Objective: To assess three prescribing
strategies for sore throat.
Design: Randomised follow up study.
Setting: 11 general practices in the South
and West region.
Subjects: 716 patients aged 4 years and
over with sore throat and an abnormal physical sign in the throat; 84%
had tonsillitis or pharyngitis. Patients were randomised to three
groups: prescription for antibiotics for 10 days (group 1, 246
patients); no prescription (group 2, 230 patients); or prescription for
antibiotics if symptoms were not starting to settle after three days
(group 3; 238 patients).
Main outcome measures: Duration of symptoms;
satisfaction and compliance with and perceived efficacy of antibiotics;
time off school or work. Outcomes were documented in 582 subjects
(81%).
Results: Median duration of antibiotic use differed
significantly in the three groups (10 v 0 v
0 days, P>0.001); 69% of patients in group 3 did not use
their prescription. The proportion of patients better by day 3 did not
differ significantly (37% v
35% v
30%,
P
=0.28), nor did the duration of illness (median 4 v
5
v
5 days, P
=0.39), days off work or school (median 2
v
2 v
1, P
=0.13), or proportion of
patients satisfied (96% v
90% v
93%,
P
=0.09), although group 1 had fewer days of fever (median 1
v
2 v
2 days, P
=0.04). More patients in
group 1 thought the antibiotics were effective (87% v
55% v
60%, P>0.001) and intended coming to the doctor
in future attacks (79% v
54% v
57%,
P>0.001). "Legitimation" of illness - to explain to work or school
(60%) or family or friends (37%) - was an important reason for
consultation. Patients who were more satisfied got better more quickly,
and satisfaction related strongly to how well the doctor dealt with
patient's concerns.
Conclusion: Prescribing antibiotics for sore throat
only marginally affects the resolution of symptoms but enhances belief
in antibiotics and intention to consult in future when compared with
the acceptable strategies of no prescription or delayed prescription.
Psychosocial factors are important in the decision to see a general
practitioner and in predicting the duration of illness.
Primary Medical Care,
Faculty of Health,
Medicine and Biological Sciences,
Aldermoor Health Centre,
Southampton
University,
Southampton SO16 5ST
P Little,
Wellcome training fellow
I Williamson,
senior lecturer in primary care
C
Gould, research assistant
M Gantley,
anthropologist
A L Kinmonth,
professor of primary medical care
Nightingale
Surgery,
Romsey,
Hampshire
G Warner, general
practitioner
Correspondence to: Dr
Little.