Editor's Choice | This Week in BMJ | Press releases




A young man slipped on ice on his garden path and landed heavily on a metal pipe used to support a plant in a pot. The pipe penetrated the chest wall at the anterior axillary fold, passed in front of the right clavicle, and entered the root of the neck. It passed behind the trachea and exited underneath the left ear. No major structure was damaged. The pipe was removed under general anaesthesia. The patient went home after 48 hours with only two small skin wounds to show for his injury.

R Mohammed, consultant surgeon, Queen Margaret Hospital, Dunfermline KY12 0SU

Submissions for this page should include the signed consent to publication from the patient



One factor in the increase in the numbers of patients with multidrug resistant tuberculosis is the poor quality of treatment - and its supervision - in the private sectors of countries of all levels of prosperity. An editorial in Chest (1997;111:1149-51) argues that the most effective solution is to persuade the manufacturers to remove from the market all single formulations of rifampicin, isoniazid, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol. Only combination products should be available for use.

Children with chronic renal insufficiency grow more slowly than normal, but this growth failure is now treatable. Long term studies have shown (Nephron 1997;76:125-9) that treatment with recombinant human growth hormone closes the gap in height and continues to do so while the treatment continues. Children treated for five years have shown no adverse effects.

Autologous blood transfusion ought to be entirely safe, but it has become so popular that the scale of the collection and distribution process makes errors inevitable. A study in Canada of 70,000 units collected (Transfusion 1997;37;523-7) showed that something went wrong in 279 cases: mostly late delivery of the blood to the operating theatre, blood sent to the wrong hospital, and so on. In one case a unit was transfused into the wrong recipient. Errors were most common when the blood was processed into components.

Treatment for carcinoma of the larynx causes functional, cosmetic, and psychological disability. Most patients say they would like a laryngeal transplant if that was possible. An editorial in the British Journal of Surgery (1997;84:739-40) reviews the revival of interest in transplantation, which is making progress in experiments on pigs. There is no immediate prospect of surgery on patients.

A small outbreak of rubella among British troops serving in Bosnia caused some alarm because of the 620 women among the personnel (Epidemiology and Infection 1997;118:253-7). One woman soldier who was pregnant was flown out of Bosnia as a precaution. Policymakers are now trying to decide whether all recruits to the armed forces should be immunised with measles-mumps-rubella vaccine whatever their vaccination status.

The Romans and the ancient Egyptians had names for wines suggesting that they believed that they induced abortion, but research publications give conflicting opinions on the effects of moderate drinking on the risk of miscarriage (Alcohol and Alcoholism 1997;32:211-9). Studies in the United States have mostly found an effect, while those in Europe and Australia have not. Confounders such as smoking make the topic more difficult; yet again the conclusion is that the published work is unsatisfactory and more, better research is needed.

Taking the contraceptive pill puts up the basal metabolic rate (British Journal of Nutrition 1997;77:827-31). A study of 24 women and 22 controls found that the women on the pill had metabolic rates 5% higher than the controls and slightly higher blood pressures; the differences persisted after the exclusion of women who took a lot of exercise.

The list of indications for treatment with botulinum toxin continues to lengthen. A double blind placebo controlled randomised trial of injections of the toxin in 14 children with hemiplegia from cerebral palsy appears in Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology (1997;39:185-93). Most patients showed a reduction in muscle tone, but the effects on function varied. The conclusion was that the treatment seems likely to be useful in selected patients.

A case report in the Journal of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh (1997;42:202-3) is a reminder that infection with Strongyloides stercoralis is one possibility in patients with persistent bloody diarrhoea: the patient described had been treated for ulcerative colitis for 14 years before the correct diagnosis was made.

The processes of Darwinian evolution may operate within a malignant tumour over a period of years, so that in time the tumour becomes more aggressive and invasive - as well as more resistant to treatment. A review in Cancer (1997;79:2275-81) makes these points and concludes that the earlier treatment can be started the softer the target for the oncologist - further reason for early diagnosis to be given high priority.

In developing countries hundreds of millions of farm workers and their families are exposed to pesticide chemicals that have been banned in the United States and Europe. A review in Health Policy and Planning (1997;12:97-106) says that many of these chemicals have been shown to have immunosuppressive actions in animals and may be expected to interfere with the immune systems of men and women who come into contact with them. Few developing countries have safety legislation to protect farm workers, and even fewer enforce such laws.

The big clinical trials of high dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow transplantation for metastatic breast cancer have not yet reported, but in the United States metastatic breast cancer is now the most common indication for autotransplantation. A review in JAMA (1997;277:1827-9) says it is too soon to know whether this treatment offers any real prospect of a cure, but conventional treatment for metastatic disease has so little to offer that women are choosing the option that gives them some hope.

The standard treatment for a fracture of the scaphoid is still immobilisation - which may need to be continued for 12 weeks or sometimes longer. Screw fixation was first tried more than 40 years ago; the technique has now been refined (Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 1997;77[Br]:418-21), and a minimally invasive percutaneous method is used, with a guidewire and an image intensifier. With this approach manual workers can be back at work in six weeks.


Home | Current issue | Past issues | Classified ads | Career Focus | Feedback
Collections | About this site | About the BMJ | BMA | Medline