohol and other lifestyle habits: how patients report the actions of GPs in relation to their own expectations and satisfaction with the consultation. Eur J Public Health 15: 615-620 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Christensen, K. S., Toft, T., Frostholm, L., Ornbol, E., Fink, P., Olesen, F. (2005). Screening for common mental disorders: who will benefit? Results from a randomised clinical trial. Fam Pract 22: 428-434 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Bertholet, N., Daeppen, J.-B., Wietlisbach, V., Fleming, M., Burnand, B. (2005). Reduction of Alcohol Consumption by Brief Alcohol Intervention in Primary Care: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Arch Intern Med 165: 986-995 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Jacobsen, E. T., Rasmussen, S. R., Christensen, M., Engberg, M., Lauritzen, T. (2005). Perspectives on lifestyle intervention: The views of general practitioners who have taken part in a health promotion study. Scand J Public Health 33: 4-10 [Abstract]  
• Moyer, V. A., Butler, M. (2004). Gaps in the Evidence for Well-Child Care: A Challenge to Our Profession. Pediatrics 114: 1511-1521 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• AALTO, M., SEPPA, K. (2004). USEFULNESS, LENGTH AND CONTENT OF ALCOHOL-RELATED DISCUSSIONS IN PRIMARY HEALTH CARE: THE EXIT POLL SURVEY. Alcohol Alcohol 39: 532-535 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• McCloud, A., Barnaby, B., Omu, N., Drummond, C., Aboud, A. (2004). Relationship between alcohol use disorders and suicidality in a psychiatric population: In-patient prevalence study. Br. J. Psychiatry 184: 439-445 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• McCambridge, J., Platts, S., Whooley, D., Strang, J. (2004). ENCOURAGING GP ALCOHOL INTERVENTION: PILOT STUDY OF CHANGE-ORIENTATED REFLECTIVE LISTENING (CORL). Alcohol Alcohol 39: 146-149 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Kypri, K., Saunders, J. B., Gallagher, S. J. (2003). ACCEPTABILITY OF VARIOUS BRIEF INTERVENTION APPROACHES FOR HAZARDOUS DRINKING AMONG UNIVERSITY STUDENTS. Alcohol Alcohol 38: 626-628 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Beich, A., Thorsen, T., Rollnick, S. (2003). Screening in brief intervention trials targeting excessive drinkers in general practice: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ 327: 536-542 [Abstract] [Full text]  
• Heather, N., Anderson, P., Gual, A., Seppa, K. (2003). Some screening is necessary to identify excessive drinkers early in primary care. BMJ 326: 550-550 [Full text]  
• Rollnick, S., McCambridge, J., Keaney, F., Strang, J., Rollnick, S., Patton, R., Touquet, R. (2003). General practitioner screening for excessive alcohol use. BMJ 326: 336-336 [Full text]  

Rapid Responses:

Read all Rapid Responses

Lifestyle advice

Pablo Millares
bmj.com, 18 Oct 2002 [Full text]

Conclusions do not take account of all the relevant data

Tim Lancaster
bmj.com, 21 Oct 2002 [Full text]

Re: Conclusions do not take account of all the relevant data

Anders Beich
bmj.com, 24 Oct 2002 [Full text]

Strange definition of excessive drinking

Adam Jacobs
bmj.com, 29 Oct 2002 [Full text]

Re: Strange definition of excessive drinking

Anders Beich
bmj.com, 4 Nov 2002 [Full text]

Talking about drink: Why GP experiences are important

Jim McCambridge, et al.
bmj.com, 8 Nov 2002 [Full text]

IMPLEMENTATION OF BRIEF ALCOHOL INTERVENTION DEPENDS ON THOROUGH PREPARATION AND PROPER TRAINING

Kaija Seppä, et al.
bmj.com, 13 Nov 2002 [Full text]

Re: Talking about drink: Why GP experiences are important

Anders Beich
bmj.com, 13 Nov 2002 [Full text]

Re: IMPLEMENTATION OF BRIEF ALCOHOL INTERVENTION DEPENDS ON THOROUGH PREPARATION AND PROPER TRAINING

Anders Beich, et al.
bmj.com, 18 Nov 2002 [Full text]

OPEN DEBATE ABOUT A COMPLEX INTERVENTION

Stephen Rollnick
bmj.com, 19 Nov 2002 [Full text]

Open mind on screening and brief alcohol intervention

Kaija Seppä, et al.
bmj.com, 23 Nov 2002 [Full text]

Re: Open mind on screening and brief alcohol intervention

Anders Beich
bmj.com, 1 Dec 2002 [Full text]

Online poll

Find out more >>